MC-110903Cannot remove horse saddle using /replaceitem
The bug
Using /replaceitem you cannot set the horse saddle to air (remove it), one would expect it to function the same as any other slot.
How to reproduce
- Summon a horse:
/summon horse ~ ~ ~ {Tame:1} - Add a saddle:
/replaceitem entity @e[type=horse,limit=1] horse.saddle saddle
→
See "Replaced a slot on Horse with [Saddle]" - Try to remove the saddle:
/replaceitem entity @e[type=horse,limit=1] horse.saddle air
→
See "Could not put [Air] in slot 400"
Code analysis
The following is based on a decompiled version of Minecraft using MCP for 1.11.
The replaceItemInInventory() method in class net.minecraft.entity.passive.AbstractHorse requires the item to be a saddle at all times:
if (i == 0 && itemStackIn.getItem() != Items.SADDLE) { return false; }
This is unlike other mob equipment such as ArmorItems, where the contents can be deleted by replacing with "air".
![[Mod] Urielsalis](../../../data/assets/gravatar/urielsalis.jpeg){kind=small}
Created Issue:
Cannot remove horse saddle using /replaceitem
Using /replaceitem you cannot set the horse saddle to air (remove it), one would expect it to function the same as any other slot.
![[Mod] Skylinerw](../../../data/assets/gravatar/skylinerw.png){kind=small}
Using /replaceitem you cannot set the horse saddle to air (remove it), one would expect it to function the same as any other slot.
Code analysis using MCP for 1.11:
The replaceItemInInventory() method in class net.minecraft.entity.passive.AbstractHorse requires the item to be a saddle at all times:
if (i == 0 && itemStackIn.getItem() != Items.SADDLE) { return false; }This is unlike other mob equipment such as ArmorItems , where the contents can be deleted by replacing with "air".
![[Mod] tryashtar](../../../data/avatars/users/41963.png){kind=small}
Using /replaceitem you cannot set the horse saddle to air (remove it), one would expect it to function the same as any other slot.
Steps to reproduce:
- Summon a horse:
/summon horse ~ ~ ~ {Tame:1}- Add a saddle:
/replaceitem entity @e[type=horse,limit=1] horse.saddle saddle- See "Replaced a slot on Horse with [Saddle]"
- try to remove the saddle:
/replaceitem entity @e[type=horse,limit=1] horse.saddle air- See "The target does not have the specified slot"
Code analysis using MCP for 1.11:
The replaceItemInInventory() method in class net.minecraft.entity.passive.AbstractHorse requires the item to be a saddle at all times:
if (i == 0 && itemStackIn.getItem() != Items.SADDLE) { return false; }This is unlike other mob equipment such as ArmorItems, where the contents can be deleted by replacing with "air".
Using /replaceitem you cannot set the horse saddle to air (remove it), one would expect it to function the same as any other slot.
Steps to reproduce:
- Summon a horse:
/summon horse ~ ~ ~ {Tame:1}- Add a saddle:
/replaceitem entity @e[type=horse,limit=1] horse.saddle saddle- See "Replaced a slot on Horse with [Saddle]"
- try to remove the saddle:
/replaceitem entity @e[type=horse,limit=1] horse.saddle air- See "The target does not have the specified slot"
Code analysis using MCP for 1.11:
The replaceItemInInventory() method in class net.minecraft.entity.passive.AbstractHorse requires the item to be a saddle at all times:if (i == 0 && itemStackIn.getItem() != Items.SADDLE) { return false; }This is unlike other mob equipment such as ArmorItems, where the contents can be deleted by replacing with "air".
The bug
Using /replaceitem you cannot set the horse saddle to air (remove it), one would expect it to function the same as any other slot.
How to reproduce
- Summon a horse:
/summon horse ~ ~ ~ {Tame:1}- Add a saddle:
/replaceitem entity @e[type=horse,limit=1] horse.saddle saddle- See "Replaced a slot on Horse with [Saddle]"
- try to remove the saddle:
/replaceitem entity @e[type=horse,limit=1] horse.saddle air- See "Could not put [Air] in slot 400"
Code analysis
The following is based on a decompiled version of Minecraft using MCP for 1.11.
The replaceItemInInventory() method in class net.minecraft.entity.passive.AbstractHorse requires the item to be a saddle at all times:if (i == 0 && itemStackIn.getItem() != Items.SADDLE) { return false; }This is unlike other mob equipment such as ArmorItems, where the contents can be deleted by replacing with "air".
![[Mod] Neko](../../../data/avatars/users/92901.png){kind=small}
![[Mojang] Nathan Adams](../../../data/assets/gravatar/dinnerbone.png){kind=small}
![[Mod] Michael Wobst](../../../data/avatars/users/37868.png){kind=small}
The bug
Using /replaceitem you cannot set the horse saddle to air (remove it), one would expect it to function the same as any other slot.
