MC-83013End pillars generate without ground to generate on
The bug
For some seeds the end generates without or too less end stone beneath some obsidian pillars. This would prevent a fix for MC-86654 from working for these cases.
How to reproduce
Seed: 1194164352143763445 Coordinates: /execute in minecraft:the_end run tp @s 10.40 37.65 35.55 326.11 53.71
Seed: 3947383662603549734 Coordinates: /execute in minecraft:the_end run tp @s -0.65 53.00 -30.70 848.10 35.10
Suggested solution
Place some end stone around y=62 when generating obsidian pillars.
Linked Issues
Low
![[Mod] Avoma](../../../data/avatars/users/86198.png){kind=small}
Created Issue:
Extra Obsidian Tower Out of Place
When I went to the End to fight the Ender Dragon and look at all of the new End stuff, I was flying around and saw an extra obsidian tower with an Ender Crystal floating underneath the island.
So far I've only seen it in one world (the first one I made, what are the odds?)
Seed: -2699160148021300249
Attachments3
When I went to the End to fight the Ender Dragon and look at all of the new End stuff, I was flying around and saw an extra obsidian tower with an Ender Crystal floating underneath the island.
So far I've only seen it in one world (the first one I made, what are the odds?)
Seed: -2699160148021300249To Recreate:
1. Create a New World with the above seed in Creative
2. Create an End Portal/Find the Stronghold
3. Go into the End and fly under the island
When I went to the End to fight the Ender Dragon and look at all of the new End stuff, I was flying around and saw an extra obsidian tower with an Ender Crystal floating underneath the island.
So far I've only seen it in one world (the first one I made, what are the odds?), but I'm currently looking for more
Seed: -2699160148021300249To Recreate:
1. Create a New World with the above seed in Creative
2. Create an End Portal/Find the Stronghold
3. Go into the End and fly under the island
is duplicated by
ExtraObsidian Tower Out of PlaceObsidian Towers Out of Place
When I went to the End to fight the Ender Dragon and look at all of the new End stuff, I was flying around and saw an extra obsidian tower with an Ender Crystal floating underneath the island.
So far I've only seen it in one world (the first one I made, what are the odds?), but I'm currently looking for more
Seed: -2699160148021300249To Recreate:
1. Create a New World with the above seed in Creative
2. Create an End Portal/Find the Stronghold
3. Go into the End and fly under the islandWhen experimenting with the new End, I noticed
So far I've only seen it in one world (the first one I made, what are the odds?), but I'm currently looking for more
Seed:To Recreate:
1. Create a New World with the above seed in Creative
2. Create an End Portal/Find the Stronghold
3. Go into the End and fly under the island
When experimenting with the new End, I noticed
So far I've only seen it in one world (the first one I made, what are the odds?), but I'm currently looking for more
Seed:To Recreate:
1. Create a New World with the above seed in Creative
2. Create an End Portal/Find the Stronghold
3. Go into the End and fly under the islandWhen experimenting with the new End, I noticed that some of the pillars are generating badly.
It seems that when that since the pillars generate in set positions, if there is no End Stone to generate on, the pillar is lowered.So far I've only seen it in one world (the first one I made, what are the odds?), but I'm currently looking for more
Seed: -2699160148021300249http://i.imgur.com/Ql3j5wT.png
To Recreate:
1. Create a New World with the above seed in Creative
2. Create an End Portal/Find the Stronghold
3. Go into the End and fly under the island
When experimenting with the new End, I noticed that some of the pillars are generating badly.
It seems that when that since the pillars generate in set positions, if there is no End Stone to generate on, the pillar is lowered.
So far I've only seen it in one world (the first one I made, what are the odds?), but I'm currently looking for more
Seed: -2699160148021300249
http://i.imgur.com/Ql3j5wT.pngTo Re
create:
1. Create a New World with the above seed in Creative
2. Create an End Portal/Find the Stronghold
3. Go into the End and fly under the islandWhen experimenting with the new End, I noticed that some of the pillars are generating badly.
