Item and XP drops are sucked towards the player's feet instead of their chest/torso
Possibly due to Grum's noted 14w06a change: Grum's techy notes on Twitter.
Fixed server referencing Entities by origin, client referencing by eyes (!!)
In first person mode, items and XP orbs no longer fly towards the player's hand (eyes, really) upon pickup, instead flying and being absorbed into the player's feet, where the origin of the entity supposedly is.
This is an awkward aesthetic bug which can be troublesome; sometimes you cannot see whether you've picked an item up because it's flown into your feet, not your chest where you can see it every time.
Compare with versions before 14w06a/1.8 to see the difference.
Linked Issues
is duplicated by22
MC-48584Items are collected into feetDuplicateMC-54032No item pickup animationDuplicateMC-54038Arrow poof into your inventoryDuplicateMC-54547Pick up items have no animation.DuplicateMC-54846Items no longer animate when picked upDuplicateMC-54903AnimationDuplicateMC-54949Items don't move toward player when picked upDuplicateMC-57931Blocks dont drag into your body when you pick up blocksDuplicateMC-57946Missing Item AnimationDuplicateMC-59710Picking up item bug/breaking blocksDuplicateMC-59804No pickup animationDuplicateMC-62412No item pick up animationDuplicateMC-62518Баг который не все заметили!DuplicateMC-65142Items don't appear to fly into your character when picked up, just disappears.DuplicateMC-65445When trying to pick up items there is no animation to go with it.DuplicateMC-65703No item pick-up animationDuplicateMC-65809Dropped Items do not fly towards players when picked upDuplicateMC-65949When picking up items/blocks does not show item being pulled towards your player.DuplicateMC-66177no picj up animation, instantly goes into inventoryDuplicateMC-66178no pick up animation DuplicateMC-67207No Pick up animation DuplicateMC-68088Item pickup animationDuplicate
![[Mod] NeunEinser](../../../data/avatars/users/39263.png){kind=small}
Created Issue:
Item and XP drops are sucked towards the player's feet instead of their chest/torso
Possibly due to grum's noted 14w06 change:
"14w06
Fixed server referencing Entities by origin, client referencing by eyes (!!)"Items and XP orbs no longer fly towards the player's hand (eyes, really) upon pickup, instead flying and being absorbed into the player's feet, where the origin of the entity supposedly is. This is an awkward aesthetic bug which can be troublesome; sometimes you cannot see whether you've picked an item up because it's flown into your feet, not your chest where you can see it every time.
Sorry if duplicate, I've searched and have not found a report for this issue.
Environment
Java 7u51 64 bit, windows 8
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
Working as Intended.
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
This error does for all gameplay because all players got used that XP and blocks, objects and all other in Minecraft that can be held in a hand does not fly to the player as before(
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
![[Mojang] Grum (Erik Broes)](../../../data/assets/gravatar/grum.png){kind=small}
[Mojang] Grum (Erik Broes)![[Mod] Torabi](../../../data/assets/gravatar/torabi.png){kind=small}
Fixed in 1.8.2-pre6, possibly earlier.
A comment with security level 'global-moderators' was removed.
relates to
No, this bug behaves the same in 15w51b as 1.8.9, and in 1.8.9
MC-11519isn't fixed.
Affects 15w51b & 1.8.9
![[Mod] Michael Wobst](../../../data/avatars/users/37868.png){kind=small}
Possibly due to grum's noted 14w06 change:
"14w06Fixed server referencing Entities by origin, client referencing by eyes (!!)"Items and XP orbs no longer fly towards the player's hand (eyes, really) upon pickup, instead flying and being absorbed into the player's feet, where the origin of the entity supposedly is. This is an awkward aesthetic bug which can be troublesome; sometimes you cannot see whether you've picked an item up because it's flown into your feet, not your chest where you can see it every time.
Sorry if duplicate, I've searched and have not found a report for this issue.
Possibly due to Grum's noted 14w06a change: Grum's techy notes on Twitter
Fixed server referencing Entities by origin, client referencing by eyes (!!)In first person mode, items and XP orbs no longer fly towards the player's hand (eyes, really) upon pickup, instead flying and being absorbed into the player's feet, where the origin of the entity supposedly is.
This is an awkward aesthetic bug which can be troublesome; sometimes you cannot see whether you've picked an item up because it's flown into your feet, not your chest where you can see it every time.
Java 7u51 64 bit, windows 8
Possibly due to Grum's noted 14w06a change: Grum's techy notes on Twitter
Fixed server referencing Entities by origin, client referencing by eyes (!!)In first person mode, items and XP orbs no longer fly towards the player's hand (eyes, really) upon pickup, instead flying and being absorbed into the player's feet, where the origin of the entity supposedly is.
This is an awkward aesthetic bug which can be troublesome; sometimes you cannot see whether you've picked an item up because it's flown into your feet, not your chest where you can see it every time.Possibly due to Grum's noted 14w06a change: Grum's techy notes on Twitter.
Fixed server referencing Entities by origin, client referencing by eyes (!!)In first person mode, items and XP orbs no longer fly towards the player's hand (eyes, really) upon pickup, instead flying and being absorbed into the player's feet, where the origin of the entity supposedly is.
This is an awkward aesthetic bug which can be troublesome; sometimes you cannot see whether you've picked an item up because it's flown into your feet, not your chest where you can see it every time.Compare with versions before 14w06a/1.8 to see the difference.
