Sneaking while a transparent block is placed at feet causes player to appear not sneaking but hitbox remains shorter
Brief summary
Courtesy of misterblue28: While sneaking, set the block where your feet are to glass. After releasing the sneak key, your hitbox and eye level will remain lowered, but otherwise you will behave as if not sneaking.
Some info
- This bug can be reproduced in snapshot 20w29a or release 1.16.1. I haven't tested this in any other versions (may change in the future as newer versions are released).
- It was difficult to search for this bug because the only summary I could think of was the really long one you see above, so I'm sorry if this duplicates any other reports.
- The screenshots taken that are directly embedded within the description were taken in release 1.16.1.
- Sorry if the images are resized strangely; I'm not too sure why that's happening.
- This relates to many reports, so I'll explain all relations here:
- MC-157183 is slightly different than this report as that report deals specifically with doors; also, that report mentions that the speed of the player is reduced while in that position, unlike this report.
- MC-181404 contradicts MC-157183 by stating that speed isn't affected by crouching in the door.
MC-131942is different than this report because when the player released their crouch key, their appearance reverted to standing up. The appearance in this report is locked until the block is broken or the player moves out of the block.MC-148390is different than this report because this report is about the appearance of the player in third-person view more than their hitbox; yes, this report is about hitboxes but talks about the relationship between the hitbox and third-person view.- MC-165423 is included in this report, and the method described in that ticket is now obsolete. This contains more information (including new reproduction steps). I'll link the video included in that report here
- MC-149259 relates to MC-165423, and the same relations apply.
The bug
If a solid transparent block* (that confused me, so it might confuse you; take a look at the links at the end of the report to learn more) is forced into the space where the player's feet are located, then the player's hitbox remains the same size as a sneaking player's, even though the player, seen from third person view, is shown as not sneaking anymore.
While in this state, the player can walk at normal speed, even while their hitbox is shortened. This can be used to their advantage in a PVP situation where a tiny difference in hitbox sizes can make a huge difference.
When the block described above is broken, the camera shifts upwards (as if the player was leaving sneak mode), even though the rendered player does not change at all (but the hitbox reverts to its normal size).
How to reproduce
- Place a wooden pressure plate with 10 redstone ticks of delay in repeaters coming out of it:
- Place a command block (Impulse, Needs Redstone) at the end of the repeater chain:
- Insert the following command into the command block (note that glass can be replaced by any solid transparent blocks*):
execute at @p run setblock ~ ~ ~ minecraft:glass
- Stand on a block that isn't part of the contraption you've built.
- Enter third-person view mode by pressing F5 and enable hitboxes by pressing F3 + B (note: keybinds may differ):
- Throw an item onto the pressure plate while sneaking (set to left shift by default) and wait for the redstone signal to reach the command block.
- When the block is set, notice how player appears to have stood up, but the hitbox is still shortened (and notice how player can now walk at normal speed instead of sneaking speed).
- Release sneaking key, and notice how nothing changes.
- Break the solid transparent block, and notice how hitbox expands and camera shifts upwards, even though the player doesn't appear to have changed in any way.
Alternate reproduction method
Instead of using a command block to insert the block, the player can surround themselves with solid blocks and then, using a piston or a one-tick sticky piston, push the glass block into themself. The same results can be achieved, replacing steps 1-3 above; steps 4-9 must still be followed.
Footnotes
- Opacity (solid transparent block): https://minecraft.gamepedia.com/Opacity
- *note: full-block solids, non-full-block solids, and solid mechanisms, as shown on this wiki page, are all considered solid transparent blocks for the simplicity of this report.