It seems that when that since the pillars generate in set positions, if there is no End Stone to generate on, the pillar is lowered. I actually found one world where the entire pillar is floating beneath the island. Seed for this one is: -2699160148021300249Video from CaptainSparklez with lowered towers:
https://youtu.be/icqQwSFkZ8Q?t=3472Another image, linked by Classified reporter of
MC-83330
http://i.imgur.com/Ql3j5wT.pngTo Reproduce:
Since it is a flaw in generation, the already shown examples could be recreated, but other reproduction would need to be done through lucky random generation, so simply create a new world, go to the End, and check.
When experimenting with the new End, I noticed that some of the pillars are generating badly.
It seems that when that since the pillars generate in set positions, if there is no End Stone to generate on, the pillar is lowered. I actually found one world where the entire pillar is floating beneath the island. Seed for this one is: -2699160148021300249Video from CaptainSparklez with lowered towers visible:
https://youtu.be/icqQwSFkZ8Q?t=3472Another image, linked by Classified reporter of
MC-83330
http://i.imgur.com/Ql3j5wT.pngTo Reproduce:
Since it is a flaw in generation, the already shown examples could be recreated, but other reproduction would need to be done through lucky random generation, so simply create a new world, go to the End, and check.
When experimenting with the new End, I noticed that some of the pillars are generating badly.
It seems that when that since the pillars generate in set positions, if there is no End Stone to generate on, the pillar is lowered. I actually found one world where the entire pillar is floating beneath the island. Seed for this one is: -2699160148021300249Video from CaptainSparklez with lowered tower
svisible:
https://youtu.be/icqQwSFkZ8Q?t=3472Another image, linked by Classified reporter of
MC-83330
http://i.imgur.com/Ql3j5wT.pngTo Reproduce:
Since it is a flaw in generation, the already shown examples could be recreated, but other reproduction would need to be done through lucky random generation, so simply create a new world, go to the End, and check.When experimenting with the new End, I noticed that some of the pillars are generating badly.
It seems that when that since the pillars generate in set positions, if there is no End Stone to generate on, the pillar is lowered. I actually found one world where the entire pillar is floating beneath the island. Seed for this one is: -2699160148021300249Video from CaptainSparklez with a lowered tower visible:
https://youtu.be/icqQwSFkZ8Q?t=3472Another image, linked by Classified reporter of
MC-83330
http://i.imgur.com/Ql3j5wT.pngTo Reproduce:
Since it is a flaw in generation, the already shown examples could be recreated, but other reproduction would need to be done through lucky random generation, so simply create a new world, go to the End, and check.
![[Mojang] Nathan Adams](../../../data/assets/gravatar/dinnerbone.png){kind=small}
[Mojang] Nathan Adamsis duplicated by
Obsidian Towers Out of PlaceEnd pillars generate below the island
is duplicated by
relates to
is duplicated by
End pillars generatebelow the islandEnd pillars generate without ground to generate on
is duplicated by
[Mojang] Nathan AdamsBest observed on seed -1985377277835010495. Suggested fix: Place some endstone around y=62 when generating obsidian pillars.
When experimenting with the new End, I noticed that some of the pillars are generating badly.
It seems that when that since the pillars generate in set positions, if there is no End Stone to generate on, the pillar is lowered. I actually found one world where the entire pillar is floating beneath the island. Seed for this one is: -2699160148021300249Video from CaptainSparklez with a lowered tower visible:
https://youtu.be/icqQwSFkZ8Q?t=3472Another image, linked by Classified reporter of
MC-83330
http://i.imgur.com/Ql3j5wT.pngTo Reproduce:
Since it is a flaw in generation, the already shown examples could be recreated, but other reproduction would need to be done through lucky random generation, so simply create a new world, go to the End, and check.
![[Mojang] Grum (Erik Broes)](../../../data/assets/gravatar/grum.png){kind=small}
![[Mojang] Jeb (Jens Bergensten)](../../../data/assets/gravatar/jeb.jpeg){kind=small}
[Mojang] Jeb (Jens Bergensten)![[Mod] Neko](../../../data/avatars/users/92901.png){kind=small}
![[Mod] Michael Wobst](../../../data/avatars/users/37868.png){kind=small}
Is this still an issue in the most recent versions (currently that is 1.10.2, or 16w42a) of Minecraft? If so, please update the affected versions and help us keeping this ticket updated from time to time. If you are the owner/reporter of this ticket, you can modify the affected version(s) yourself.
