MC-219836Parity issue: White particles should appear when extinguished in powder snow/when defrosting on fire
This bug report is a parity issue with Bedrock.
Summary:
In the bedrock version, when extinguishing in powder snow or defrosting in fire (or lava), white particles appear, while in java only sound appears (and then only when extinguishing MC-219635)
Steps to reproduce:
When defrosting
- Place powder snow.
- Enter powder snow.
- Wait a while inside powder snow (to better see the defrosting effect).
- Set fire to a block nearby.
- Enter the fire.
When extinguishing
- Set fire to a block nearby.
- Enter the fire.
- Place powder snow.
- Enter powder snow.
Observed results:
No particles from the player will appear.
Expected results:
White particles will appear (to match the bedrock version).
Video:
Bedrock:
When defrosting 2021-03-15 15-28-56.mp4
When extinguishing 2021-03-15 15-28-58.mp4
Java:
When defrosting 2021-03-15 15-20-06.mp4
When extinguishing 2021-03-15 15-20-07.mp4
Linked Issues
MCPE-121240![[Mod] EVGENSYPERPRO](../../../data/avatars/users/92853.png){kind=small}
LowCreated Issue:
White particles should appear when extinguished in powder snow/when defrosting on fire (vanilla parity)
This bug report is a parity issue with Bedrock.
Summary:
In the bedrock version, when extinguishing in powder snow or defrosting in fire (or lava), white particles appear, while in java only sound appears (and then only when extinguishing
MC-219635)Steps to reproduce:
When defrosting
- Place powder snow.
- Enter powder snow.
- Wait a while inside powder snow (to better see the defrosting effect).
- Set fire to a block nearby.
- Enter the fire.
When extinguishing
- Set fire to a block nearby.
- Enter the fire.
- Place powder snow.
- Enter powder snow.
Observed results:
No particles from the player will appear.
Expected results:
White particles will appear (to match the bedrock version).
Video:
Bedrock:
When defrosting 2021-03-15 15-28-56.mp4
When extinguishing 2021-03-15 15-28-58.mp4
Java:
When defrosting 2021-03-15 15-20-06.mp4
When extinguishing 2021-03-15 15-20-07.mp4
![[Mod] violine1101](../../../data/avatars/users/92858.png){kind=small}
![[Mod] Michael Wobst](../../../data/avatars/users/37868.png){kind=small}
![[Mojang] Adrian Östergård](../../../data/assets/gravatar/nighter.jpeg){kind=small}
![[Helper] Johnibur](../../../data/avatars/users/28381.png){kind=small}
![[Mod] ampolive](../../../data/avatars/users/18949.svg){kind=small}
White particles should appear when extinguished in powder snow/when defrosting on fire(vanilla parity)Parity issue: White particles should appear when extinguished in powder snow/when defrosting on fire
![[Mojang] slicedlime](../../../data/assets/gravatar/slicedlime.jpeg){kind=small}
This bug report is a parity issue with Java.
Summary:
In the Java version, the particles from the destruction (from extinguishing the player) of the powder snow block are scattered in the same way (and in the same amount), as if the player had just broken powder snow.
In the bedrock version, when powder snow breaks down (from extinguishing the player), small amounts of particles simply remain on the surface.
Steps to reproduce:
- Place powder snow.
- For a better view, use a third person view.
- Set yourself on fire.
- Put out in powder snow.
- Place powder snow.
- Break down powder snow.
Observed results:
The particles from powder snow do not behave the same as if the player just broke powder snow.
Expected results:
The particles will fly out just like when the player breaks powder snow with his hand. To match the java version.
Notes:
Perhaps in the bedrock version this was done on purpose, since in the Java version there are no particles from the player MC-219836.
Video:
Java Minecraft 1.17.1 - 2021-08-15 19-05-09.mp4
Bedrock Minecraft 2021-08-15 19-09-41.mp4
Bedrock (slowmo) Produce_0.mp4
Bedrock report
MCPE-121240Can confirm in 21w13a.
still a problem in java version
Confirmed with 1.18.2 and 22w14a