MC-245845You can place lily pads and frogspawn outside of the world border and inside spawn protection
The Bug:
You can place lily pads and frogspawn outside of the world border and inside spawn protection.
Please note that the issue isn't a desync.
Steps to Reproduce:
- Summon a large area of water below your feet by using the command provided below,
/fill ~10 ~-1 ~10 ~-10 ~-1 ~-10 minecraft:water
- Set the world border's center to your current position and to seven blocks wide by using the commands provided below.
/worldborder center ~ ~
/worldborder set 7
- Switch into survival mode, obtain some lily pads and frogspawn, and attempt to place them outside of the world border.
- Take note as to whether or not you can place lily pads and frogspawn outside of the world border and inside spawn protection.
Observed Behavior:
Lily pads and frogspawn can be placed.
Expected Behavior:
Lily pads and frogspawn would not be able to be placed.
Linked Issues
Attachments2
![[Mod] Avoma](../../../data/avatars/users/86198.png){kind=small}
Created Issue:
You can collect liquids and place lily pads outside of the world border and inside spawn protection
The Bug:
You can collect liquids and place lily pads outside of the world border and inside spawn protection.
Steps to Reproduce:
- Summon a large area of water below your feet.
- Set the size of the world border to seven blocks and the center of it to your current position.
- Obtain some buckets and attempt to collect some water that is outside of the world border.
- Take note as to whether or not you can collect liquids and place lily pads outside of the world border and inside spawn protection.
Observed Behavior:
You can collect liquids and place lily pads outside of the world border and inside spawn protection.
Expected Behavior:
You would not be able to collect liquids and place lily pads outside of the world border and inside spawn protection.
![[Mod] markderickson](../../../data/avatars/users/18946.svg){kind=small}
The Bug:
You can collect liquids and place lily pads outside of the world border and inside spawn protection.
Please note that the issue with collecting liquids outside of the world border or inside spawn protection is a desync, (the action succeeds client-side but fails server-side). On the other hand, the issue with placing lily pads outside of the world border or inside spawn protection is not a desync and the action is successfully executed.
Steps to Reproduce:
- Summon a large area of water below your feet.
- Set the size of the world border to seven blocks and the center of it to your current position.
- Obtain some buckets and attempt to collect some water that is outside of the world border.
- Take note as to whether or not you can collect liquids and place lily pads outside of the world border and inside spawn protection.
Observed Behavior:
You can collect liquids and place lily pads outside of the world border and inside spawn protection.
Expected Behavior:
You would not be able to collect liquids and place lily pads outside of the world border and inside spawn protection.
The Bug:
You can collect liquids and place lily pads outside of the world border and inside spawn protection.
Please note that the issue with collecting liquids outside of the world border or inside spawn protection is a desync, (the action succeeds client-side but fails server-side). On the other hand, the issue with placing lily pads outside of the world border or inside spawn protection is not a desync and the action is successfully
executed.Steps to Reproduce:
- Summon a large area of water below your feet.
- Set the size of the world border to seven blocks and the center of it to your current position.
- Obtain some buckets and attempt to collect some water that is outside of the world border.
- Take note as to whether or not you can collect liquids and place lily pads outside of the world border and inside spawn protection.
Observed Behavior:
You can collect liquids and place lily pads outside of the world border and inside spawn protection.
Expected Behavior:
You would not be able to collect liquids and place lily pads outside of the world border and inside spawn protection.
The Bug:
You can collect liquids and place lily pads outside of the world border and inside spawn protection.
Please note that the issue with collecting liquids outside of the world border or inside spawn protection is a desync, (the action succeeds client-side but fails server-side). On the other hand, the issue with placing lily pads outside of the world border or inside spawn protection is not a desync, and the action is successfully carried out.
Steps to Reproduce:
- Summon a large area of water below your feet.
- Set the size of the world border to seven blocks and the center of it to your current position.
- Obtain some buckets and attempt to collect some water that is outside of the world border.
- Take note as to whether or not you can collect liquids and place lily pads outside of the world border and inside spawn protection.
Observed Behavior:
You can collect liquids and place lily pads outside of the world border and inside spawn protection.
Expected Behavior:
You would not be able to collect liquids and place lily pads outside of the world border and inside spawn protection.
The Bug:
You can collect liquids and place lily pads outside of the world border and inside spawn protection.
Please note that the issue with collecting liquids outside of the world border or inside spawn protection is a desync, (the action succeeds client-side but fails server-side). On the other hand, the issue with placing lily pads outside of the world border or inside spawn protection is not a desync, and the action is successfully carried out.
Steps to Reproduce:
- Summon a large area of water below your feet.
- Set the size of the world border to seven blocks and the center of it to your current position.
- Obtain some buckets and attempt to collect some water that is outside of the world border.
- Take note as to whether or not you can collect liquids and place lily pads outside of the world border and inside spawn protection.
