MCPE-21304Tree falled - Planted saplings sometimes grow as fallen trees
Update by [Mojang] Mega_Spud (Jay Wells):
Summary:
Trees grown from saplings can sometimes grow as a fallen tree variant.
Steps to Reproduce:
- Start a new flat world
- Walk along and repeatedly use the command /fill ~ ~ ~ ~100 ~ ~ sapling to plant several rows of saplings
- Wait for the rows of saplings to grow (Increase random tick to speed up repro)
Observed Results:
Eventually some will generate as fallen trees, or just as a one block stump.
Expected Results:
Fallen trees should not grow from saplings.
Screenshots/Videos attached: Yes
Notes:
Original Description:
What the heck mojang..Is this supposed happend?? After a few min,It grow and falled..
Attachments1
Created Issue:
Tree falled
What the heck mojang..Is this supposed happend?? After a few min,It grow and falled..
Attachments1
![[MCPE Mod] Dr.Awesome4333](../../../data/assets/gravatar/drawesome4333.png){kind=small}
Thanks for the report, however this is working as intended. This is a MCPE feature where fallen trees can generate.
![[Mojang] Mega_Spud (Jay Wells)](../../../data/avatars/users/92696.png){kind=small}
![[Mod] bemoty](../../../data/avatars/users/50554.png){kind=small}
This is intended. Also see Tree#Fallen_trees.
Tree falledTree falled - Planted saplings sometimes grow as fallen trees
What the heck mojang..Is this supposed happend?? After a few min,It grow and falled..
Update by [Mojang] Mega_Spud (Jay Wells) :
Summary:
Trees grown from saplings can sometimes grow as a fallen tree variant.Steps to Reproduce:
- Start a new flat world
- Walk along and repeatedly use the command /fill ~ ~ ~ ~100 ~ ~ sapling to plant several rows of saplings
- Wait for the rows of saplings to grow (Increase random tick to speed up repro)
Observed Results:
Eventually some will generate as fallen trees, or just as a one block stump.Expected Results:
Fallen trees should not grow from saplings.Screenshots/Videos attached: Yes
Notes:
Original Description:
What the heck mojang..Is this supposed happend?? After a few min,It grow and falled..
![[Mod] OcelotOnesie](../../../data/avatars/users/43220.png){kind=small}
no longer appears in 1.16.40 with a sample of 2000+ saplings (probably fixed earlier)
Or this is exclusive feature??
Phraidyt you're right why would you want this gone.
It looks as though when the tree is spawning its selecting from the entire random list of spawned trees and not just the different height, normal, leafy trees.
Still Affect 1.1+
Happens with other tree types. Fallen trees generate from saplings, including saplings grown with bonemeal. Doesn't make sense for a tree to instantly grow into a fallen tree.
How about just make the growing of a tree not even have "fallen tree" as an option. This is very annoying for tree farms in that you dont get the sapplings. That is all i have to talk about for the bug. Now what would be cool if there were fallen trees with leaves still on them.
Lol that's funny.
It is intended for them to generate naturally, not from bonemeal
I haven't had any fallen trees "grow" in my tree farm lately, and I also tested growing a bunch with bonemeal, so it appears to be fixed, unless I've just been really lucky.
I've had fallen trees generate from bonemeal. It's rare, but it does happen. I regularly incorporate tree farms in my homesteads, so I don't have to travel so far for rarer woods like acacias and jungle. I've yet to spawn a fallen jungle tree, or giant spruce. Now THAT I would like to see. LOL
WAI
It's still occur in latest version.....I can't attach the picture bec my world so laggy.....but I still can confirm
iPad Pro 12.9” Gen 1 on iPadOS 13.4 with Minecraft 1.14.30.
Still exists on 1.14.30. Though I find that when it generates it only generates the stump not the whole fallen tree. Tested with Birch only though.