![[Mod] Pokechu22](../../../data/avatars/users/92931.png){kind=small}
relates to
![[Mojang] Nathan Adams](../../../data/assets/gravatar/dinnerbone.png){kind=small}
ProfMobius (Thomas Guimbretiere)![[Mod] CubeTheThird](../../../data/assets/gravatar/cubethethird.jpeg){kind=small}
Duplicate of MC-48577?
Duplicate of MC-48577
At 50...60 fps I can see the movement animation, see my screenshots in MC-48577
Dupe of MC-48577
Dupe of MC-48577
Dupe of MC-48577
Dupe of MC-48577
Dupe of MC-48577
Dupe of MC-48577
Duplicate of MC-48577
Duplicate of MC-48577
Duplicate of MC-48577
Dupe of MC-48577
How to reproduce:
- Put item on a block that is on the ground.
- Stand on the ground next to the block.
Result: On the way towards the player's feet, the item goes through the block.
Note: This bug could also occur if MC-48577 was fixed, the way to reproduce it would just be different.
This might be working as intended or "won't fix", but I created a report so that there can be an official answer to if it is.
Still in 14w11b
I thought I saw this in the update log from one of the 1.8 snapshots
This is not WIA.
Grum's technical notes say that client now references by origin of entity now as of 14w06a.
https://s3.amazonaws.com/Minecraft.Download/blocknotes.txt
This is used to play the animation effect (entity is rendered flying from the ground to the entity picking it up's position). Position on the client used to be the eye level, but it was refactored in 14w06, so this animation now flies to a point much lower.
Looking at Mojang's post for 14w06a: https://mojang.com/2014/02/minecraft-snapshot-14w06a/
No mention whatsoever of this "intended change".
Besides it makes no aesthetic sense nor does it satisfy any need for change. Many times you can no longer tell what or if an item has been picked up because it goes under you, not into your chest.
Please reopen.
I don't know who marked this as affecting 14w18a. In that snapshot there is no pickup animation at all.
It's still there but plays super fast, so it's almost like there wasn't one at all.
The effects of this bug still apply too, further reducing awareness of whether an item was picked up or not.
This is one of the most core animations mc has had, hope Mojang doesn't botch this up too o.o
Still in 14w27b. In 1.7.10 it works as expected.
This mistake spoils all gameplay because all players got used that XP and blocks, subjects and all the rest in Minecraft that it is possible to hold in hand don't fly to the player as earlier (
An annoying bug when picking up items coloured similarly to surrounding blocks (common!). It is especially irritating in dark conditions such as collecting clay underwater, as it makes it hard to tell straight away whether an item has been picked up.
Still an issue in 14w32a. Info for the Mojang devs: in 1.7.10 it works as expected.
Well, this probably fixes
MC-11519, though [Mojang] Grum (Erik Broes)'s notes suggests the change wasn't made specifically for that reason. I'm a little surprised it doesn't appear to have fixedMC-460, since that is reportedly caused by a client-server position mismatch.Big bug. I really wish mojang would fix this, this seems like the kindof bug they miss in the snapshot and never fix.
A visual annoyance is barely a big bug. There's plenty of bigger fish to fry.
"barely a big bug" is still a bug.
Yes, and so are most of the other ~2900 open issues. Are you saying this one is more important than all of those?
I never said anything about this one being more important than the others, but as this issue has been open for 6 months and still isn't fixed, perhaps it is time for further action (such as a repost.) No need to be rude.
In case there's any doubt, it's never time for a repost. That just clutters up the bug tracker and causes more work for the moderation team. This ticket is still open, and not even close to being the oldest one. I cannot see how either Mustek or my comments qualify as "rude". Everyone considers different bugs to be more or less important, which is why the tracker has a voting system to allow Mojang to get a feel for popular opinion on the matter. Comments that do not include any new information about a bug aren't going to help it get fixed any faster, and instead only annoy anyone watching the issue.
14w34c: Items and XP still fly towards my feet.
^ yes. In third person mode they fly to the eyes, but in first person they fly somewhere in between the feet and eyes. It's not as bad as it was before but still looks like we're absorbing blocks into our crotches or something, haha.
Your hands are somewhere between your feet and your eyes, so that sounds like an improvement over either of the previous behaviors. But yes, it does still seem a bit low when trying it out.
Still an issue in 1.8-pre2.
Still an issue in 1.8.
Still an issue in Minecraft 1.8.1
After testing, I can confirm this issue is fixed in 1.8.2-pre6, possibly earlier.
No, cannot confirm it's fixed in 1.8.2-pre6. Also please note that this issues mostly applies to first person view.
This is only partially fixed in 14w34c+. It looks completely fine in third person view (items fly towards the player's hands / head area). In first person mode, however, the items still fly a little lower than they used to, now flying somewhere towards the waist/crotch area. Compare with 1.7.10 for proper behavior.
Still an issue in 1.8.8 and all 1.9 snapshots.
Caused by the fix of
MC-11519XP is fixed in 15w51b, didn't test items.
I tried to recreate, but the Movement of Items and XP Orbs are directed towards the players hip/torso. This Issue is fixed in 1.13.1-pre1.
... or fixed in 1.13 ?
Yes actually! In 1.13 it's the same behaviour. Fixed.
No, this is still not fixed. Nothing has changed here. Also don't get mislead by the attached screenshots. It's about first person mode.
Confirmed for 1.13.1.
The items are not necessarily moving towards the feet, as some already stated. They move towards the knees/torso it looks like from first person.
If that is the bug, then it's affecting 1.14.4 and 1.15-pre1.
I can't reproduce this in 20w07a, xp gets sucked to my torso:
This is the intended height as evident by ProfMobius (Thomas Guimbretiere)'s comment in
MC-11519