MC-68302Some 2D blocks models are shaded incorrectly
The bug
Since snapshot 14w25b, all 2D plants in Flower Pot, Pumpkin and Melon Stem, Mushrooms on Red and Brown Mooshroms, Redstone Repeater torch and Comparator torch models are shaded, making their textures to look darker than normal.
Fixed Resource Packs for each one (except for both Mooshrooms) can be found attached.
Linked Issues
is duplicated by4
Attachments23
- Works As Intended
Mega611- 26
- 15
- Confirmed
- Lighting Rendering Textures and models
- block block-entity-model block-model entity-model item redstone rendering texture
14w33c - 1.16.2
14w33c 14w34a 14w34b 14w34c 14w34d 1.8-pre1 1.8-pre2 1.8-pre3 1.8 1.8.1-pre1 1.8.1-pre2 1.8.1-pre3 1.8.1-pre4 1.8.1-pre5 1.8.1 1.8.2-pre1 1.8.2-pre2 1.8.2-pre3 1.8.2-pre4 1.8.2-pre5 1.8.2-pre6 1.8.2-pre7 1.8.2 1.8.3 1.8.4 1.8.5 1.8.6 1.8.7 1.8.8 15w31a 15w33a 15w33b 15w34a 15w34b 15w34c 15w34d 15w35d 15w35e 15w36b 15w36c 15w36d 15w37a 15w38a 15w38b 15w39b 15w39c 15w40a 15w40b 15w41b 15w42a 15w43c 15w44b 15w45a 15w46a 15w47a 15w47b 15w47c 15w49a 15w49b 1.8.9 15w50a 1.9-pre1 1.9-pre2 1.9.4 1.10 1.10.2 16w43a 16w44a 1.13.1 19w13a 1.14.4 19w45b 1.15-pre3 1.15.2 20w14a 20w15a 20w17a 20w19a 20w21a 20w22a 1.16-pre1 1.16-pre3 1.16-pre4 1.16-pre5 1.16-pre6 1.16-pre7 1.16-pre8 1.16-rc1 1.16 1.16.1 20w28a 1.16.2-pre1 1.16.2-pre3 1.16.2-rc2 1.16.2
Created Issue:
Redstone repeater torch and comparator torch texture are darker.
From snapshot 14w25b to snapshot 14w33c redstone repeater torch and comparator torch texture are darker.
Bug is still in snapshot 14w25b, 14w26c, 14w27b, 14w28b, 14w29b, 14w30c, 14w31a, 14w32d, 14w33c and 14w34c.Environment
OS: Windows 7 , 64 bit Build 7601 Service Pack 1
CPU:total 4 (4 cores per cpu, 1 threads per core) family 6 model 58 stepping 9, cmov, cx8, fxsr, mmx, sse, sse2, sse3, ssse3, sse4.1, sse4.2, popcnt, avx, aes, erms, tsc, tscinvbit, tscinv
Memory: 4k page, physical 8348784k(1986892k free), swap 16695704k(8473172k free)
vm_info: Java HotSpot(TM) 64-Bit Server VM (24.65-b04) for windows-amd64 JRE (1.7.0_65-b20), built on Jul 11 2014 00:39:37 by "java_re" with unknown MS VC++:1600
Attachments6
2014-08-19_21.27.55.png
duplicates
relates to
duplicates
This yes OK
Still a dupe... of
MC-67830
From snapshot 14w25b to snapshot 14w33c redstone repeater torch and comparator torch texture are darker.
Bug is still in snapshot 14w25b, 14w26c, 14w27b, 14w28b, 14w29b, 14w30c, 14w31a, 14w32d, 14w33c and 14w34c.From snapshot 14w25b to snapshot 14w33c redstone repeater torch and comparator torch texture are darker.
Bug is still in snapshot 14w25b, 14w26c, 14w27b, 14w28b, 14w29b, 14w30c, 14w31a, 14w32d, 14w33c and 14w34d.
Redstone repeater torch and comparator torch texture are darker.Tripwire hook, lever, redstone repeater torch and comparator torch texture are darker.
From snapshot 14w25b to snapshot 14w33c tripwire hook, lever, redstone repeater torch and comparator torch texture are darker.
