MC-121429effects_changed trigger does not trigger with instant_health, instant_damage, and saturation lingering, splash and drinkable potions
The bug
The advancement trigger for "effects_changed" seems to activate inconsistently when used in a custom advancement. "instant_damage", "instant_health", and "saturation" don't seem to trigger the advancement whenever the player:
- drinks a potion
- uses a splash potion
- uses a lingering potion
(However, the advancement DOES get triggered when the player uses a tipped arrow with the respective effect, or uses the /effect command to give the respective status effect)
How to reproduce
Create custom data pack(1.13 snapshot) OR place in the respective advancement folder (1.12.2)
{
"display": {
"title": "instant damage test",
"description": "",
"icon": {
"item": "minecraft:potion"
},
"background": "minecraft:textures/gui/advancements/backgrounds/stone.png",
"show_toast": true,
"announce_to_chat": true
},
"criteria": {
"instant_damage": {
"trigger": "minecraft:effects_changed",
"conditions": {
"effects": {
"minecraft:instant_damage": {
}
}
}
}
}
}
}
(replacing the "effects" conditions with the respective status effect)
Then using a potion (drinking, slash, or lingering) with the assigned status effects.
I've included a world download with advancements and potions already made and ready to use.
Linked Issues
Attachments1
Created Issue:
ADVANCEMENT TRIGGER BROKEN- effects_changed trigger gives inconsistent results with instant_health, instant_damage, and saturation
The advancement trigger for "effects_changed" seems to activate inconsistently when used in a custom advancement. "instant_damage", "instant_health", and "saturation" don't seem to trigger the advancement whenever the player:
drinks a potion
uses a splash potion
uses a lingering potion
(However, the advancement DOES get triggered when the player uses a tipped arrow with the respective effect, or uses the /effect command to give the respective status effect)
How to replicate:
create custom data pack(1.13 snapshot) OR place in the respective advancement folder (1.12.2){ "display": { "title": "instant damage test", "description": "", "icon": { "item": "minecraft:potion" }, "background": "minecraft:textures/gui/advancements/backgrounds/stone.png", "show_toast": true, "announce_to_chat": true }, "criteria": { "instant_damage": { "trigger": "minecraft:effects_changed", "conditions": { "effects": { "minecraft:instant_damage": { } } } } } } }(replacing the "effects" conditions with the respective status effect)
Then using a potion (drinking, slash, or lingering) with the assigned status effects.I've included a world download with advancements and potions already made and ready to use.
Attachments1
ADVANCEMENT TRIGGER BROKEN-effects_changed trigger gives inconsistent results with instant_health, instant_damage, and saturation
![[Bot] Arisa](../../../data/assets/gravatar/mustek2.png){kind=small}
effects_changed triggergives inconsistent resultswith instant_health, instant_damage, and saturationeffects_changed trigger does not trigger with instant_health, instant_damage, and saturation lingering, splash and srinkable potions
effects_changed trigger does not trigger with instant_health, instant_damage, and saturation lingering, splash andsrinkable potionseffects_changed trigger does not trigger with instant_health, instant_damage, and saturation lingering, splash and drinkable potions
![[Mod] Pokechu22](../../../data/avatars/users/92931.png){kind=small}
relates to
The advancement trigger for "effects_changed" seems to activate inconsistently when used in a custom advancement. "instant_damage", "instant_health", and "saturation" don't seem to trigger the advancement whenever the player:
drinks a potion
uses a splash potion
uses a lingering potion
(However, the advancement DOES get triggered when the player uses a tipped arrow with the respective effect, or uses the /effect command to give the respective status effect)
How to replicate:
create custom data pack(1.13 snapshot) OR place in the respective advancement folder (1.12.2){ "display": { "title": "instant damage test", "description": "", "icon": { "item": "minecraft:potion" }, "background": "minecraft:textures/gui/advancements/backgrounds/stone.png", "show_toast": true, "announce_to_chat": true }, "criteria": { "instant_damage": { "trigger": "minecraft:effects_changed", "conditions": { "effects": { "minecraft:instant_damage": { } } } } } } }(replacing the "effects" conditions with the respective status effect)
Then using a potion (drinking, slash, or lingering) with the assigned status effects.I've included a world download with advancements and potions already made and ready to use.
