MC-92863/spreadplayers occasionally suffocates players
The spreadplayers command behaves much better than it used to, but it still sometimes suffocates players. Specifically, if you run
/spreadplayers ~10000 ~10000 50000 50001 true @s
about 100 times, about 5 of those times you'll find yourself suffocating in a block.
Every time I was suffocating, the behavior was consistent: the block above my head was a leaf block. I speculate that when spreadplayers sees that the topmost block at the x,z it wants to put you at is a 'leaf' block, it moves you down so that the players head is one block below the bottom-most contiguous leaf. However, leaves can be above wood or the ground, and so sometimes this means the player spawn in solid wood or dirt, suffocating.
(This is a relatively minor bug; the behavior now seems much improved compared to MC-52254 )
Linked Issues
is duplicated by3
Attachments1
Created Issue:
spreadplayers occasionally suffocates players
The spreadplayers command behaves much better than it used to, but it still sometimes suffocates players. Specifically, if you run
/spreadplayers 0 0 1 100000 true @pabout 100 times, about 5 of those times you'll find yourself suffocating in a block.
Every time I was suffocating, the behavior was consistent: the block above my head was a leaf block. I speculate that when spreadplayers sees that the topmost block at the x,z it wants to put you at is a 'leaf' block, it moves you down so that the players head is one block below the bottom-most contiguous leaf. However, leaves can be above wood or the ground, and so sometimes this means the player spawn in solid wood or dirt, suffocating.
(This is a relatively minor bug; the behavior now seems much improved compared to
MC-52254)
relates to
![[Mod] Michael Wobst](../../../data/avatars/users/37868.png){kind=small}
/spreadplayers occasionally suffocates players
![[Mod] violine1101](../../../data/avatars/users/92858.png){kind=small}
The spreadplayers command behaves much better than it used to, but it still sometimes suffocates players.
Specifically, if you run/spreadplayers 0 0 1 100000 true @pabout 100 times, about 5 of those times you'll find yourself suffocating in a block.
Every time I was suffocating, the behavior was consistent: the block above my head was a leaf block. I speculate that when spreadplayers sees that the topmost block at the x,z it wants to put you at is a 'leaf' block, it moves you down so that the players head is one block below the bottom-most contiguous leaf. However, leaves can be above wood or the ground, and so sometimes this means the player spawn in solid wood or dirt, suffocating.
(This is a relatively minor bug; the behavior now seems much improved compared to
MC-52254)The spreadplayers command behaves much better than it used to, but it still sometimes suffocates players. Specifically, if you run
/spreadplayers ~10000 ~10000 50000 50001 true @sabout 100 times, about 5 of those times you'll find yourself suffocating in a block.
Every time I was suffocating, the behavior was consistent: the block above my head was a leaf block. I speculate that when spreadplayers sees that the topmost block at the x,z it wants to put you at is a 'leaf' block, it moves you down so that the players head is one block below the bottom-most contiguous leaf. However, leaves can be above wood or the ground, and so sometimes this means the player spawn in solid wood or dirt, suffocating.
(This is a relatively minor bug; the behavior now seems much improved compared to
MC-52254)
![[Mojang] Nathan Adams](../../../data/assets/gravatar/dinnerbone.png){kind=small}
![[Mod] LateLag](../../../data/avatars/users/92884.png){kind=small}
is duplicated by
![[Mod] j_p_smith](../../../data/avatars/users/92851.png){kind=small}
Why create another issue, it's the same problem, isn't it?
When you say above your head, is your head in the leaves, or below the leaves?
Can't reproduce in 16w42a: you are always spread on top of the leaves
Can confirm in 16w42a. See screenshot
Can this still be reproduced in 1.13.2 and higher?
I have been trying for some time and couldn't reproduce; as SunCat said, you always teleport on top of the leaves.
Note: I'd seek a second opinion before marking this as fixed.
I was also unable to reproduce this in 1.16.
The ticket has now been marked as fixed. Please comment if you're still affected by it.