Bug is still in snapshot 14w25b, 14w26c, 14w27b, 14w28b, 14w29b, 14w30c, 14w31a, 14w32d, 14w33c and 14w34d.
Tripwire hook, lever, redstone repeater torch and comparator torch texture are darker.Iron bars, tripwire hook, lever, redstone repeater torch and comparator torch texture are darker.
From snapshot 14w25b to snapshot 14w3
3ctripwire hook, lever, redstone repeater torch and comparator torch texture are darker.
Bug is still in snapshot 14w25b, 14w26c, 14w27b, 14w28b, 14w29b, 14w30c, 14w31a, 14w32d, 14w33c and 14w34d.From snapshot 14w25b to snapshot 14w34d iron bars, tripwire hook, lever, redstone repeater torch and comparator torch texture are darker.
Bug is still in snapshot 14w25b, 14w26c, 14w27b, 14w28b, 14w29b, 14w30c, 14w31a, 14w32d, 14w33c and 14w34d.
Iron bars, tripwire hook, lever, redstone repeater torch and comparator torch texture are darker.Bed, iron bars, tripwire hook, lever, redstone repeater torch and comparator torch texture are darker.
From snapshot 14w25b to snapshot 14w34d bed, iron bars, tripwire hook, lever, redstone repeater torch and comparator torch texture are darker.
Bug is still in snapshot 14w25b, 14w26c, 14w27b, 14w28b, 14w29b, 14w30c, 14w31a, 14w32d, 14w33c and 14w34d.
From snapshot 14w25b to snapshot 1
4w34dbed, iron bars, tripwire hook, lever, redstone repeater torch and comparator torch texture are darker.
Bug is still in snapshot 14w25b, 14w26c, 14w27b, 14w28b, 14w29b, 14w30c, 14w31a, 14w32d, 14w33cand14w34d.From snapshot 14w25b to snapshot 1.8-pre1 bed, iron bars, tripwire hook, lever, redstone repeater torch and comparator torch texture are darker.
Bug is still in snapshot 14w25b, 14w26c, 14w27b, 14w28b, 14w29b, 14w30c, 14w31a, 14w32d, 14w33c, 14w34d and 1.8-pre1.
From snapshot 14w25b to
snapshot1.8-pre1bed, iron bars, tripwire hook, lever, redstone repeater torch and comparator torch texture are darker.
Bug is still in snapshot 14w25b, 14w26c, 14w27b, 14w28b, 14w29b, 14w30c, 14w31a, 14w32d, 14w33c, 14w34d and 1.8-pre1.From snapshot 14w25b to pre-release 1.8-pre2 bed, iron bars, tripwire hook, lever, redstone repeater torch and comparator torch texture are darker.
Bug is still in snapshot 14w25b, 14w26c, 14w27b, 14w28b, 14w29b, 14w30c, 14w31a, 14w32d, 14w33c, 14w34d, 1.8-pre1 and 1.8-pre2.
Bed, iron bars, tripwire hook, lever, redstone repeater torch and comparator torch texture are darker.Pumpkin and melon stem, bed, iron bars, tripwire hook, lever, redstone repeater torch and comparator torch texture are darker.
From snapshot 14w25b to pre-release 1.8-pre2 pumpkin and melon stem, bed, iron bars, tripwire hook, lever, redstone repeater torch and comparator torch texture are darker.
Bug is still in snapshot 14w25b, 14w26c, 14w27b, 14w28b, 14w29b, 14w30c, 14w31a, 14w32d, 14w33c, 14w34d, 1.8-pre1 and 1.8-pre2.
Pumpkin and melon stem, bed, iron bars, tripwire hook, lever, redstone repeater torch and comparator torch texture are darker.Brewing stand, item in flower pot, pumpkin and melon stem, bed, iron bars, tripwire hook, lever, redstone repeater torch and comparator torch texture are darker.
From snapshot 14w25b to pre-release 1.8-pre
2pumpkin and melon stem, bed, iron bars, tripwire hook, lever, redstone repeater torch and comparator torch texture are darker.