Linked Issues
is duplicated by13
MC-156393When crouching on stair blocks and closing a trapdoor, the player model does not match the camera.DuplicateMC-161608Crouching in Trapdoors makes you stand up but not the Camera.DuplicateMC-197377Closing a Trapdoor or Fence Gate on yourself while you are stuck crouching causes client-side issuesDuplicateMC-200821TrapdoorDuplicateMC-206090Players are able to unshift under a spot where they physically cannotDuplicateMC-209694Hitbox glitch with sneaking in fence gatesDuplicateMC-210451Bug when i am under a slab and shiftingDuplicateMC-217922Closing a trapdoor on feet bugDuplicateMC-227426Wrong hitbox and stuck in crouch mode when in doorDuplicateMC-229836Sneaking visual misalignment between first and second personDuplicateMC-240775Weird Visual Glitch When sneaking inside a door with a slab on top of your headDuplicateMC-245393Hitbox remains in the crouched position when between a trapdoor, fence and stairsDuplicateMC-248057Crouching inside of blocks does not update POVDuplicaterelates to5
MC-149259Crouching inside fence gate, but no crouching hit box or visualConfirmedMC-165423Allows you to walk at the same speed while being crouchedConfirmedMC-131942Player's hitbox doesn't change while crouching inside of some blocksAwaiting ResponseMC-181404Pressing shift in a door will let you sprintCommunity ConsensusMC-148390Cannot sneak while inside a blockWon't Fix
- Unresolved
![[Mod] markderickson](../../../data/avatars/users/18946.svg)
[Mod] markderickson- 8
- 9
- Confirmed
Low- Gameplay
- Camera Hitboxes Player
- crouch hitbox player sneak transparent-block
1.16.1 - 25w05a
1.16.1 20w29a 20w30a 1.16.2-pre1 1.16.2-pre2 1.16.2-pre3 1.16.2-rc1 1.16.2-rc2 1.16.2 1.16.3-rc1 1.16.3 1.16.4-pre1 1.16.4-pre2 1.16.4-rc1 1.16.4 20w45a 20w46a 20w48a 20w49a 20w51a 21w03a 1.16.5 21w05b 21w06a 21w07a 21w08b 21w10a 21w11a 1.17-rc1 1.17 1.17.1 21w39a 21w44a 1.18-pre2 1.18.1 22w12a 22w14a 1.19 1.19.2 1.19.4 1.20-pre4 23w51b 1.21 25w05a
Created Issue:
Sneaking while a transparent block is placed at feet causes player to appear not sneaking but hitbox remains shorter
Some info
- This bug can be reproduced in snapshot 20w29a or release 1.16.1. I haven't tested this in any other versions (may change in the future as newer versions are released).
- It was difficult to search for this bug because the only summary I could think of was the really long one you see above, so I'm sorry if this duplicates any other reports.
- The screenshots taken that are directly embedded within the description were taken in release 1.16.1.
- Sorry if the images are resized stragely; I'm not too sure why that's happening.
- This relates to MC-181404 and MC-157183:
- MC-157183 is slightly different than this report as that report deals specifically with doors; also, that report mentions that the speed of the player is reduced while in that position, unlike this report.
- MC-181404 contradicts MC-157183 by stating that speed isn't affected by crouching in the door.
The bug
If a solid transparent block* (that confused me, so it might confuse you; take a look at the links at the end of the report to learn more) is forced into the space where the player's feet are located, then the player's hitbox remains the same size as a sneaking player's, even though the player, seen from third person view, is shown as not sneaking anymore.
While in this state, the player can walk at normal speed, even while their hitbox is shortened. This can be used to their advantage in a PVP situation where a tiny difference in hitbox sizes can make a huge difference.
When the block described above is broken, the camera shifts upwards (as if the player was leaving sneak mode), even though the rendered player does not change at all (but the hitbox reverts to its normal size).
How to reproduce
- Place a wooden pressure plate with 10 redstone ticks of delay in repeaters coming out of it:
- Place a command block (Impulse, Needs Redstone) at the end of the repeater chain:
- Insert the following command into the command block (note that glass can be replaced by any solid transparent blocks*):
execute at @p run setblock ~ ~ ~ minecraft:glass
- Stand on a block that isn't part of the contraption you've built.
- Enter third-person view mode by pressing F5 and enable hitboxes by pressing F3 + B (note: keybinds may differ):
- Throw an item onto the pressure plate while sneaking (set to left shift by default) and wait for the redstone signal to reach the command block.
- When the block is set, notice how player appears to have stood up, but the hitbox is still shortened (and notice how player can now walk at normal speed instead of sneaking speed).
- Release sneaking key, and notice how nothing changes.
- Break the solid transparent block, and notice how hitbox expands and camera shifts upwards, even though the player doesn't appear to have changed in any way.
Alternate reproduction method
Instead of using a command block to insert the block, the player can surround themselves with solid blocks and then, using a piston or a one-tick sticky piston, push the glass block into themselves. The same results can be achieved, replacing steps 1-3 above; steps 4-9 must still be followed.