Best observed on seed -1985377277835010495. Suggested fix: Place some endstone around y=62 when generating obsidian pillars.
When experimenting with the new End, I noticed that some of the pillars are generating badly.
It seems that when that since the pillars generate in set positions, if there is no End Stone to generate on, the pillar is lowered. I actually found one world where the entire pillar is floating beneath the island. Seed for this one is: -2699160148021300249
VideofromCaptainSparklez with a lowered tower visible:
https://youtu.be/icqQwSFkZ8Q?t=3472Another image, linked by Classified reporter of
MC-83330
http://i.imgur.com/Ql3j5wT.pngTo Reproduce:
Since it is a flaw in generation, the already shown examples could be recreated, but other reproduction would need to be done through lucky random generation, so simply create a new world, go to the End, and check.The bug
For some seeds the end generates without or too less end stone beneath some obsidian pillars. This can cause them to spawn too low and would prevent a fix for MC-86654 from working for these cases.
Seeds
- -1985377277835010495
- 8627439086671208170
- -2699160148021300249
Suggested solution
Place some end stone around y=62 when generating obsidian pillars.
The bug
For some seeds the end generates without or too less end stone beneath some obsidian pillars. This
can cause them to spawn too low andwould prevent a fix for MC-86654 from working for these cases.Seeds
- -1985377277835010495
- 8627439086671208170
- -2699160148021300249
Suggested solution
Place some end stone around y=62 when generating obsidian pillars.
The bug
For some seeds the end generates without or too less end stone beneath some obsidian pillars. This would prevent a fix for MC-86654 from working for these cases.
Seeds
- -1985377277835010495
- 8627439086671208170
- -2699160148021300249
Suggested solution
Place some end stone around y=62 when generating obsidian pillars.
The bug
For some seeds the end generates without or too less end stone beneath some obsidian pillars. This would prevent a fix for MC-86654 from working for these cases.
How to reproduce
Seed: -953538683905638291 Coordinates: /execute in minecraft:the_end run tp @s 37.79 57.79 -12.46 700.24 34.74Suggested solution
Place some end stone around y=62 when generating obsidian pillars.
[Mojang] Jeb (Jens Bergensten)![[Mod] Urielsalis](../../../data/assets/gravatar/urielsalis.jpeg){kind=small}
The bug
For some seeds the end generates without or too less end stone beneath some obsidian pillars. This would prevent a fix for MC-86654 from working for these cases.
How to reproduce
Seed: -953538683905638291 Coordinates:/execute in minecraft:the_end run tp @s 37.79 57.79 -12.46 700.24 34.74Suggested solution
Place some end stone around y=62 when generating obsidian pillars.
The bug
For some seeds the end generates without or too less end stone beneath some obsidian pillars. This would prevent a fix for MC-86654 from working for these cases.
How to reproduce
Seed-953538683905638291Coordinates/execute in minecraft:the_end run tp @s 37.79 57.79 -12.46 700.24 34.74Suggested solution
Place some end stone around y=62 when generating obsidian pillars.
![[Mod] violine1101](../../../data/avatars/users/92858.png){kind=small}
![[Helper] gaspoweredpick](../../../data/avatars/users/80904.png){kind=small}
Feature request
![[Mojang] Adrian Östergård](../../../data/assets/gravatar/nighter.jpeg){kind=small}
![[Mod] ampolive](../../../data/avatars/users/18949.svg){kind=small}
The bug
For some seeds the end generates without or too less end stone beneath some obsidian pillars. This would prevent a fix for MC-86654 from working for these cases.
How to reproduce
Seed-953538683905638291Coordinates/execute in minecraft:the_end run tp @s 37.79 57.79 -12.46 700.24 34.74Suggested solution
Place some end stone around y=62 when generating obsidian pillars.
The bug
For some seeds the end generates without or too less end stone beneath some obsidian pillars. This would prevent a fix for MC-86654 from working for these cases.
How to reproduce
Version: 1.19.2Seed: -953538683905638291 Coordinates: /execute in minecraft:the_end run tp @s 35.50 48.00 7.57 224.47 37.13Suggested solution
Place some end stone around y=62 when generating obsidian pillars.