Bug is still in snapshot 14w25b, 14w26c, 14w27b, 14w28b, 14w29b, 14w30c, 14w31a, 14w32d, 14w33c, 14w34d, 1.8-pre1 and 1.8-pre2.From snapshot 14w25b to pre-release 1.8-pre3 brewing stand, item in flower pot, pumpkin and melon stem, bed, iron bars, tripwire hook, lever, redstone repeater torch and comparator torch texture are darker.
Bug is still in snapshot 14w25b, 14w26c, 14w27b, 14w28b, 14w29b, 14w30c, 14w31a, 14w32d, 14w33c, 14w34d, 1.8-pre1, 1.8-pre2 and 1.8-pre3.
From snapshot 14w25b to
pre-release 1.8-pre3brewing stand, item in flower pot, pumpkin and melon stem, bed, iron bars, tripwire hook, lever, redstone repeater torch and comparator torch texture are darker.
Bug is still in snapshot 14w25b, 14w26c, 14w27b, 14w28b, 14w29b, 14w30c, 14w31a, 14w32d, 14w33c, 14w34d, 1.8-pre1, 1.8-pre2and1.8-pre3.From snapshot 14w25b to release 1.8 brewing stand, item in flower pot, pumpkin and melon stem, bed, iron bars, tripwire hook, lever, redstone repeater torch and comparator torch texture are darker.
Bug is still in snapshot 14w25b, 14w26c, 14w27b, 14w28b, 14w29b, 14w30c, 14w31a, 14w32d, 14w33c, 14w34d, 1.8-pre1, 1.8-pre2, 1.8-pre3 and release 1.8.
From snapshot 14w25b to release 1.8 brewing stand, item in flower pot, pumpkin and melon stem, bed, iron bars, tripwire hook, lever, redstone repeater torch and comparator torch texture are darker.
Bug is still in snapshot 14w25b, 14w26c, 14w27b, 14w28b, 14w29b, 14w30c, 14w31a, 14w32d, 14w33c, 14w34d, 1.8-pre1, 1.8-pre2, 1.8-pre3andrelease 1.8.From snapshot 14w25b to release 1.8 brewing stand, item in flower pot, pumpkin and melon stem, bed, iron bars, tripwire hook, lever, redstone repeater torch and comparator torch texture are darker.
Bug is still in snapshot 14w25b, 14w26c, 14w27b, 14w28b, 14w29b, 14w30c, 14w31a, 14w32d, 14w33c, 14w34d, 1.8-pre1, 1.8-pre2, 1.8-pre3, release 1.8 and 1.8.1-pre1.
From snapshot 14w25b to release 1.8 brewing stand, item in flower pot, pumpkin and melon stem, bed, iron bars, tripwire hook, lever, redstone repeater torch and comparator torch texture are darker.
Bug is still in snapshot 14w25b, 14w26c, 14w27b, 14w28b, 14w29b, 14w30c, 14w31a, 14w32d, 14w33c, 14w34d, 1.8-pre1, 1.8-pre2, 1.8-pre3, release 1.8 and 1.8.1-pre1.From snapshot 14w25b to release 1.8 brewing stand, item in flower pot, pumpkin and melon stem, bed, iron bars, tripwire hook, lever, redstone repeater torch and comparator torch texture are darker.
Bug is still in snapshot 14w25b, 14w26c, 14w27b, 14w28b, 14w29b, 14w30c, 14w31a, 14w32d, 14w33c, 14w34d, 1.8-pre1, 1.8-pre2, 1.8-pre3, release 1.8, 1.8.1-pre1 and 1.8.1-pre2.
From snapshot 14w25b to release 1.8 brewing stand, item in flower pot, pumpkin and melon stem, bed, iron bars, tripwire hook, lever, redstone repeater torch and comparator torch texture are darker.
Bug is still in snapshot 14w25b, 14w26c, 14w27b, 14w28b, 14w29b, 14w30c, 14w31a, 14w32d, 14w33c, 14w34d, 1.8-pre1, 1.8-pre2, 1.8-pre3, release 1.8, 1.8.1-pre1 and 1.8.1-pre2.From snapshot 14w25b to release 1.8 brewing stand, item in flower pot, pumpkin and melon stem, bed, iron bars, tripwire hook, lever, redstone repeater torch and comparator torch texture are darker.
