MC-21806Throwing an ender pearl through a portal into the nether works, throwing out of the nether doesn't
Throwing an ender pearl through a nether portal behaves differently depending on whether it is thrown from the overworld to the nether or from the nether to the overworld.
What I expected to happen
I expected to be teleported after following the pearl through the portal.
What actually happened
I was teleported after throwing an pearl and then entering the nether, but was not teleported after throwing a pearl and leaving the nether. It seems that the pearl is correctly transported one way, but not the other.
Steps to reproduce:
You need multiple nether portals behind each other, which can be created using
/fill ~1 ~ ~1 ~11 ~4 ~4 obsidian
/fill ~1 ~1 ~2 ~11 ~3 ~3 air
/fill ~1 ~1 ~2 ~11 ~1 ~2 fire
If you do that in the Overworld nothing happens until you enter the Nether, however when you do it in the Nether it teleports you where you would end up in the Overworld, for example 10000 becomes 80000 (times 8).
Suggested solutions
1) Have throwing a pearl from the nether to the overworld teleport the player after following the pearl through the portal.
2) Have the pearl become 'lost' (i.e. have no effect) regardless of the direction it is thrown. (Less desirable solution than option 1).
3) Have pearls not be affected by portals and continue in the same dimension (as if the portal wasn't there).
Untested related behaviour
I've not tested ender pearls with end portals. Perhaps check this too...
Linked Issues
Created Issue:
Throwing an ender pearl through a portal into the nether works, throwing out of the nether doesn't
Throwing an ender pearl through a nether portal behaves differently depending on whether it is thrown from the overworld to the nether or from the nether to the overworld.
What I expected to happen
I expected to be teleported after following the pearl through the portal.
What actually happened
I was teleported after throwing an pearl and then entering the nether, but was not teleported after throwing a pearl and leaving the nether. It seems that the pearl is correctly transported one way, but not the other.
Suggested solutions
1) Have throwing a pearl from the nether to the overworld teleport the player after following the pearl through the portal.
2) Have the pearl become 'lost' (i.e. have no effect) regardless of the direction it is thrown. (Less desirable solution than option 1).
3) Have pearls not be affected by portals and continue in the same dimension (as if the portal wasn't there).
Untested related behaviour
I've not tested ender pearls with end portals. Perhaps check this too...
![[Mod] Torabi](../../../data/assets/gravatar/torabi.png){kind=small}
![[Mod] Neko](../../../data/avatars/users/92901.png){kind=small}
Throwing an ender pearl through a nether portal behaves differently depending on whether it is thrown from the overworld to the nether or from the nether to the overworld.
What I expected to happen
I expected to be teleported after following the pearl through the portal.
What actually happened
I was teleported after throwing an pearl and then entering the nether, but was not teleported after throwing a pearl and leaving the nether. It seems that the pearl is correctly transported one way, but not the other.
Suggested solutions
1) Have throwing a pearl from the nether to the overworld teleport the player after following the pearl through the portal.
2) Have the pearl become 'lost' (i.e. have no effect) regardless of the direction it is thrown. (Less desirable solution than option 1).
3) Have pearls not be affected by portals and continue in the same dimension (as if the portal wasn't there).
Untested related behaviour
I've not tested ender pearls with end portals. Perhaps check this too...
Throwing an ender pearl through a nether portal behaves differently depending on whether it is thrown from the overworld to the nether or from the nether to the overworld.
What I expected to happen
I expected to be teleported after following the pearl through the portal.
What actually happened
I was teleported after throwing an pearl and then entering the nether, but was not teleported after throwing a pearl and leaving the nether. It seems that the pearl is correctly transported one way, but not the other.
Steps to reproduce:
You need multiple nether portals behind each other, which can be created using/fill ~ ~ ~ ~10 ~4 ~3 obsidian default hollowand then lighting them.
If you do that in the Overworld nothing happens until you enter the Nether, however when you do it in the Nether it teleports you where you would end up in the Overworld, for example 10000 becomes 80000 (times 8).
Suggested solutions
1) Have throwing a pearl from the nether to the overworld teleport the player after following the pearl through the portal.
2) Have the pearl become 'lost' (i.e. have no effect) regardless of the direction it is thrown. (Less desirable solution than option 1).
3) Have pearls not be affected by portals and continue in the same dimension (as if the portal wasn't there).
Untested related behaviour
I've not tested ender pearls with end portals. Perhaps check this too...
Please add that to the description
![[Mod] tryashtar](../../../data/avatars/users/41963.png){kind=small}
![[Mojang] Nathan Adams](../../../data/assets/gravatar/dinnerbone.png){kind=small}
![[Mod] NeunEinser](../../../data/avatars/users/39263.png){kind=small}
Throwing an ender pearl through a nether portal behaves differently depending on whether it is thrown from the overworld to the nether or from the nether to the overworld.
What I expected to happen
I expected to be teleported after following the pearl through the portal.
What actually happened
I was teleported after throwing an pearl and then entering the nether, but was not teleported after throwing a pearl and leaving the nether. It seems that the pearl is correctly transported one way, but not the other.
