MC-214664Plants in flower pots are shaded differently from when normally placed
When plants are placed by themselves, no shading is applied to them. However, if that very same plant is instead placed inside a flower pot, it suddenly gains shading, which is nonsensical and obviously inconsistent.
Which behaviour is intended is not known, as the evidence is contradictory - the fixing of MC-57159 implies that there not being shading is what is intended, but the resolution of MC-68302 goes directly against that by saying the exact opposite.
As the behaviour in 1.7 and prior was to apply shading to neither, this is what the attached fix pack will do.
This is also a parity issue, as neither are shaded in Bedrock Edition.
Linked Issues
LowCreated Issue:
Plants in flower pots are shaded differently from when normally placed
Closely relates to
MC-214662.When plants are placed by themselves, no shading is applied to them. However, if that very same plant is instead placed inside a flower pot, it suddenly gains shading, which is nonsensical and obviously inconsistent.
Which behaviour is intended is not known, as the evidence is contradictory - the fixing of
MC-57159implies that there not being shading is what is intended, but the resolution ofMC-68302goes directly against that by saying the exact opposite.As the behaviour in 1.7 and prior was to apply shading to neither, this is what the attached fix pack will do.
Attachments3
Closely relates to
MC-214662.When plants are placed by themselves, no shading is applied to them. However, if that very same plant is instead placed inside a flower pot, it suddenly gains shading, which is nonsensical and obviously inconsistent.
Which behaviour is intended is not known, as the evidence is contradictory - the fixing of
MC-57159implies that there not being shading is what is intended, but the resolution ofMC-68302goes directly against that by saying the exact opposite.As the behaviour in 1.7 and prior was to apply shading to neither, this is what the attached fix pack will do.
This is also a parity issue, as neither are shaded in Bedrock Edition.
![[Mojang] slicedlime](../../../data/assets/gravatar/slicedlime.jpeg){kind=small}
![[Mod] Michael Wobst](../../../data/avatars/users/37868.png){kind=small}
![[Mod] Chandler](../../../data/assets/gravatar/triwonder81.png){kind=small}
Closely relates to
MC-214662.When plants are placed by themselves, no shading is applied to them. However, if that very same plant is instead placed inside a flower pot, it suddenly gains shading, which is nonsensical and obviously inconsistent.
Which behaviour is intended is not known, as the evidence is contradictory - the fixing of
MC-57159implies that there not being shading is what is intended, but the resolution ofMC-68302goes directly against that by saying the exact opposite.As the behaviour in 1.7 and prior was to apply shading to neither, this is what the attached fix pack will do.
This is also a parity issue, as neither are shaded in Bedrock Edition.
Can confirm
Can confirm in 21w06a.
Can confirm in 21w07a.
Duplicates
MC-129826