From snapshot 14w25b to pre-release 3 of 1.8.1 brewing stand, item in flower pot, pumpkin and melon stem, bed, iron bars, tripwire hook, lever, redstone repeater torch and comparator torch texture are darker.
From snapshot 14w25b to pre-release
3of 1.8.1 brewing stand, item in flower pot, pumpkin and melon stem, bed, iron bars, tripwire hook, lever, redstone repeater torch and comparator torch texture are darker.From snapshot 14w25b to pre-release 4 of 1.8.1 brewing stand, item in flower pot, pumpkin and melon stem, bed, iron bars, tripwire hook, lever, redstone repeater torch and comparator torch texture are darker.
From snapshot 14w25b to pre-release
4of 1.8.1 brewing stand, item in flower pot, pumpkin and melon stem, bed, iron bars, tripwire hook, lever, redstone repeater torch and comparator torch texture are darker.From snapshot 14w25b to pre-release 5 of 1.8.1 brewing stand, item in flower pot, pumpkin and melon stem, bed, iron bars, tripwire hook, lever, redstone repeater torch and comparator torch texture are darker.
From snapshot 14w25b to
pre-release 5 of1.8.1 brewing stand, item in flower pot, pumpkin and melon stem, bed, iron bars, tripwire hook, lever, redstone repeater torch and comparator torch texture are darker.
From snapshot 14w25b to 1.8.2-pre1 brewing stand, item in flower pot, pumpkin and melon stem, bed, iron bars, tripwire hook, lever, redstone repeater torch and comparator torch texture are darker.
From snapshot 14w25b to 1.8.2-pre
1brewing stand, item in flower pot, pumpkin and melon stem, bed, iron bars, tripwire hook, lever, redstone repeater torch and comparator torch texture are darker.From snapshot 14w25b to 1.8.2-pre4 brewing stand, item in flower pot, pumpkin and melon stem, bed, iron bars, tripwire hook, lever, redstone repeater torch and comparator torch texture are darker.
From snapshot 14w25b to 1.8.2-pre
4brewing stand, item in flower pot, pumpkin and melon stem, bed, iron bars, tripwire hook, lever, redstone repeater torch and comparator torch texture are darker.From snapshot 14w25b to 1.8.2-pre6 brewing stand, item in flower pot, pumpkin and melon stem, bed, iron bars, tripwire hook, lever, redstone repeater torch and comparator torch texture are darker.
From snapshot 14w25b to 1.8.2
-pre6brewing stand, item in flower pot, pumpkin and melon stem, bed, iron bars, tripwire hook, lever, redstone repeater torch and comparator torch texture are darker.
From snapshot 14w25b to 1.8.
2brewing stand, item in flower pot, pumpkin and melon stem, bed, iron bars, tripwire hook, lever, redstone repeater torch and comparator torch texture are darker.From snapshot 14w25b to 1.8.3 brewing stand, item in flower pot, pumpkin and melon stem, bed, iron bars, tripwire hook, lever, redstone repeater torch and comparator torch texture are darker.
From snapshot 14w25b to 1.8.
3brewing stand, item in flower pot, pumpkin and melon stem, bed, iron bars, tripwire hook, lever, redstone repeater torch and comparator torch texture are darker.From snapshot 14w25b to 1.8.7 brewing stand, item in flower pot, pumpkin and melon stem, bed, iron bars, tripwire hook, lever, redstone repeater torch and comparator torch texture are darker.
From snapshot 14w25b to 1
.8.7brewing stand, item in flower pot, pumpkin and melon stem, bed, iron bars, tripwire hook, lever, redstone repeater torch and comparator torch texture are darker.From snapshot 14w25b to 15w40b brewing stand, item in flower pot, pumpkin and melon stem, bed, iron bars, tripwire hook, lever, redstone repeater torch and comparator torch texture are darker.
From snapshot 14w25b to 15w4
0bbrewing stand, item in flower pot, pumpkin and melon stem, bed, iron bars, tripwire hook, lever, redstone repeater torch and comparator torch texture are darker.From snapshot 14w25b to 15w42a brewing stand, item in flower pot, pumpkin and melon stem, bed, iron bars, tripwire hook, lever, redstone repeater torch and comparator torch texture are darker.