Footnotes
- Opacity (solid transparent block): https://minecraft.gamepedia.com/Opacity
- *note: full-block solids, non-full-block solids, and solid mechanisms, as shown on this wiki page, are all considered solid transparent blocks for the simplicity of this report.
Attachments3
Some info
- This bug can be reproduced in snapshot 20w29a or release 1.16.1. I haven't tested this in any other versions (may change in the future as newer versions are released).
- It was difficult to search for this bug because the only summary I could think of was the really long one you see above, so I'm sorry if this duplicates any other reports.
- The screenshots taken that are directly embedded within the description were taken in release 1.16.1.
- Sorry if the images are resized stragely; I'm not too sure why that's happening.
- This relates to MC-181404 and MC-157183:
- MC-157183 is slightly different than this report as that report deals specifically with doors; also, that report mentions that the speed of the player is reduced while in that position, unlike this report.
- MC-181404 contradicts MC-157183 by stating that speed isn't affected by crouching in the door.
The bug
If a solid transparent block* (that confused me, so it might confuse you; take a look at the links at the end of the report to learn more) is forced into the space where the player's feet are located, then the player's hitbox remains the same size as a sneaking player's, even though the player, seen from third person view, is shown as not sneaking anymore.
While in this state, the player can walk at normal speed, even while their hitbox is shortened. This can be used to their advantage in a PVP situation where a tiny difference in hitbox sizes can make a huge difference.
When the block described above is broken, the camera shifts upwards (as if the player was leaving sneak mode), even though the rendered player does not change at all (but the hitbox reverts to its normal size).
How to reproduce
- Place a wooden pressure plate with 10 redstone ticks of delay in repeaters coming out of it:
- Place a command block (Impulse, Needs Redstone) at the end of the repeater chain:
- Insert the following command into the command block (note that glass can be replaced by any solid transparent blocks*):
execute at @p run setblock ~ ~ ~ minecraft:glass
- Stand on a block that isn't part of the contraption you've built.
- Enter third-person view mode by pressing F5 and enable hitboxes by pressing F3 + B (note: keybinds may differ):
- Throw an item onto the pressure plate while sneaking (set to left shift by default) and wait for the redstone signal to reach the command block.
- When the block is set, notice how player appears to have stood up, but the hitbox is still shortened (and notice how player can now walk at normal speed instead of sneaking speed).
- Release sneaking key, and notice how nothing changes.
- Break the solid transparent block, and notice how hitbox expands and camera shifts upwards, even though the player doesn't appear to have changed in any way.
Alternate reproduction method
Instead of using a command block to insert the block, the player can surround themselves with solid blocks and then, using a piston or a one-tick sticky piston, push the glass block into themselves. The same results can be achieved, replacing steps 1-3 above; steps 4-9 must still be followed.
Footnotes
- Opacity (solid transparent block): https://minecraft.gamepedia.com/Opacity
- *note: full-block solids, non-full-block solids, and solid mechanisms, as shown on this wiki page, are all considered solid transparent blocks for the simplicity of this report.
Some info
- This bug can be reproduced in snapshot 20w29a or release 1.16.1. I haven't tested this in any other versions (may change in the future as newer versions are released).
- It was difficult to search for this bug because the only summary I could think of was the really long one you see above, so I'm sorry if this duplicates any other reports.
- The screenshots taken that are directly embedded within the description were taken in release 1.16.1.
- Sorry if the images are resized stragely; I'm not too sure why that's happening.
- This relates to MC-181404 and MC-157183:
- MC-157183 is slightly different than this report as that report deals specifically with doors; also, that report mentions that the speed of the player is reduced while in that position, unlike this report.
- MC-181404 contradicts MC-157183 by stating that speed isn't affected by crouching in the door.
The bug
If a solid transparent block* (that confused me, so it might confuse you; take a look at the links at the end of the report to learn more) is forced into the space where the player's feet are located, then the player's hitbox remains the same size as a sneaking player's, even though the player, seen from third person view, is shown as not sneaking anymore.
While in this state, the player can walk at normal speed, even while their hitbox is shortened. This can be used to their advantage in a PVP situation where a tiny difference in hitbox sizes can make a huge difference.
