The hand animation is inconsistent when right clicking redstone ore in different contexts
The bug
When right clicking a redstone ore block in different situations with different items, the hand animation's behavior will be inconsistent. In all cases, the redstone ore will activate, but sometimes the hand animation will, or won't play.
Steps to Reproduce:
- Place down redstone ore a few blocks into the air
- Stand in front of the redstone ore
- Try and place a solid block next to the ore (should not place, as you are blocking it)
→
Redstone ore is activated, hand animation doesn't play. - Try and place a lantern on a side of the redstone ore, with no support above or below it (so that it cannot be placed)
→ Redstone ore is activated, hand animation doesn't play. - Place a torch on a side of the redstone ore
- Right click the redstone ore itself with a torch (on the same side as the previously placed torch)
→
Redstone ore is activated, hand animation plays.
Video:
Linked Issues
relates to4
MC-161151Right clicking on redstone ore, which causes it to light up, plays no hand animationFixedMC-187462Holding right click on a button does not play a hand animation/activation sound for each activation
LowMC-213667Hand animation and sound sometimes don't play when dying a sheep blue while an evoker dyes it redConfirmedMC-225232Repairing an Iron Golem immediately after it takes damage sometimes doesn't play a hand animation
NormalAttachments1
![[Mod] Jiingy](../../../data/avatars/users/91802.png){kind=small}
Created Issue:
Right clicking redstone ore with a block that cannot be placed because it would intersect an entity or needs support, doesn’t play hand animation even though the redstone ore gets activated
The bug
When you right click redstone ore with a block that cannot be placed, because a player or mob is standing there, it doesn’t play the hand animation. If you right click it with a block that can’t be placed, because it needs support, it also doesn’t play the hand animation. However if you try to place a block on it, when the position is occupied by a different block, the hand animation does play.
How to reproduce:
- Place a redstone ore
- Hold a solid block in your hand, for example stone
- Look at the redstone
- Stand close to the redstone ore, so that you can’t place the block, but still target the redstone ore
- Right click
The bug
When you right click redstone ore with a block that cannot be placed, because a player or mob is standing there, it doesn’t play the hand animation. If you right click it with a block that can’t be placed, because it needs support (for example when trying to place a lantern without a block underneath or above it so that is would float), it also doesn’t play the hand animation. However if you try to place a block on it, when the position is occupied by a different block, the hand animation does play.
How to reproduce:
- Place a redstone ore
- Hold a solid block in your hand, for example stone
- Look at the redstone
- Stand close to the redstone ore, so that you can’t place the block, but still target the redstone ore
- Right click
![[Helper] Misode](../../../data/avatars/users/93314.png){kind=small}
![[Mojang] slicedlime](../../../data/assets/gravatar/slicedlime.jpeg){kind=small}
![[Mod] Michael Wobst](../../../data/avatars/users/37868.png){kind=small}
The bug
When you right click redstone ore with a block that cannot be placed, because a player or mob is standing there, it doesn’t play the hand animation. If you right click it with a block that can’t be placed, because it needs support (for example when trying to place a lantern without a block underneath or above it so that is would float), it also doesn’t play the hand animation. However if you try to place a block on it, when the position is occupied by a different block, the hand animation does play.
How to reproduce
:
- Place a redstone ore
- Hold a solid block in your hand, for example stone
- Look at the redstone
- Stand close to the redstone ore, so that you can’t place the block, but still target the redstone ore
- Right click
.The bug
When you right click redstone ore with a block that cannot be placed, because a player or mob is standing there, it doesn’t play the hand animation. If you right click it with a block that can’t be placed, because it needs support (for example when trying to place a lantern without a block underneath or above it so that is would float), it also doesn’t play the hand animation. However if you try to place a block on it, when the position is occupied by a different block, the hand animation does play.
How to reproduce
- Place a redstone ore
- Hold a solid block in your hand, for example stone
- Look at the redstone
- Stand close to the redstone ore, so that you can’t place the block, but still target the redstone ore
- Right click
→
The bug
When you right click redstone ore with a block that cannot be placed, because a player or mob is standing there, it doesn’t play the hand animation. If you right click it with a block that can’t be placed, because it needs support (for example when trying to place a lantern without a block underneath or above it so that is would float), it also doesn’t play the hand animation. However if you try to place a block on it, when the position is occupied by a different block, the hand animation does play. Also affects the new deepslate redstone ore.