Observed Behavior:
You can collect liquids and place lily pads outside of the world border and inside spawn protection.
Expected Behavior:
You would not be able to collect liquids and place lily pads outside of the world border and inside spawn protection.
MC-245845.mp4
![[Mod] Les3awe](../../../data/avatars/users/79847.png){kind=small}
The Bug:
You can
collect liquids andplace lily pads outside of the world border and inside spawn protection.Please note that the issue with collecting liquids outside of the world border or inside spawn protection is a desync, (the action succeeds client-side but fails server-side). On the other hand, the issue with placing lily pads outside of the world border or inside spawn protection is not a desync, and the action is successfully carried out.
Steps to Reproduce:
- Summon a large area of water below your feet.
- Set the size of the world border to seven blocks and the center of it to your current position.
Obtain somebucketsand attempt tocollect some water that isoutside of the world border.- Take note as to whether or not you can
collect liquids andplace lily pads outside of the world border and inside spawn protection.Observed Behavior:
You can
collect liquids andplace lily pads outside of the world border and inside spawn protection.Expected Behavior:
You would not be able to
collect liquids andplace lily pads outside of the world border and inside spawn protection.The Bug:
You can place lily pads outside of the world border and inside spawn protection.
Please note that the issue isn't a desync.
Steps to Reproduce:
- Summon a large area of water below your feet.
- Set the size of the world border to seven blocks and the center of it to your current position.
- Switch into survival mode, obtain some lily pads, and attempt to place them outside of the world border.
- Take note as to whether or not you can place lily pads outside of the world border and inside spawn protection.
Observed Behavior:
You can place lily pads outside of the world border and inside spawn protection.
Expected Behavior:
You would not be able to place lily pads outside of the world border and inside spawn protection.
You cancollect liquids andplace lily pads outside of the world border and inside spawn protection
This ticket clones
MC-54119.
![[Mojang] Moesh](../../../data/avatars/users/10122.svg){kind=small}
Low![[Mod] ampolive](../../../data/avatars/users/18949.svg){kind=small}
The Bug:
You can place lily pads and frogspawn outside of the world border and inside spawn protection.
Please note that the issue isn't a desync.
Steps to Reproduce:
- Summon a large area of water below your feet.
- Set the size of the world border to seven blocks and the center of it to your current position.
- Switch into survival mode, obtain some lily pads and frogspawn, and attempt to place them outside of the world border.
- Take note as to whether or not you can place lily pads and frogspawn outside of the world border and inside spawn protection.
Observed Behavior:
You can place lily pads and frogspawn outside of the world border and inside spawn protection.
Expected Behavior:
You would not be able to place lily pads and frogspawn outside of the world border and inside spawn protection.
You can place lily pads and frogspawn outside of the world border and inside spawn protection
![[Helper] Johnibur](../../../data/avatars/users/28381.png){kind=small}
The Bug:
You can place lily pads and frogspawn outside of the world border and inside spawn protection.
Please note that the issue isn't a desync.
Steps to Reproduce:
- Summon a large area of water below your feet.
- Set the size of the world border to seven blocks and the center of it to your current position.
/worldborder center ~ ~
- Switch into survival mode, obtain some lily pads and frogspawn, and attempt to place them outside of the world border.
- Take note as to whether or not you can place lily pads and frogspawn outside of the world border and inside spawn protection.
Observed Behavior:
You can place lily pads and frogspawn outside of the world border and inside spawn protection.
Expected Behavior:
You would not be able to place lily pads and frogspawn outside of the world border and inside spawn protection.
The Bug:
You can place lily pads and frogspawn outside of the world border and inside spawn protection.
Please note that the issue isn't a desync.
Steps to Reproduce:
- Summon a large area of water below your feet.
- Set the size of the world border to seven blocks and the center of it to your current position.
- Switch into survival mode, obtain some lily pads and frogspawn, and attempt to place them outside of the world border.
- Take note as to whether or not you can place lily pads and frogspawn outside of the world border and inside spawn protection.
Observed Behavior:
You can place lily pads and frogspawn outside of the world border and inside spawn protection.
Expected Behavior:
You would not be able to place lily pads and frogspawn outside of the world border and inside spawn protection.
The Bug:
You can place lily pads and frogspawn outside of the world border and inside spawn protection.
Please note that the issue isn't a desync.
Steps to Reproduce:
- Summon a large area of water below your feet.
- Set the size of the world border to seven blocks and the center of it to your current position.
- Switch into survival mode, obtain some lily pads and frogspawn, and attempt to place them outside of the world border.
- Take note as to whether or not you can place lily pads and frogspawn outside of the world border and inside spawn protection.
Observed Behavior:
You can place lily pads and frogspawnoutside of the world border and inside spawn protection.Expected Behavior:
You would not be able to place lily pads and frogspawn outside of the world border and inside spawn protection.The Bug:
You can place lily pads and frogspawn outside of the world border and inside spawn protection.