The Bug:
The advancement trigger for "effects_changed" seems to activate inconsistently when used in a custom advancement. "instant_damage", "instant_health", and "saturation" don't seem to trigger the advancement whenever the player:
drinks a potion
uses a splash potion
uses a lingering potion
(However, the advancement DOES get triggered when the player uses a tipped arrow with the respective effect, or uses the /effect command to give the respective status effect)How to replicate:
create custom data pack(1.13 snapshot) OR place in the respective advancement folder (1.12.2)
{ "display": { "title": "instant damage test", "description": "", "icon": { "item": "minecraft:potion" }, "background": "minecraft:textures/gui/advancements/backgrounds/stone.png", "show_toast": true, "announce_to_chat": true }, "criteria": { "instant_damage": { "trigger": "minecraft:effects_changed", "conditions": { "effects": { "minecraft:instant_damage": { } } } } } } }(replacing the "effects" conditions with the respective status effect)
Then using a potion (drinking, slash, or lingering) with the assigned status effects.I've included a world download with advancements and potions already made and ready to use.
![[Mod] tryashtar](../../../data/avatars/users/41963.png){kind=small}
![[Mod] redstonehelper](../../../data/avatars/users/10122.svg){kind=small}
![[Mod] Michael Wobst](../../../data/avatars/users/37868.png){kind=small}
The
Bug:The advancement trigger for "effects_changed" seems to activate inconsistently when used in a custom advancement. "instant_damage", "instant_health", and "saturation" don't seem to trigger the advancement whenever the player:
drinks a potion
uses a splash potion
uses a lingering potion
(However, the advancement DOES get triggered when the player uses a tipped arrow with the respective effect, or uses the /effect command to give the respective status effect)How to rep
licate:
create custom data pack(1.13 snapshot) OR place in the respective advancement folder (1.12.2){ "display": { "title": "instant damage test", "description": "", "icon": { "item": "minecraft:potion" }, "background": "minecraft:textures/gui/advancements/backgrounds/stone.png", "show_toast": true, "announce_to_chat": true }, "criteria": { "instant_damage": { "trigger": "minecraft:effects_changed", "conditions": { "effects": { "minecraft:instant_damage": { } } } } } } }(replacing the "effects" conditions with the respective status effect)
Then using a potion (drinking, slash, or lingering) with the assigned status effects.I've included a world download with advancements and potions already made and ready to use.
The bug
The advancement trigger for "effects_changed" seems to activate inconsistently when used in a custom advancement. "instant_damage", "instant_health", and "saturation" don't seem to trigger the advancement whenever the player:
- drinks a potion
- uses a splash potion
- uses a lingering potion
(However, the advancement DOES get triggered when the player uses a tipped arrow with the respective effect, or uses the /effect command to give the respective status effect)How to reproduce
Create custom data pack(1.13 snapshot) OR place in the respective advancement folder (1.12.2)
{ "display": { "title": "instant damage test", "description": "", "icon": { "item": "minecraft:potion" }, "background": "minecraft:textures/gui/advancements/backgrounds/stone.png", "show_toast": true, "announce_to_chat": true }, "criteria": { "instant_damage": { "trigger": "minecraft:effects_changed", "conditions": { "effects": { "minecraft:instant_damage": { } } } } } } }(replacing the "effects" conditions with the respective status effect)
Then using a potion (drinking, slash, or lingering) with the assigned status effects.I've included a world download with advancements and potions already made and ready to use.
The bug
The advancement trigger for "effects_changed" seems to activate inconsistently when used in a custom advancement. "instant_damage", "instant_health", and "saturation" don't seem to trigger the advancement whenever the player:
- drinks a potion
- uses a splash potion
- uses a lingering potion
(However, the advancement DOES get triggered when the player uses a tipped arrow with the respective effect, or uses the /effect command to give the respective status effect)How to reproduce
Create custom data pack(1.13 snapshot) OR place in the respective advancement folder (1.12.2)
{ "display": { "title": "instant damage test", "description": "", "icon": { "item": "minecraft:potion" }, "background": "minecraft:textures/gui/advancements/backgrounds/stone.png", "show_toast": true, "announce_to_chat": true }, "criteria": { "instant_damage": { "trigger": "minecraft:effects_changed", "conditions": { "effects": { "minecraft:instant_damage": { } } } } } } }(replacing the "effects" conditions with the respective status effect)
Then using a potion (drinking, slash, or lingering) with the assigned status effects.I've included a world download with advancements and potions already made and ready to use.