When the block described above is broken, the camera shifts upwards (as if the player was leaving sneak mode), even though the rendered player does not change at all (but the hitbox reverts to its normal size).
How to reproduce
- Place a wooden pressure plate with 10 redstone ticks of delay in repeaters coming out of it:
- Place a command block (Impulse, Needs Redstone) at the end of the repeater chain:
- Insert the following command into the command block (note that glass can be replaced by any solid transparent blocks*):
execute at @p run setblock ~ ~ ~ minecraft:glass
- Stand on a block that isn't part of the contraption you've built.
- Enter third-person view mode by pressing F5 and enable hitboxes by pressing F3 + B (note: keybinds may differ):
- Throw an item onto the pressure plate while sneaking (set to left shift by default) and wait for the redstone signal to reach the command block.
- When the block is set, notice how player appears to have stood up, but the hitbox is still shortened (and notice how player can now walk at normal speed instead of sneaking speed).
- Release sneaking key, and notice how nothing changes.
- Break the solid transparent block, and notice how hitbox expands and camera shifts upwards, even though the player doesn't appear to have changed in any way.
Alternate reproduction method
Instead of using a command block to insert the block, the player can surround themselves with solid blocks and then, using a piston or a one-tick sticky piston, push the glass block into themselves. The same results can be achieved, replacing steps 1-3 above; steps 4-9 must still be followed.
Footnotes
- Opacity (solid transparent block): https://minecraft.gamepedia.com/Opacity
- *note: full-block solids, non-full-block solids, and solid mechanisms, as shown on this wiki page, are all considered solid transparent blocks for the simplicity of this report.
Some info
- This bug can be reproduced in snapshot 20w29a or release 1.16.1. I haven't tested this in any other versions (may change in the future as newer versions are released).
- It was difficult to search for this bug because the only summary I could think of was the really long one you see above, so I'm sorry if this duplicates any other reports.
- The screenshots taken that are directly embedded within the description were taken in release 1.16.1.
- Sorry if the images are resized stragely; I'm not too sure why that's happening.
- This relates to MC-181404 and MC-157183:
- MC-157183 is slightly different than this report as that report deals specifically with doors; also, that report mentions that the speed of the player is reduced while in that position, unlike this report.
- MC-181404 contradicts MC-157183 by stating that speed isn't affected by crouching in the door.
The bug
If a solid transparent block* (that confused me, so it might confuse you; take a look at the links at the end of the report to learn more) is forced into the space where the player's feet are located, then the player's hitbox remains the same size as a sneaking player's, even though the player, seen from third person view, is shown as not sneaking anymore.
While in this state, the player can walk at normal speed, even while their hitbox is shortened. This can be used to their advantage in a PVP situation where a tiny difference in hitbox sizes can make a huge difference.
When the block described above is broken, the camera shifts upwards (as if the player was leaving sneak mode), even though the rendered player does not change at all (but the hitbox reverts to its normal size).
How to reproduce
- Place a wooden pressure plate with 10 redstone ticks of delay in repeaters coming out of it:
- Place a command block (Impulse, Needs Redstone) at the end of the repeater chain:
- Insert the following command into the command block (note that glass can be replaced by any solid transparent blocks*):
execute at @p run setblock ~ ~ ~ minecraft:glass
- Stand on a block that isn't part of the contraption you've built.
- Enter third-person view mode by pressing F5 and enable hitboxes by pressing F3 + B (note: keybinds may differ):
- Throw an item onto the pressure plate while sneaking (set to left shift by default) and wait for the redstone signal to reach the command block.
- When the block is set, notice how player appears to have stood up, but the hitbox is still shortened (and notice how player can now walk at normal speed instead of sneaking speed).
- Release sneaking key, and notice how nothing changes.
- Break the solid transparent block, and notice how hitbox expands and camera shifts upwards, even though the player doesn't appear to have changed in any way.
Alternate reproduction method
Instead of using a command block to insert the block, the player can surround themselves with solid blocks and then, using a piston or a one-tick sticky piston, push the glass block into themselves. The same results can be achieved, replacing steps 1-3 above; steps 4-9 must still be followed.
Footnotes
- Opacity (solid transparent block): https://minecraft.gamepedia.com/Opacity
- *note: full-block solids, non-full-block solids, and solid mechanisms, as shown on this wiki page, are all considered solid transparent blocks for the simplicity of this report.
