Right clicking on redstone ore, which causes it to light up, plays no hand animation
Since this is an interaction with a block that triggers a change in block state, a hand animation should be played, however in this case none happens, which is very inconsistent. Right clicking on lit redstone ore should also play a hand animation, since it causes it to emit a burst of particles.
Linked Issues
testing discovered1
discovered while testing1
relates to15
MC-101084Held items/blocks appears to bob down and up while opening horse's inventoryFixedMC-127094Arm animation is not executed in certain circumstancesFixedMC-165510Water and lava can't be placed on redstone ore
LowMC-166435Blocks in offhand can't be placed on any side of a redstone ore blockLowMC-195094Lighting redstone ore overrides the use action of held items, despite not overriding block placementConfirmedMC-201802The hand animation is inconsistent when right clicking redstone ore in different contextsConfirmedMC-132445Spawn eggs used on water do not display a hand animationFixedMC-160895Breeding animals does not display a hand animationFixedMC-160896Shearing sheep and mooshrooms does not display a hand animationFixedMC-160897Dropping an item using the drop key displays the hand animation but dropping items from within the inventory does notFixedMC-160981Making tamed parrots sit/stand plays no hand animationFixedMC-161259Using the carrot on a stick while riding a pig plays no hand animationFixedMC-161261Treating zombie villagers does not display a hand animationFixedMC-161262Feeding pandas does not play hand animationFixedMC-163921Placing a block while looking at redstone ore plays no soundFixedAttachments1
Created Issue:
Right clicking on redstone ore, which causes it to light up, plays no hand animation
Attachments1
![[Mod] Michael Wobst](../../../data/avatars/users/37868.png){kind=small}
relates to
discovered while testing
![[Mojang] Adrian Östergård](../../../data/assets/gravatar/nighter.jpeg){kind=small}
Low![[Mojang] Cory Scheviak](../../../data/avatars/users/92893.png){kind=small}
[Mojang] Cory ScheviakDiscovered while testing MC-161150 and relates to
MC-132445,MC-160895,MC-160896,MC-160897andMC-160981.Since this is an interaction with a block that triggers a change in block state, a hand animation should be played, however in this case none happens, which is very inconsistent. Res the clicking on kit redstone ore should not display a hand animation though.
Discovered while testing MC-161150 and relates to
MC-132445,MC-160895,MC-160896,MC-160897andMC-160981.Since this is an interaction with a block that triggers a change in block state, a hand animation should be played, however in this case none happens, which is very inconsistent. R
es theclicking onkit redstone ore should not display a hand animation though.Discovered while testing MC-161150 and relates to
MC-132445,MC-160895,MC-160896,MC-160897andMC-160981.Since this is an interaction with a block that triggers a change in block state, a hand animation should be played, however in this case none happens, which is very inconsistent. Roght clicking on lit redstone ore should not display a hand animation though.
Discovered while testing MC-161150 and relates to
MC-132445,MC-160895,MC-160896,MC-160897andMC-160981.Since this is an interaction with a block that triggers a change in block state, a hand animation should be played, however in this case none happens, which is very inconsistent. R
oght clicking on lit redstone ore should not display a hand animation though.Discovered while testing MC-161150 and relates to
MC-132445,MC-160895,MC-160896,MC-160897andMC-160981.Since this is an interaction with a block that triggers a change in block state, a hand animation should be played, however in this case none happens, which is very inconsistent. Right clicking on lit redstone ore should not display a hand animation though.
![[Mod] violine1101](../../../data/avatars/users/92858.png){kind=small}
relates to
![[Mod] Les3awe](../../../data/avatars/users/79847.png){kind=small}
relates to
relates to
relates to
Discovered while testing MC-161150 and relates to
MC-132445,MC-160895,MC-160896,MC-160897andMC-160981.Since this is an interaction with a block that triggers a change in block state, a hand animation should be played, however in this case none happens, which is very inconsistent. Right clicking on lit redstone ore should
not display a hand animationthough.Discovered while testing MC-161150 and relates to
MC-132445,MC-160895,MC-160896,MC-160897andMC-160981.Since this is an interaction with a block that triggers a change in block state, a hand animation should be played, however in this case none happens, which is very inconsistent. Right clicking on lit redstone ore should also play a hand animation, since it causes it to emit a burst of particles.
[Missing hand animation] Right clicking on redstone ore, which causes it to light up, plays no hand animation
[Missing hand animation]Right clicking on redstone ore, which causes it to light up, plays no hand animation
![[Bot] Piston](../../../data/avatars/users/31202.png){kind=small}
testing discovered
relates to
relates to
relates to
Discovered while testing MC-161150 and relates to
MC-132445,MC-160895,MC-160896,MC-160897andMC-160981.Since this is an interaction with a block that triggers a change in block state, a hand animation should be played, however in this case none happens, which is very inconsistent. Right clicking on lit redstone ore should also play a hand animation, since it causes it to emit a burst of particles.
![[Mod] SPGoding](../../../data/avatars/users/44622.png){kind=small}
relates to
Arm animation is not executed in certains circumstances. Which are:
- Dyeing a sheep, or wolf/cat collar
- Shearing a sheep or mooshroom (not fixed, see
MC-160896) - Dropping an item (not fixed when dropping from GUI, see
MC-160897) - Emptying a water/lava/fish bucket.
- Filling a bucket.
- Placing a boat.
- Throwing an ender pearl, snowball, or potion.
- Throwing an eye of ender.
- Feeding an animal. (not fixed, see
MC-160895) - Making tamed animals sit/stand (not fixed, see
MC-160981) - Activating redstone ore (not fixed, see
MC-161151)
Crossed circumstances have been crossed out, those who are not are still not present in the game.
A couple more:
- Redstone ore doesn't produce a sound when you right click on it, which causes a block state change. Relates to
MC-161151
- Entering a bed also doesn't make a sound, despite this changing the occupied block state to true.
- Certain projectiles don't have sounds when they collide with something (i.e. eggs, snowballs, ender pearls)
MC-161151 is another one
In 19w42a, as the fix for MC-161151, right clicking on redstone ore was made to play a hand animation. However, this hand animation is still played when clicking on already lit redstone ore.
Prior to 19w42a, right clicking on already lit redstone ore produced an extra burst of particles, and due to this I suggested that the hand animation be kept due to this. However, it seems as though as of 19w42a this extra particle burst feature has been removed, leaving the hand animation completely redundant.
There are two possible fixes for this issue:
- Reimplement the extra burst of particles that appear on the ore after subsequent clicks
- Remove the hand animation when clicking on already lit redstone ore
Probably caused by the fix for MC-161151.
Confirmed for 21w13a. This didn’t happen in 1.14.4. This was probably caused by the fix of MC-161151.
This didn’t happen in 1.14.4. This was probably caused by the fix of MC-161151.
Same applies to rotating items in an item frame. Do we have a ticket for this?
Tested rotation in 19w37a, it definitely has a hand animation now.
Aye! I've accidentally tested it in 1.14.4.
Might have been fixed alongside
MC-127094thenConfirmed in 19w38b.