From snapshot 14w25b to 15w4
2abrewing stand, item in flower pot, pumpkin and melon stem, bed, iron bars, tripwire hook, lever, redstone repeater torch and comparator torch texture are darker.From snapshot 14w25b to 15w43c brewing stand, item in flower pot, pumpkin and melon stem, bed, iron bars, tripwire hook, lever, redstone repeater torch and comparator torch texture are darker.
From snapshot 14w25b to 15w4
3c brewing stand, item in flower pot, pumpkin and melon stem, bed, iron bars, tripwire hook, lever, redstone repeater torch and comparator torch texture are darker.From snapshot 14w25b to 15w47c brewing stand, item in flower pot, pumpkin and melon stem, bed, iron bars, tripwire hook, lever, redstone repeater torch and comparator torch texture are darker.
From snapshot 14w25b to 15w
47cbrewing stand, item in flower pot, pumpkin and melon stem, bed, iron bars, tripwire hook, lever, redstone repeater torch and comparator torch texture are darker.From snapshot 14w25b to 15w50a brewing stand, item in flower pot, pumpkin and melon stem, bed, iron bars, tripwire hook, lever, redstone repeater torch and comparator torch texture are darker.
From snapshot 14w25b to 1
5w50abrewing stand, item in flower pot, pumpkin and melon stem, bed, iron bars, tripwire hook, lever, redstone repeater torch and comparator torch texture are darker.From snapshot 14w25b to 1.9-pre2 brewing stand, item in flower pot, pumpkin and melon stem, bed, iron bars, tripwire hook, lever, redstone repeater torch and comparator torch texture are darker.
From snapshot 14w25b to 1.
9-pre2brewing stand, item in flower pot, pumpkin and melon stem, bed, iron bars, tripwire hook, lever, redstone repeater torch and comparator torch texture are darker.From snapshot 14w25b to 1.10 brewing stand, item in flower pot, pumpkin and melon stem, bed, iron bars, tripwire hook, lever, redstone repeater torch and comparator torch texture are darker.
From snapshot 14w25b to 1
.10brewing stand, item in flower pot, pumpkin and melon stem, bed, iron bars, tripwire hook, lever, redstone repeater torch and comparator torch texture are darker.From snapshot 14w25b to 16w44a brewing stand, item in flower pot, pumpkin and melon stem, bed, iron bars, tripwire hook, lever, redstone repeater torch and comparator torch texture are darker.
![[Mod] Michael Wobst](../../../data/avatars/users/37868.png){kind=small}
![[Mojang] Nathan Adams](../../../data/assets/gravatar/dinnerbone.png){kind=small}
![[Mod] tryashtar](../../../data/avatars/users/41963.png){kind=small}
is duplicated by
![[Mod] CubeTheThird](../../../data/assets/gravatar/cubethethird.jpeg){kind=small}
![[Mod] violine1101](../../../data/avatars/users/92858.png){kind=small}
![[Helper] Misode](../../../data/avatars/users/93314.png){kind=small}
Manytransparent blockstexture are darker.Some transparent blocks models are shaded incorrectly
Sometransparentblocks models are shaded incorrectlySome 2D blocks models are shaded incorrectly
OS: Windows 7 , 64 bit Build 7601 Service Pack 1
CPU:total 4 (4 cores per cpu, 1 threads per core) family 6 model 58 stepping 9, cmov, cx8, fxsr, mmx, sse, sse2, sse3, ssse3, sse4.1, sse4.2, popcnt, avx, aes, erms, tsc, tscinvbit, tscinv
Memory: 4k page, physical 8348784k(1986892k free), swap 16695704k(8473172k free)
vm_info: Java HotSpot(TM) 64-Bit Server VM (24.65-b04) for windows-amd64 JRE (1.7.0_65-b20), built on Jul 11 2014 00:39:37 by "java_re" with unknown MS VC++:1600
is duplicated by
The bug
Since snapshot 14w25b, all 2D plants in flower pot, pumpkin and melon stem, mushrooms on red and brown mooshroms, redstone repeater torch and comparator torch models are shaded, making their textures to look darker than normal.