Some info
- This bug can be reproduced in snapshot 20w29a or release 1.16.1. I haven't tested this in any other versions (may change in the future as newer versions are released).
- It was difficult to search for this bug because the only summary I could think of was the really long one you see above, so I'm sorry if this duplicates any other reports.
- The screenshots taken that are directly embedded within the description were taken in release 1.16.1.
- Sorry if the images are resized stragely; I'm not too sure why that's happening.
- This relates to MC-181404 and MC-157183:
- MC-157183 is slightly different than this report as that report deals specifically with doors; also, that report mentions that the speed of the player is reduced while in that position, unlike this report.
- MC-181404 contradicts MC-157183 by stating that speed isn't affected by crouching in the door.
The bug
If a solid transparent block* (that confused me, so it might confuse you; take a look at the links at the end of the report to learn more) is forced into the space where the player's feet are located, then the player's hitbox remains the same size as a sneaking player's, even though the player, seen from third person view, is shown as not sneaking anymore.
While in this state, the player can walk at normal speed, even while their hitbox is shortened. This can be used to their advantage in a PVP situation where a tiny difference in hitbox sizes can make a huge difference.
When the block described above is broken, the camera shifts upwards (as if the player was leaving sneak mode), even though the rendered player does not change at all (but the hitbox reverts to its normal size).
How to reproduce
- Place a wooden pressure plate with 10 redstone ticks of delay in repeaters coming out of it:
- Place a command block (Impulse, Needs Redstone) at the end of the repeater chain:
- Insert the following command into the command block (note that glass can be replaced by any solid transparent blocks*):
execute at @p run setblock ~ ~ ~ minecraft:glass
- Stand on a block that isn't part of the contraption you've built.
- Enter third-person view mode by pressing F5 and enable hitboxes by pressing F3 + B (note: keybinds may differ):
- Throw an item onto the pressure plate while sneaking (set to left shift by default) and wait for the redstone signal to reach the command block.
- When the block is set, notice how player appears to have stood up, but the hitbox is still shortened (and notice how player can now walk at normal speed instead of sneaking speed).
- Release sneaking key, and notice how nothing changes.
- Break the solid transparent block, and notice how hitbox expands and camera shifts upwards, even though the player doesn't appear to have changed in any way.
Alternate reproduction method
Instead of using a command block to insert the block, the player can surround themselves with solid blocks and then, using a piston or a one-tick sticky piston, push the glass block into themsel
ves. The same results can be achieved, replacing steps 1-3 above; steps 4-9 must still be followed.Footnotes
- Opacity (solid transparent block): https://minecraft.gamepedia.com/Opacity
- *note: full-block solids, non-full-block solids, and solid mechanisms, as shown on this wiki page, are all considered solid transparent blocks for the simplicity of this report.
Some info
- This bug can be reproduced in snapshot 20w29a or release 1.16.1. I haven't tested this in any other versions (may change in the future as newer versions are released).
- It was difficult to search for this bug because the only summary I could think of was the really long one you see above, so I'm sorry if this duplicates any other reports.
- The screenshots taken that are directly embedded within the description were taken in release 1.16.1.
- Sorry if the images are resized stragely; I'm not too sure why that's happening.
- This relates to MC-181404 and MC-157183:
- MC-157183 is slightly different than this report as that report deals specifically with doors; also, that report mentions that the speed of the player is reduced while in that position, unlike this report.
- MC-181404 contradicts MC-157183 by stating that speed isn't affected by crouching in the door.
The bug
If a solid transparent block* (that confused me, so it might confuse you; take a look at the links at the end of the report to learn more) is forced into the space where the player's feet are located, then the player's hitbox remains the same size as a sneaking player's, even though the player, seen from third person view, is shown as not sneaking anymore.
While in this state, the player can walk at normal speed, even while their hitbox is shortened. This can be used to their advantage in a PVP situation where a tiny difference in hitbox sizes can make a huge difference.
When the block described above is broken, the camera shifts upwards (as if the player was leaving sneak mode), even though the rendered player does not change at all (but the hitbox reverts to its normal size).
