REALMS-1808Kicked During End Credits Due to 'Idling'
While I was on my realms, after defeating the Ender Dragon (which was fun) me and my friend jumped in the portal to read the End Credits and return to the overworld. During my beautiful narration of the End Credits, Realms kicked both me and my friend off for being AFK. I understand that there is an anti-idle kick after 10 minutes. However, when an idle kick causes conflicts with game features and intentions, that's what I would say is a bug.
I would suggest firstly to allow /setidletimetimeout on Realms and perhaps allow scheduling of the server maintenance and/or allow players to automatically rejoin the realms after a serve maintenance. Yes, it's a 'good' idea to keep resources available by disabling the command and setting a hard idle timeout time, but here's a few things:
1) Perhaps most obviously, many players rely on AFK Farming to gather resources and whatnot. Yes, you can usually 'bypass' the idle timeout by doing something such as opening/closing a trapdoor or hitting a noteblock and so on, but sometimes this doesn't work and is quite frankly annoying to deal with.
2) Some people will leave to go to travel, go to a camp, and so on where they know exactly how long they will be gone. Being that AFK farms generate various useful things and that people can need an extensive supply of resources for various projects, if one could use the time that they will be gone wisely, that would be very beneficial. Although, I would recommend capping the idle kickoff time to about 1-2 months.
3) You get kicked on the END CREDITS! C'mon. At least set the idle time to allow game features to run and finish! A minimum time of 20 minutes would probably be 'enough.'
4) Most likely, most people wouldn't even touch the command at all, so the idle timeout would usually be set at default (again, refer to 2)
5) Sometimes people just need to step away for a little while and don't quite know how long. I doubt people would step away for more than an hour and usually not even that long. Perhaps everyday life should be considered.
Secondly, if the server maintenance must needs be done once everyday or at certain times and /setidletimetimeout can not be instated, match the idle time with the time between server maintenance. Again, I would advice allowing scheduling of the server maintenance and/or allowing players to automatically reconnect to the realms after a maintenance.
AT A MINIMUM, the idle time timeout MUST be increased by AT LEAST 5-10 minutes (see 3)
I will be sending this in as a feature suggestion, but nonetheless THIS IS A BUG.
(Sorry about the long bug report. I could not find a show/hide text button option)
The following bug reports the kick/timeout during the End Credits:
REALMS-1624
The following bug reports /setidletimetimeout not working/request for it to work/request a method to prevent being idle kicked/the actual idle kick timeout:
REALMS-266
REALMS-40
MC-112204
REALMS-1592
REALMS-198
The following bug report requests core server features to be included (such as /setidletimetimeout):
REALMS-72
The following bug could be related to the idle timeout:
REALMS-957
Environment
Note: All versions of Realms should be affected
Linked Issues
is duplicated by3
MC-179615
Created Issue:
Kicked During End Credits Due to 'Idling'
While I was on my realms, after defeating the Ender Dragon (which was fun) me and my friend jumped in the portal to read the End Credits and return to the overworld. During my beautiful narration of the End Credits, Realms kicked both me and my friend off for being AFK. I understand that there is an anti-idle kick after 10 minutes. However, when an idle kick causes conflicts with game features and intentions, that's what I would say is a bug.
I would suggest firstly to allow /setidletimetimeout on Realms and perhaps allow scheduling of the server maintenance and/or allow players to automatically rejoin the realms after a serve maintenance. Yes, it's a 'good' idea to keep resources available by disabling the command and setting a hard idle timeout time, but here's a few things:
1) Perhaps most obviously, many players rely on AFK Farming to gather resources and whatnot. Yes, you can usually 'bypass' the idle timeout by doing something such as opening/closing a trapdoor or hitting a noteblock and so on, but sometimes this doesn't work and is quite frankly annoying to deal with.
2) Some people will leave to go to travel, go to a camp, and so on where they know exactly how long they will be gone. Being that AFK farms generate various useful things and that people can need an extensive supply of resources for various projects, if one could use the time that they will be gone wisely, that would be very beneficial. Although, I would recommend capping the idle kickoff time to about 1-2 months.
3) You get kicked on the END CREDITS! C'mon. At least set the idle time to allow game features to run and finish! A minimum time of 20 minutes would probably be 'enough.'
4) Most likely, most people wouldn't even touch the command at all, so the idle timeout would usually be set at default (again, refer to 2)
5) Sometimes people just need to step away for a little while and don't quite know how long. I doubt people would step away for more than an hour and usually not even that long. Perhaps everyday life should be considered.Secondly, if the server maintenance must needs be done once everyday or at certain times and /setidletimetimeout can not be instated, match the idle time with the time between server maintenance. Again, I would advice allowing scheduling of the server maintenance and/or allowing players to automatically reconnect to the realms after a maintenance.
AT A MINIMUM, the idle time timeout MUST be increased by AT LEAST 5-10 minutes (see 3)
I will be sending this in as a feature suggestion, but nonetheless THIS IS A BUG.
(Sorry about the long bug report. I could not find a show/hide text button option)
Bug ReportsThe following bug reports the kick/timeout during the End Credits:
REALMS-1624The following bug reports /setidletimetimeout not working/request for it to work/request a method to prevent being idle kicked/the actual idle kick timeout:
REALMS-266
REALMS-40
MC-112204
REALMS-1592
REALMS-198The following bug report requests core server features to be included (such as /setidletimetimeout):
REALMS-72The following bug could be related to the idle timeout:
REALMS-957Environment
Note: All versions of Realms should be affected
![[Mojang] Fredrik Telenius](../../../data/avatars/users/10122.svg){kind=small}
![[Mod] violine1101](../../../data/avatars/users/92858.png){kind=small}
duplicates
relates to
is duplicated by
duplicates
relates to
![[Bot] Arisa](../../../data/avatars/users/43007.png){kind=small}
relates to
![[Mod] tryashtar](../../../data/avatars/users/41963.png){kind=small}
is duplicated by
![[Mod] Michael Wobst](../../../data/avatars/users/37868.png){kind=small}
relates to
![[MCQA] v-magwar](../../../data/avatars/users/18935.svg){kind=small}
This ticket is only about the issue on Bedrock Edition from now on. For Java Edition, I have reopened REALMS-1808.
Thank you for your report!
We're tracking this issue in REALMS-1808, so this ticket is being resolved and linked as a duplicate.
If you would like to add a vote and any extra information to the main ticket it would be appreciated.
If you haven't already, you might like to make use of the search feature to see if the issue has already been mentioned.
Quick Links:
📓 Bug Tracker Guidelines – 💬 Community Support – 📧 Mojang Support
📓 Project Summary – ✍️ Feedback and Suggestions – 📖 Game Wiki
– I am a bot. This action was performed automatically! Please report any issues on Discord or Reddit
Is this a Realm, REALMS-1808?
I reproduced this without a realm, REALMS-1808 seems to be the same issue but specific to realms.
Reopened, this will be the parent ticket for Java Edition Realms from now on.
Can be reproduced without a realm, this is a server issue in general: MC-237843.
Suggesting to move this to the MC project instead.