![[Mojang] slicedlime](../../../data/assets/gravatar/slicedlime.jpeg){kind=small}
The bug
For some seeds the end generates without or too less end stone beneath some obsidian pillars. This would prevent a fix for MC-86654 from working for these cases.
How to reproduce
Version: 1.19.2Seed: -953538683905638291 Coordinates: /execute in minecraft:the_end run tp @s 35.50 48.00 7.57 224.47 37.13Suggested solution
Place some end stone around y=62 when generating obsidian pillars.
The bug
For some seeds the end generates without or too less end stone beneath some obsidian pillars. This would prevent a fix for MC-86654 from working for these cases.
How to reproduce
Version: 1.19.2Seed: -953538683905638291 Coordinates: /execute in minecraft:the_end run tp @s 35.50 48.00 7.57 224.47 37.13Version: 1.20.4Seed: 3947383662603549734 Coordinates: /execute in minecraft:the_end run tp @s -0.65 53.00 -30.70 848.10 35.10Suggested solution
Place some end stone around y=62 when generating obsidian pillars.
The bug
For some seeds the end generates without or too less end stone beneath some obsidian pillars. This would prevent a fix for MC-86654 from working for these cases.
How to reproduce
Version:1.19.2Seed:-953538683905638291Coordinates: /execute in minecraft:the_end run tp @s35.50 48.00 7.57 224.47 37.13Version: 1.20.4Seed: 3947383662603549734 Coordinates: /execute in minecraft:the_end run tp @s -0.65 53.00 -30.70 848.10 35.10Suggested solution
Place some end stone around y=62 when generating obsidian pillars.
The bug
For some seeds the end generates without or too less end stone beneath some obsidian pillars. This would prevent a fix for MC-86654 from working for these cases.
How to reproduce
Version: 24w20aSeed: 1194164352143763445 Coordinates: /execute in minecraft:the_end run tp @s 10.40 37.65 35.55 326.11 53.71Version: 1.20.4Seed: 3947383662603549734 Coordinates: /execute in minecraft:the_end run tp @s -0.65 53.00 -30.70 848.10 35.10Suggested solution
Place some end stone around y=62 when generating obsidian pillars.
Relates to MC-83013 or even duplicates it (strangerwise this link was created by [Mod] redstonehelper but somehow got removed)
last time i checked the seed you put in the world gen. does not effect the formation of the end, sorry.
This used to be true, but it seems this is no longer the case. I created a world with the same seed 3 times because I thought the same thing, but each time I got the same main island with the glitched pillar. Just try it.
Of course, if the End wasn't affected by the seed, then you wouldn't have consistent locations of End Cities between worlds with the same seed. Would kinda defeat the purpose since the seed is supposed to generate the same dungeons in the same places.
I got an end pillar that spawned on top of another end pillar!
The top pillar encased the lower pillar's crystal with obsidian!
Bug confirmed and still active in 15w37a.
Cannot confirm in 15w45a
Itouch2: Which seed did you use? I don't think we have a proper seed to reproduce yet.
I think you search a seed for something that has an already confirmed underlaying bug: The fact that the island is not always big enough.
If you would fix that they spawn too low, you would have instead floating towers. With the provided seed you can still see that one of the pillars has not a complete end stone area below it.
The height of the pillars is not based on the blocks below it anymore. Therefor towers as low as shown in the screenshots won't generate.
I suggest to keep this report open until we know if MC-86654 is intended. If not, this bugs might cause problems like end pillars going to Y 0 or pillars without complete support below them.
Confirmed for 19w14b
Confirmed in 1.15.2 and 1.16 Pre-release 7.
Can confirm in 20w48a.
Can confirm in 20w51a using the provided seed and coordinates.
Can confirm in 21w03a.
Can confirm in 21w05b.
Can confirm in 21w06a.
Can confirm in 21w07a.
Can confirm in 21w15a.
I actually can't replicate in 1.16 or in the 1.17 snapshots. The end pillars generate normally.
I am still able to reproduce this issue in 1.17 using the provided seed & coordinates. MC-83013.png
Can confirm in 1.17.1. Video attached.
Can confirm in 1.18.2 and 22w18a.
Can confirm in 1.19.