Villager AI (farming) broken
Farmers (and other brown-coated villagers) who were happily farming in 15w40 now stand around staring at ripe crops. They very occasionally remember how to break them, and then usually leave the drops on the ground to despawn and fail to replant.
The only time they seem to successfully do anything is when they "switch tasks" between farming and breeding attempts, farming and wandering, or farming and running for home at sunset. After one successful operation they get stuck again.
EDIT: Villagers who are pushed into the farm block can harvest/re-plant, so it appears to be an issue with the distance for walking to/from a crop and the distance for working on a crop/farmland block not matching up anymore.
Environment
Windows 8 64-bit
java version "1.8.0_51"
Java(TM) SE Runtime Environment (build 1.8.0_51-b16)
Java HotSpot(TM) Client VM (build 25.51-b03, mixed mode)
Linked Issues
is duplicated by18
MC-90122Beetroot unknown to Villager AIDuplicateMC-90310Well for some reason the Villagers don't seem to be able to farm the new Beetroot... so ya I just wanted to report this problem...DuplicateMC-90432Villagers Wont FarmDuplicateMC-90468villagers no longer farming crops consistentlyDuplicateMC-90724Villagers can't farmDuplicateMC-90772Villagers dont steal my dropped breadDuplicateMC-90801Villagers don't worksDuplicateMC-91056Brown robe villagers do not farm, even with full seed inventoriesDuplicateMC-91059Villagers take a long time to harvest a single cropDuplicateMC-91192Villagers are not farming correctlyDuplicateMC-91361villager AI bugDuplicateMC-91512Villagers can't farm correctlyDuplicateMC-91594Villager Ai buggedDuplicateMC-91681Villager farming is brokenDuplicateMC-91743Villagers won't harvest and replant cropsDuplicateMC-91752Farmer villager's not farmingDuplicateMC-91911The villagers won't plant the crops DuplicateMC-92124Farmer Villagers won't harvest cropsDuplicaterelates to5
MC-89920Ocelots/cats partially broken in some waysAwaiting ResponseMC-89924Ridable Animals (Horses, Pigs) BrokenFixedMC-89938Mobs won't attack if target isn't in the middle of a blockFixedMC-90397Villagers stand outside opening and closing doors instead of entering.DuplicateMC-91832Villagers inconsistently don't run from ZombiesDuplicate![[Mod] Les3awe](../../../data/avatars/users/79847.png){kind=small}
Created Issue:
Farmer villagers have forgotten how to farm
Farmers (and other brown-coated villagers) who were happily farming in 15w40 now stand around staring at ripe crops. They very occasionally remember how to break them, and then usually leave the drops on the ground to despawn and fail to replant.
The only time they seem to successfully do anything is when they "switch tasks" between farming and breeding attempts, farming and wandering, or farming and running for home at sunset. After one successful operation they get stuck again.
Environment
Windows 8 64-bit
java version "1.8.0_51"
Java(TM) SE Runtime Environment (build 1.8.0_51-b16)
Java HotSpot(TM) Client VM (build 25.51-b03, mixed mode)
relates to
is duplicated by
Farmer villagers have forgotten how to farmVillager AI (farming) broken
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
relates to
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
Farmers (and other brown-coated villagers) who were happily farming in 15w40 now stand around staring at ripe crops. They very occasionally remember how to break them, and then usually leave the drops on the ground to despawn and fail to replant.
The only time they seem to successfully do anything is when they "switch tasks" between farming and breeding attempts, farming and wandering, or farming and running for home at sunset. After one successful operation they get stuck again.
EDIT: Villagers who are pushed into the farm block can harvest/re-plant, so it appears to be an issue with the distance for walking to/from a crop and the distance for working on a crop/farmland block not matching up anymore.
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
relates to
relates to
is duplicated by
relates to
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
relates to
is duplicated by
relates to
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
relates to
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
It appears that farmers are not "close enough" to the block of farmland they are targeting. If nudged forward a little bit, they will harvest/plant the block.
Confirmed for me. Both my automatic wheat and beetroot farms have stopped working. Every 2-3 minutes the villager finally decides to harvest/replant a patch or two. More often than not, he harvests and doesn't replant at all. He's just constantly looking down, doing nothing, as if totally depressed!
Confirmed
Farmer villagers still harvest, but they don't pick up the items or replant. It seems that most of the mobs AI's are broken.
Maybe you should try putting pressure plates to detect when they harvest to trigger water that flows the crops into hoppers.
Confirmed for
You could change the title to something more accurate like "Villager harvesting AI partwise broken" or something similar
Still an issue in 15w42a
Still an issue in 15w43a
Still an issue in 15w43b / Confirmed
15w43c too
Confirmed for 15w43c.
In the attached screenshots you can see that the pathfinding of the villagers stops one block too early to plant, harvest, or go through doors.
I'd be willing to bet this is related, if not a duplicate, of
MC-89938.Linking as related.
Still in 15w44a.
Mine was ´duplicated´ of this one but my villagers wons do ANYTHING they will never pickup, never farm, they only walk on them.
(15w44b)
Franke van Zuilen: They're probably the same issue. If the fix for this bug doesn't fix your issue, please re-report.
Still in 15w44b, attached video
when the villager try to havest the crop , they can't havest the crop because they stand not close enough
to the crop , so they can't destroy the block .as the result, they keep staring at the without doing anything, after the player push them a little bit, they are close enough to destroy the crop and pick up them
Can confirm that the issue seems to be that Villagers don't stand close enough to e.g. the wheat (or the farmland that needs a seed).
You can see it demonstrated in Panda4994's snapshot test video of 15w44a:
Starting at https://youtu.be/vCtgyeaq_cA?t=2h31m31s for 2 minutes
May be AI pathfinding has issues?
Villagers error:
1. Unable to farming.
2. Unable to correctly open the door. (
MC-90397)3. Unable to escape the zombies. (
MC-91832)I think that it is just a universal pathfinding issue, hence my link to the bug with zombies path finding.
Is fixed in 15w45a
Confirmed fixed in 15w45a