How to reproduce
- Summon a horse:
/summon horse ~ ~ ~ {Tame:1}- Add a saddle:
/replaceitem entity @e[type=horse,limit=1] horse.saddle saddle- See "Replaced a slot on Horse with [Saddle]"
- try to remove the saddle:
/replaceitem entity @e[type=horse,limit=1] horse.saddle air- See "Could not put [Air] in slot 400"
Code analysis
The following is based on a decompiled version of Minecraft using MCP for 1.11.
The replaceItemInInventory() method in class net.minecraft.entity.passive.AbstractHorse requires the item to be a saddle at all times:if (i == 0 && itemStackIn.getItem() != Items.SADDLE) { return false; }This is unlike other mob equipment such as ArmorItems, where the contents can be deleted by replacing with "air".
The bug
Using /replaceitem you cannot set the horse saddle to air (remove it), one would expect it to function the same as any other slot.
How to reproduce
- Summon a horse:
/summon horse ~ ~ ~ {Tame:1}- Add a saddle:
/replaceitem entity @e[type=horse,limit=1] horse.saddle saddle→
- Try to remove the saddle:
/replaceitem entity @e[type=horse,limit=1] horse.saddle air→
Code analysis
The following is based on a decompiled version of Minecraft using MCP for 1.11.
The replaceItemInInventory() method in class net.minecraft.entity.passive.AbstractHorse requires the item to be a saddle at all times:if (i == 0 && itemStackIn.getItem() != Items.SADDLE) { return false; }This is unlike other mob equipment such as ArmorItems, where the contents can be deleted by replacing with "air".
![[Helper] Johnibur](../../../data/avatars/users/28381.png){kind=small}
![[Mod] violine1101](../../../data/avatars/users/92858.png){kind=small}
![[Mod] NeunEinser](../../../data/avatars/users/39263.png){kind=small}
relates to
![[Mojang] slicedlime](../../../data/assets/gravatar/slicedlime.jpeg){kind=small}
relates to
Confirmed for 1.16.1
Confirmed for 20w28a
Confirmed for 1.16-pre8
Confirmed for 1.16-pre6
Confirmed for 1.16-pre5
Confirmed for 1.16-pre4
Confirmed for 1.16-rc1
Confirmed for 20w22a
Confirmed for 20w20b
Confirmed for 20w20a
Confirmed for 20w19a
Confirmed for 20w18a
Confirmed for 20w17a
Confirmed for 20w16a
Confirmed for 20w15a
Confirmed for 1.15.2-pre2
Confirmed for 1.15.1
Confirmed for 20w14a
Confirmed for 1.16-pre7
Confirmed for 20w21a
Confirmed for 20w06a
The bug
MC-110903 was fixed in 20w46 snapshot and resolved the issue of replacing a saddle with air for horses.
The issue does however still remain for donkeys/mules/skeleton horses/zombie horses. The saddle can't be manipulated at all for these entities using the item command.
For all of these entities the player can manually add/remove saddles from them.
How to reproduce
- Summon a donkey/mule:/skeleton horse/zombie horse
/summon donkey ~ ~ ~ {Tame:1} /summon mule ~ ~ ~ {Tame:1} /summon skeleton_horse ~ ~ ~ {Tame:1} /summon zombie_horse ~ ~ ~ {Tame:1}
- Try to Add a saddle:
/item entity @e[type=donkey,limit=1] horse.saddle replace saddle /item entity @e[type=mule,limit=1] horse.saddle replace saddle /item entity @e[type=skeleton_horse,limit=1] horse.saddle replace saddle /item entity @e[type=zombie_horse,limit=1] horse.saddle replace saddle
→
See "No targets accepted item [Saddle] into slot 400"
- Try to remove the saddle:
/item entity @e[type=donkey,limit=1] horse.saddle replace air /item entity @e[type=mule,limit=1] horse.saddle replace air /item entity @e[type=skeleton_horse,limit=1] horse.saddle replace air /item entity @e[type=zombie_horse,limit=1] horse.saddle replace air
→
See "No targets accepted item [Air] into slot 400"
Expected Result
Was expecting this to behave the same way as it does for horses.
- Summon a horse
/summon horse ~ ~ ~ {Tame:1}
- Try to Add a saddle:
/item entity @e[type=horse,limit=1] horse.saddle replace saddle
→
See "Replaced a slot on Horse with [Saddle]"
- Try to remove the saddle:
/item entity @e[type=horse,limit=1] horse.saddle replace air
→
See "Replaced a slot on Horse with [Air]"
In 20w29a
Still an issue for Mules/Donkeys/Zombie Horses/Skeleton Horses.
Created
MC-205220