Fixed Resource Packs for each one (except for Mooshrooms) can be found attached.
The bug
Since snapshot 14w25b, all 2D plants in
flowerpot,pumpkin andmelonstem,mushrooms onred andbrownmooshroms,redstonerepeater torch andcomparator torch models are shaded, making their textures to look darker than normal.Fixed Resource Packs for each one (except for Mooshrooms) can be found attached.
The bug
Since snapshot 14w25b, all 2D plants in Flower Pot, Pumpkin and Melon Stem, Mushrooms on Red and Brown Mooshroms, Redstone Repeater torch and Comparator torch models are shaded, making their textures to look darker than normal.
Fixed Resource Packs for each one (except for both Mooshrooms) can be found attached.
Some 2D blocks' models are shaded incorrectly
Some 2D blocks'models are shaded incorrectly
relates to
Lowrelates to
relates to
![[Mojang] Adrian Östergård](../../../data/assets/gravatar/nighter.jpeg){kind=small}
![[Bot] Arisa](../../../data/avatars/users/43007.png){kind=small}
relates to
Redstone torches on the repeaters are still affected in 14w34c, see MC-68302
Duplicate of MC-68302
Go ahead and vote for the issue and/or add more information to it.
The resource pack attached to MC-214686 offers a complete fix for this issue. Mojang have my full permission to (and are encouraged to) replace the affected vanilla model files with the contents of the resource pack.
The bug
The torches on redstone repeaters and redstone comparators appear darker than expected, and are shaded depending on the view direction. This is not the case with redstone torches themselves, which are fully lit regardless of the view direction.
This began in 1.8, and was not the case in 1.7 or earlier. In addition, this is not the case in Bedrock Edition, effectively also making this a parity issue.
While this was listed in MC-68302, I still strongly consider this behaviour unintended for many reasons, including the two stated above. In addition, MC-67830's resolution contradicts such an assertion of this being intended. Other reasons are listed in MC-236474, a very similar issue.
How to reproduce
- Place down a redstone torch, noting how bright it appears when in the "on" state
- Place down a redstone repeater in a way that the torch powers it
- Note that the torches on said redstone repeater are darker than the standalone torch
- Now place down a comparator which also receives power
- Note that it, too, has darker torches than one would expect
Expected behaviour
The torches on repeaters and comparators would appear as bright as redstone torches themselves
Actual behaviour
Repeater and comparator torches are noticeably darker
How to fix
The resource pack attached to MC-214686 fixes this issue completely.
When plants are placed by themselves, no shading is applied to them. However, if that very same plant is instead placed inside a flower pot, it suddenly gains shading, which is nonsensical and obviously inconsistent.
Which behaviour is intended is not known, as the evidence is contradictory - the fixing of MC-57159 implies that there not being shading is what is intended, but the resolution of MC-68302 goes directly against that by saying the exact opposite.
As the behaviour in 1.7 and prior was to apply shading to neither, this is what the attached fix pack will do.
This is also a parity issue, as neither are shaded in Bedrock Edition.
Duplicate of MC-68302
Maybe this work as intended, since MC-68302 was solved in this way.
I personally think the pots don't look good the way they are now and I don't think MC-68302 has given the best examples and comparisons of this specific case.
I would like, if possible, that the decision be made with the images provided here.
The resource pack attached to MC-212630 offers a complete fix for this issue. Mojang have my full permission to (and are encouraged to) replace the affected vanilla model files with the contents of the resource pack.
The bug
Melon and pumpkin stems appear considerably darker in-game than they should due to missing ["shade": false] parameters in their model files.
How to reproduce
- Plant melon or pumpkin seeds
- Have the seeds grow to their full size
- Notice how the stem looks somewhat dark. If you look at the point where the two planes intersect, a clear boundary can be seen where the shading changes, which does not apply to other crosses. this can be seen to not be a texture issue by looking at both of the planes individually, which reveals they are lit differently.
Current appearence:
Expected appearance:
How to fix
The resource pack attached to MC-212630 fixes this issue completely, alongside fixing multiple other issues with the stem model.