How to reproduce
- Place a redstone ore
- Hold a solid block in your hand, for example stone
- Look at the redstone
- Stand close to the redstone ore, so that you can’t place the block, but still target the redstone ore
- Right click
→
![[Mod] SPGoding](../../../data/avatars/users/44622.png){kind=small}
relates to
![[Helper] Johnibur](../../../data/avatars/users/28381.png){kind=small}
![[Mod] turbo](../../../data/avatars/users/92867.png){kind=small}
![[Mod] Avoma](../../../data/avatars/users/86198.png){kind=small}
Right clicking redstone ore with a block that cannot be placed because it would intersect an entity or needs support, doesn’t play hand animation even though the redstone ore gets activatedThe hand animation is inconsistent when right clicking redstone ore in different contexts
The bug
When
youright click redstone orewith a block that cannot be placed, because a player or mob is standing there,itdoesn’t playthe hand animation. If you right click it with a block that can’t be placed, because it needs support (for example when trying to place a lantern without a block underneath or above it so that is would float),it also doesn’t play the hand animation. However if you try to place a block on it, when the position is occupied by a different block, the hand animation does play. Also affects the new deepslate redstone ore.
Howtoreproduce
- Place
aredstone oreHold a solid block in your hand, for examplestone- Look at the redstone
- Stand close to the redstone ore, so that you can’t place the block, but still target the redstone ore
Right click
→The hand animation didn’t play, even though the redstone orewas activatedandit emitted particlesThe bug
When right clicking a redstone ore block in different situations with different items, the hand animation's behavior will be inconsistent. In all cases, the redstone ore will activate, but sometimes the hand animation will, or won't play.
Steps to Reproduce:
- Place down redstone ore a few blocks into the air.
- Stand in front of the redstone ore
- Try and place a solid block next to the ore (should not place, as you are blocking it)
→- Try and place a lantern on a side of the redstone ore, with no support above or below it (so that it cannot be placed)
→- Place a torch on a side of the redstone ore
- Right click the redstone ore itself with a torch (on the same side as the previously placed torch)
→Video:
The bug
When right clicking a redstone ore block in different situations with different items, the hand animation's behavior will be inconsistent. In all cases, the redstone ore will activate, but sometimes the hand animation will, or won't play.
Steps to Reproduce:
- Place down redstone ore a few blocks into the air
.- Stand in front of the redstone ore
- Try and place a solid block next to the ore (should not place, as you are blocking it)
→- Try and place a lantern on a side of the redstone ore, with no support above or below it (so that it cannot be placed)
→- Place a torch on a side of the redstone ore
- Right click the redstone ore itself with a torch (on the same side as the previously placed torch)
→Video:
The bug
When right clicking a redstone ore block in different situations with different items, the hand animation's behavior will be inconsistent. In all cases, the redstone ore will activate, but sometimes the hand animation will, or won't play.
Steps to Reproduce:
- Place down redstone ore a few blocks into the air
- Stand in front of the redstone ore
- Try and place a solid block next to the ore (should not place, as you are blocking it)
→- Try and place a lantern on a side of the redstone ore, with no support above or below it (so that it cannot be placed)
→- Place a torch on a side of the redstone ore
- Right click the redstone ore itself with a torch (on the same side as the previously placed torch)
→Video:
Notes:
The bug
When right clicking a redstone ore block in different situations with different items, the hand animation's behavior will be inconsistent. In all cases, the redstone ore will activate, but sometimes the hand animation will, or won't play.
Steps to Reproduce:
- Place down redstone ore a few blocks into the air
- Stand in front of the redstone ore
- Try and place a solid block next to the ore (should not place, as you are blocking it)
→- Try and place a lantern on a side of the redstone ore, with no support above or below it (so that it cannot be placed)
→- Place a torch on a side of the redstone ore
- Right click the redstone ore itself with a torch (on the same side as the previously placed torch)
→Video:
Notes:
relates to
I can confirm for 1.16.3
Can confirm in 1.17.
Can confirm in 1.17.1.
Requesting ownership of this issue.