Please note that the issue isn't a desync.
Steps to Reproduce:
- Summon a large area of water below your feet by using the command provided below,
/fill ~10 ~-1 ~10 ~-10 ~-1 ~-10 minecraft:water- Set the world border's center to your current position and to seven blocks wide by using the commands provided below.
/worldborder set 7/worldborder center ~ ~- Switch into survival mode, obtain some lily pads and frogspawn, and attempt to place them outside of the world border.
- Take note as to whether or not you can place lily pads and frogspawn outside of the world border and inside spawn protection.
Observed Behavior:
Lily pads and frogspawn can be placed.
Expected Behavior:
Lily pads and frogspawn would not be able to be placed.
The Bug:
You can place lily pads and frogspawn outside of the world border and inside spawn protection.
Please note that the issue isn't a desync.
Steps to Reproduce:
- Summon a large area of water below your feet by using the command provided below,
/fill ~10 ~-1 ~10 ~-10 ~-1 ~-10 minecraft:water- Set the world border's center to your current position and to seven blocks wide by using the commands provided below.
/worldborderset 7/worldbordercenter ~ ~- Switch into survival mode, obtain some lily pads and frogspawn, and attempt to place them outside of the world border.
- Take note as to whether or not you can place lily pads and frogspawn outside of the world border and inside spawn protection.
Observed Behavior:
Lily pads and frogspawn can be placed.
Expected Behavior:
Lily pads and frogspawn would not be able to be placed.
The Bug:
You can place lily pads and frogspawn outside of the world border and inside spawn protection.
Please note that the issue isn't a desync.
Steps to Reproduce:
- Summon a large area of water below your feet by using the command provided below,
/fill ~10 ~-1 ~10 ~-10 ~-1 ~-10 minecraft:water- Set the world border's center to your current position and to seven blocks wide by using the commands provided below.
/worldborder center ~ ~/worldborder set 7- Switch into survival mode, obtain some lily pads and frogspawn, and attempt to place them outside of the world border.
- Take note as to whether or not you can place lily pads and frogspawn outside of the world border and inside spawn protection.
Observed Behavior:
Lily pads and frogspawn can be placed.
Expected Behavior:
Lily pads and frogspawn would not be able to be placed.
The Bug:
You can place lily pads and frogspawn outside of the world border and inside spawn protection.
Please note that the issue isn't a desync.
Steps to Reproduce:
- Summon a large area of water below your feet by using the command provided below,
/fill ~10 ~-1 ~10 ~-10 ~-1 ~-10 minecraft:water- Set the world border's center to your current position and to seven blocks wide by using the commands provided below.
- Switch into survival mode, obtain some lily pads and frogspawn, and attempt to place them outside of the world border.
- Take note as to whether or not you can place lily pads and frogspawn outside of the world border and inside spawn protection.
Observed Behavior:
Lily pads and frogspawn can be placed.
Expected Behavior:
Lily pads and frogspawn would not be able to be placed.
![[Mojang] slicedlime](../../../data/assets/gravatar/slicedlime.jpeg){kind=small}
![[Mod] ManosSef](../../../data/avatars/users/61702.png){kind=small}
I was told to create a new ticket regarding this issue so I've gone ahead and done so. The new report is MC-245845. 
This ticket may relate to MC-245845
![[Mod] Jiingy](../../../data/avatars/users/91802.png){kind=small}
When targeting a block which is a valid placement position for frogspawn or lily pads, the game will favor the camera/look direction's raycast and place the block in an unexpected or undesired position.
(By raycast, I mean a straight line created from the player's view to the first water source block it hits)
Steps to Reproduce:
- Create a 3x3x3 pond of water
- In the center-most position, place a block
- Stand on the edge of the pond (allowing space for placement on top of the water in front of you)
- Target the front-half of the block inside the pond
- Try and place a lily pad or frogspawn
Observed Behavior:
The block is placed on the water block closest to the player.
Expected Result:
The block would be placed above the center block, because it was targeted.
Screenshots/Videos:
In this example, I am trying to place the lily pad above the white wool. While this position is valid for placement, the lily pad is put on top of the water block my camera first views, instead of being placed on top of the block I am targeting.
water_blocks_place.mp4
Notes:
- To clarify; while this is very similar to MC-226518, it is different as that issue specifies the block is being placed when it otherwise should not be placed at all. In this instance, the block should be placed, but is put in the wrong position. The two however are closely related.
- Other related lily pad/frogspawn placement issues:
MC-237476 MC-256407 MC-136405 MC-245845 MC-218114 MC-206807
I was told to split this ticket into two reports, so I've gone ahead and done so as requested.
The two tickets are this one (MC-245845) and MC-245876.
This issue also now affects frogspawn due to its similar nature to lily pads. Since I'm the reporter of this ticket, I've updated it accordingly and just left this comment here for documentation purposes.