The bug
The advancement trigger for "effects_changed" seems to activate inconsistently when used in a custom advancement. "instant_damage", "instant_health", and "saturation" don't seem to trigger the advancement whenever the player:
- drinks a potion
- uses a splash potion
- uses a lingering potion
(However, the advancement DOES get triggered when the player uses a tipped arrow with the respective effect, or uses the /effect command to give the respective status effect)
How to reproduce
Create custom data pack(1.13 snapshot) OR place in the respective advancement folder (1.12.2)
{ "display": { "title": "instant damage test", "description": "", "icon": { "item": "minecraft:potion" }, "background": "minecraft:textures/gui/advancements/backgrounds/stone.png", "show_toast": true, "announce_to_chat": true }, "criteria": { "instant_damage": { "trigger": "minecraft:effects_changed", "conditions": { "effects": { "minecraft:instant_damage": { } } } } } } }(replacing the "effects" conditions with the respective status effect)
Then using a potion (drinking, slash, or lingering) with the assigned status effects.I've included a world download with advancements and potions already made and ready to use.
![[Mojang] Nathan Adams](../../../data/assets/gravatar/dinnerbone.png){kind=small}
is duplicated by
![[Bot] Arisa](../../../data/avatars/users/43007.png){kind=small}
![[Mod] Jarl-Penguin](../../../data/avatars/users/92849.png){kind=small}
is duplicated by
Confirmed for 17w50a.
Seems to be somehow related to MC-121429 and how Minecraft processes instant effects in potions.
Thank you for your report!
We're tracking this issue in MC-121429, so this ticket is being resolved and linked as a duplicate.
If you would like to add a vote and any extra information to the main ticket it would be appreciated.
If you haven't already, you might like to make use of the search feature to see if the issue has already been mentioned.
Quick Links:
📓 Bug Tracker Guidelines – 💬 Community Support – 📧 Mojang Support
📓 Project Summary – ✍️ Feedback and Suggestions – 📖 Game Wiki
– I am a bot. This action was performed automatically! The ticket was resolved by one of our moderators, and I left this message to give more information to you.
![[Mod] Jiingy](../../../data/avatars/users/91802.png){kind=small}
This issue is alerady mostly covered in MC-121429, I would suggest resolving this as a duplicate, and update the other to include this information seeing as it's already a fairly broad report.
Thank you for your report!
We're tracking this issue in MC-121429, so this ticket is being resolved and linked as a duplicate.
If you would like to add a vote and any extra information to the main ticket it would be appreciated.
If you haven't already, you might like to make use of the search feature to see if the issue has already been mentioned.
Quick Links:
📓 Bug Tracker Guidelines – 💬 Community Support – 📧 Mojang Support (Technical Issues) – 📧 Microsoft Support (Account Issues)
📓 Project Summary – ✍️ Feedback and Suggestions – 📖 Game Wiki
I should also mention that the "saturation" effect doesn't seem to be working properly for potions, splash potions, and lingering potions?
What is the command you used to give the effect?
Here are the commands used:
Successfully triggers advancements
Successfully triggers advancements
Successfully triggers advancements
Shooting an "Arrow of Healing" at the player Successfully triggers advancements
Shooting an "Arrow of Harming" at the player Successfully triggers advancements
Shooting an "Arrow of Healing" at the player Successfully triggers advancements
Shooting a "tipped_arrow" with the "saturation" effect using
/give @p minecraft:tipped_arrow 1 0 {Potion:"minecraft:water",CustomPotionEffects:[{Id:23}],display:{Name:"Custom Potion"}}at a player Successfully triggers advancements
Drinking a "Potion of Healing" does not trigger advancements
Drinking a "Potion of Harming" does not trigger advancements
Drinking a "custom potion" with the command
/give @p minecraft:potion 1 0 {Potion:"minecraft:water",CustomPotionEffects:[{Id:23}]}does not trigger advancements
Throwing a "Splash Potion of Healing" at a player does not trigger advancements
Throwing a "Splash Potion of Harming" at a player does not trigger advancements
Throwing a "custom potion" with the command
/give @p minecraft:splash_potion 1 0 {Potion:"minecraft:water",CustomPotionEffects:[{Id:23}]}does not trigger advancements
Please stay away from the caps lock key.
I asked for the command with a reasoning, as these potions apply for 1 tick, but the command can apply it for more than 1 tick. If it did work > 1 tick but not with = 1 tick, then the bug would be simple: 1 tick effects not detected, while now (since it works for = 1 tick) the problem lies solely in the potions, which basically do the same as the command.
Throwing a "Lingering Potion of Healing" at a player does not trigger advancements
Throwing a "Lingering Potion of Harming" at a player does not trigger advancements
Throwing a "custom potion" with the command
/give @p minecraft:lingering_potion 1 0 {Potion:"minecraft:water",CustomPotionEffects:[{Id:23}]}does not trigger advancements
I'm very sorry if I was unclear earlier! Please let me know if I can do anything else to help specify the issue.
My mistake! Very sorry about that! I've given the commands that I have used.
Regarding saturation potions:
MC-25866.Still affects 18w05a, please update!
Still affects 18w09a.