Steps to reproduce:
You need multiple nether portals behind each other, which can be created using/fill ~ ~ ~ ~10 ~4 ~3 obsidian default hollowand then lighting them.
If you do that in the Overworld nothing happens until you enter the Nether, however when you do it in the Nether it teleports you where you would end up in the Overworld, for example 10000 becomes 80000 (times 8).
Suggested solutions
1) Have throwing a pearl from the nether to the overworld teleport the player after following the pearl through the portal.
2) Have the pearl become 'lost' (i.e. have no effect) regardless of the direction it is thrown. (Less desirable solution than option 1).
3) Have pearls not be affected by portals and continue in the same dimension (as if the portal wasn't there).
Untested related behaviour
I've not tested ender pearls with end portals. Perhaps check this too...
Throwing an ender pearl through a nether portal behaves differently depending on whether it is thrown from the overworld to the nether or from the nether to the overworld.
What I expected to happen
I expected to be teleported after following the pearl through the portal.
What actually happened
I was teleported after throwing an pearl and then entering the nether, but was not teleported after throwing a pearl and leaving the nether. It seems that the pearl is correctly transported one way, but not the other.
Steps to reproduce:
You need multiple nether portals behind each other, which can be created using
If you do that in the Overworld nothing happens until you enter the Nether, however when you do it in the Nether it teleports you where you would end up in the Overworld, for example 10000 becomes 80000 (times 8).
Suggested solutions
1) Have throwing a pearl from the nether to the overworld teleport the player after following the pearl through the portal.
2) Have the pearl become 'lost' (i.e. have no effect) regardless of the direction it is thrown. (Less desirable solution than option 1).
3) Have pearls not be affected by portals and continue in the same dimension (as if the portal wasn't there).
Untested related behaviour
I've not tested ender pearls with end portals. Perhaps check this too...
is blocked by
Confirmed for
- 1.8.1-pre3 also Happy Halloween
After the crash I also got this, don't know if this is too great...[18:05:19] [Client Shutdown Thread/INFO]: Saving players [18:05:19] [Server thread/WARN]: handleDisconnection() called twice [18:05:19] [Client Shutdown Thread/INFO]: Marcono1234 lost connection: TextComponent{text='Server closed', siblings=[], style=Style{hasParent=false, color=null, bold=null, italic=null, underlined=null, obfuscated=null, clickEvent=null, hoverEvent=null, insertion=null}} AL lib: (EE) alc_cleanup: 1 device not closed
Also got this
[18:23:50] [pool-2-thread-2/ERROR]: Signature is missing from textures payload
It seems like this only happens, when the nether wasn't loaded already (but also not always)
Probably relates to:MC-21806
Also, throwing snowballs from the nether to the overworld (through a portal) causes pretty much lag
Confirmed.
The End does work correctly!
Is this still a concern in the current Minecraft version? If so, please update the affected versions in order to best aid Mojang ensuring bugs are still valid in the latest releases/pre-releases.
Yes, still broken in 1.6.2
I cannot reproduce being teleported either direction in 1.7.4/5.
Is this still a concern in the latest Minecraft version 14w08a? If so, please update the affected versions in order to best aid Mojang ensuring bugs are still valid in the latest releases/pre-releases.
I'm still seeing the original reported behaviour in 1.75 (though the teleport is now not in the direction I would expect for the orientation of the portal - I land somewhere to the side of the portal, not in front/behind it).
In 14w10b I'm not getting teleported whichever way I go through the portal.
I suspect this change of behaviour with the snapshot could be caused by the change of player identification to UUIDs and that the link between the thrown pearl and the player is now broken on going through the portal.
Confirmed for 14w29b.
I attempted to recreate this in 1.8, Nothing happens and this errir appears in the GameOutput.
Confirmed for
Confirmed for 15w43c & 1.8.8.
Confirmed for 15w44a.
Confirmed for 15w51b
https://youtu.be/iczUGtd0V6k
Cannot reproduce. These days ender pearls appear to always pass through portals.retracted.Confirmed for
Please include that you need multiple nether portals behind each other, which can be created using
/fill ~ ~ ~ ~10 ~4 ~3 obsidian default hollowand then lighting them.
If you do that in the Overworld nothing happens until you enter the Nether, however when you do it in the Nether it teleports you where you would end up in the Overworld, for example 10000 becomes 80000 (times 8).
Is this still an issue in the latest snapshot 16w44a?
Still a problem in 1.11.2. Like Ethoslab showed in his lets play. and Antvenom showed to get to the world border
How to reproduce and what really happens in 1.11.2 (this changed from the original post)
1 Make a portal
2 Stand in the portal and look down
3 throw an ender pearl straight down
4 get out of the portal before you get to the other world
What will happen:
Overworld: your X and Z coordinates will be divided by 8 and you will be teleported there
Nether: your X and Z coordinates will be times 8 and you will be teleported there
Confirmed for 1.12-pre7
Is this still an issue in 20w06a?
Appears to be blocked by
MC-172031.