Notes
While this was one of the cases listed in MC-68302, a 2014 ticket which was resolved as Works as Intended, I'm still reporting this independently of it for a multitude of reasons:
- This bug makes melon and pumpkin stems very inconsistent with all other crops, as well as all other cross-shaped plants, as absolutely none of these use shading.
- This behaviour is an unannounced change from 1.7 and prior versions, as these all had the stem render without this problematic shading.
MC-68302lumped several different model issues into one ticket, which is very confusing, and a discontinued practice which is generally not recommended much in more modern times. The individual issues in such tickets deserve a chance on their own as to allow for cleaner bug reports, fixes, communication and feedback, analyses, and so on.- Two other issues split off from
MC-68302, namelyMC-129826andMC-214662, are still considered valid issues. - It just looks downright unsightly.
The bug
When "shade" is set to "false" in a block, the element in question will have the shading commonly associated with most blocks disabled, as expected. However, this only appears to affect the models when used for a block; in contexts where the model is used as part of an entity, the shading will still be present, despite it being explicitly disabled, resulting in strange-looking models.
This effect can be seen in the following situations:
- Mushrooms on top of mooshrooms (previously reported under
MC-68302, which has since been resolved as WaI; since that ticket focused more on fixable issues with models I'm re-reporting it under this ticket since this situation is different) - Blocks being held by endermen, with flowers/mushrooms revealing this effect in Survival
- Poppies held by iron golems
- Blocks displayed in a minecart with a defined custom displayed block, as well as "proper" minecarts with blocks
- Lit TNT entities
Items are also subject to this problem, and have a dedicated ticket: MC-248766
As are item frames: MC-248963
How to reproduce (vanilla resources)
- Place some red mushrooms atop mycelium, and spawn some mooshrooms nearby such that the mushrooms can be compared
- Place a block of netherrack, and place fire on top of it via flint and steel/fire charge/some other method if you must
- Summon an enderman holding a block of fire:
/summon minecraft:enderman ~ ~ ~ {carriedBlockState:{Name:"minecraft:fire"},NoAI:1} - Summon a minecart containing fire:
/summon minecraft:minecart ~ ~ ~ {CustomDisplayTile:1b,DisplayState:{Name:"minecraft:fire"},DisplayOffset:16} - Summon a falling sand entity of fire:
/summon falling_block ~ ~ ~ {BlockState:{Name:"minecraft:fire"},Time:-2147483648,NoGravity:1}
Expected results (vanilla resources)
The mushrooms on the mooshroom would appear bright much like those present on the mycelium, and the fire held by the enderman and inside the minecart, as well as the falling sand entity, would also appear fully bright like the fire placed atop the netherrack block.
Actual results (vanilla resources)
The mushrooms on the mooshroom appear darker than the placed mushroom (one plane appears darker than the other), and the fire held by the enderman and in the minecart appears noticeably darker than the placed fire. Only the falling sand entity appears shaded correctly like the block is.
How to reproduce (custom resource pack)
Attached will be a resource pack (still in progress) which replaces the TNT and brown mushroom models with the same model used for testing MC-248766. This should make this issue far clearer.
- Place some red mushrooms atop mycelium, and spawn some mooshrooms nearby such that the mushrooms can be compared
- Place a block of TNT somewhere nearby
- Place a minecart with TNT close to it to allow for comparison
- Summon a normal minecart with TNT as its displayed custom block:
/summon minecraft:minecart ~ ~ ~ {CustomDisplayTile:1b,DisplayState:{Name:"minecraft:tnt"},DisplayOffset:16} - Summon an enderman holding TNT:
/summon minecraft:enderman ~ ~ ~ {carriedBlockState:{Name:"minecraft:tnt"},NoAI:1} - Summon a primed TNT entity with a long fuse:
/summon tnt ~ ~ ~ {Fuse:32767} - Summon a falling sand entity of TNT:
/summon falling_block ~ ~ ~ {BlockState:{Name:"minecraft:tnt"},Time:-2147483648,NoGravity:1}
Expected results (custom resource pack)
The placed mushrooms, mooshroom mushrooms, placed TNT, enderman-held TNT, TNT in both minecarts, falling TNT and lit TNT would all appear as pure white cubes.
Actual results
Only the placed mushroom and falling TNT entity render as pure white cubes. Placed TNT correctly appears as a solid color, but is darker; report upcoming. The rest of the things have multiple different shades of gray due to shading being applied despite it being explicitly disabled in the model.
Further notes
While not currently listed in this ticket, piston-moved blocks correctly have shading disabled accordingly as well.
Finally time to get around to reporting this - I've been holding on to this one for a couple of years at this point. Closely related to MC-236474 (which is not a duplicate), MC-129826 and MC-214662.
The bug
The three arms that come off of brewing stands appear darker than they should due to the absence of '"shade": false' entries for these elements.
This was originally reported under MC-68302. Since three cases of this have been split off into other tickets (MC-129826, MC-214662 and MC-236474), this is following suit, as it's fixable via models only (unlike the mushroom case, for example, which is reported under MC-248703 and is a rendering issue rather than a model issue).
How to reproduce
This can be done easily by comparing a brewing stand (clearest if bottles are present within) in 1.7.10 or earlier to one in 1.8 or later. The older brewing stand will correctly have the bottles appear bright, whereas in modern versions they appear dark.
How to fix
I have attached two resource packs to this ticket to fix this issue. The "45-degree fix" is the simplest one, and is designed to work with the current model. It functionally only changes the arm models to include the parameter that disables shading. I've also cleaned up the model code and added a missing cullface parameter to the middle rod.
There is also a "60-degree fix", which rotates the arms to be at 120-degree angles from each other, which is another thing that changed in 1.8 (MC-257054). However, as Minecraft: Java Edition does not currently support rotation values in increments other than 22.5 degrees, the game's code will need to be modified to permit this. The screenshots of this model were taken in 1.16.1 using the ModelsUnlocked Fabric mod to permit this.
I talk about the texture NOT about the light what emit.
Reopened now please.
@Miguel Angel: That issue was fixed in 14w34c.
Left a note in
MC-67830Look first and ultimate photo.
Torches and Restone torches are as bright as in 1.7.10 due to the fix of
MC-67830, but not the torches on comparators and repeatersThe sides of blocks along the x axis are darker than the sides along the z axis in 1.8. Not sure if this is a bug or if it is intended.
Confirmed for tripwire.
Confirmed for 15w33a and b.
Also, shouldn't the title be shortened, by replacing all affected blocks to "many transparent blocks" or something similar? Titles should be short and objective, but this one isn't being.
Hi. I have attached some fix Flower Pot plant model.
Thank you!
Hi. I have attaches resource pack.
Fix included are : Repeater, Bed, Comparator and Lever.
I will take a look at Iron Bars, Stem and Brewing Stand soon.
Confirmed for Stem, Brewing Stand and Iron Bars
I have attached two bed files with ambient occlusion false.
Confirmed for 1.13.1. Please, if you don't mind, I'd like to be the reporter of this ticket, I'll update it accordingly.
With the lighting changes introduced in 1.14+, does this issue still occur in the current release?
As of 19w45b, these blocks are still shaded even if they shouldn’t:
• saplings, flowers, mushrooms, dead bushes and ferns in flower pots – inconsistent with cross-model plants including themselves when not planted in a pot
• pumpkin and melon stems (both normal and attached) – inconsistent with cross-model plants and other crops
• redstone torches in repeaters and comparators – inconsistent with normal redstone torches
I am the original reporter and I can say that as of 19w45b this bug isn´t fixed yet, so please reopen it.
Mega611, this ticket is yours again.
I have attached some updated Resource Packs with the bugfixes. Can someone delete the old ones please? @Michael Wobst
I don´t think that this is Work As Intended, as I reported 7 years ago in 2014 another bug related to this (
MC-67830) and it got fixed. This bug should be fixed in my opinion.The developers have decided that for the other models, this is Intended.
Relates to
MC-129826,MC-214662and MC-236474.This is not Work as Intended, as flower pots, comparators and repeaters were fixed in 24w33a. Other blocks like pumpkin and melon stem and mushrooms in red and brown mooshrooms were not fixed, so this should be reopened.
I'd suggest making new reports for any cases not fixed that don't have their own report yet. I know pumpkin/melon stems have their own report already.