How to reproduce
- Place a wooden pressure plate with 10 redstone ticks of delay in repeaters coming out of it:
- Place a command block (Impulse, Needs Redstone) at the end of the repeater chain:
- Insert the following command into the command block (note that glass can be replaced by any solid transparent blocks*):
execute at @p run setblock ~ ~ ~ minecraft:glass
- Stand on a block that isn't part of the contraption you've built.
- Enter third-person view mode by pressing F5 and enable hitboxes by pressing F3 + B (note: keybinds may differ):
- Throw an item onto the pressure plate while sneaking (set to left shift by default) and wait for the redstone signal to reach the command block.
- When the block is set, notice how player appears to have stood up, but the hitbox is still shortened (and notice how player can now walk at normal speed instead of sneaking speed).
- Release sneaking key, and notice how nothing changes.
- Break the solid transparent block, and notice how hitbox expands and camera shifts upwards, even though the player doesn't appear to have changed in any way.
Alternate reproduction method
Instead of using a command block to insert the block, the player can surround themselves with solid blocks and then, using a piston or a one-tick sticky piston, push the glass block into themself. The same results can be achieved, replacing steps 1-3 above; steps 4-9 must still be followed.
Footnotes
- Opacity (solid transparent block): https://minecraft.gamepedia.com/Opacity
- *note: full-block solids, non-full-block solids, and solid mechanisms, as shown on this wiki page, are all considered solid transparent blocks for the simplicity of this report.
Some info
- This bug can be reproduced in snapshot 20w29a or release 1.16.1. I haven't tested this in any other versions (may change in the future as newer versions are released).
- It was difficult to search for this bug because the only summary I could think of was the really long one you see above, so I'm sorry if this duplicates any other reports.
- The screenshots taken that are directly embedded within the description were taken in release 1.16.1.
- Sorry if the images are resized stragely; I'm not too sure why that's happening.
- This relates to
MC-181404and MC-157183:
- MC-157183 is
slightlydifferent than this reportas that report deals specifically with doors; also, that report mentions that the speed of the player is reduced while in that position, unlike this report.- MC-181404 contradicts MC-157183 by stating that speed isn't affected by crouching in the door.
The bug
If a solid transparent block* (that confused me, so it might confuse you; take a look at the links at the end of the report to learn more) is forced into the space where the player's feet are located, then the player's hitbox remains the same size as a sneaking player's, even though the player, seen from third person view, is shown as not sneaking anymore.
While in this state, the player can walk at normal speed, even while their hitbox is shortened. This can be used to their advantage in a PVP situation where a tiny difference in hitbox sizes can make a huge difference.
When the block described above is broken, the camera shifts upwards (as if the player was leaving sneak mode), even though the rendered player does not change at all (but the hitbox reverts to its normal size).
How to reproduce
- Place a wooden pressure plate with 10 redstone ticks of delay in repeaters coming out of it:
- Place a command block (Impulse, Needs Redstone) at the end of the repeater chain:
- Insert the following command into the command block (note that glass can be replaced by any solid transparent blocks*):
execute at @p run setblock ~ ~ ~ minecraft:glass
- Stand on a block that isn't part of the contraption you've built.
- Enter third-person view mode by pressing F5 and enable hitboxes by pressing F3 + B (note: keybinds may differ):
- Throw an item onto the pressure plate while sneaking (set to left shift by default) and wait for the redstone signal to reach the command block.
- When the block is set, notice how player appears to have stood up, but the hitbox is still shortened (and notice how player can now walk at normal speed instead of sneaking speed).
- Release sneaking key, and notice how nothing changes.
- Break the solid transparent block, and notice how hitbox expands and camera shifts upwards, even though the player doesn't appear to have changed in any way.
Alternate reproduction method
Instead of using a command block to insert the block, the player can surround themselves with solid blocks and then, using a piston or a one-tick sticky piston, push the glass block into themself. The same results can be achieved, replacing steps 1-3 above; steps 4-9 must still be followed.
Footnotes
- Opacity (solid transparent block): https://minecraft.gamepedia.com/Opacity
- *note: full-block solids, non-full-block solids, and solid mechanisms, as shown on this wiki page, are all considered solid transparent blocks for the simplicity of this report.
Some info
- This bug can be reproduced in snapshot 20w29a or release 1.16.1. I haven't tested this in any other versions (may change in the future as newer versions are released).
- It was difficult to search for this bug because the only summary I could think of was the really long one you see above, so I'm sorry if this duplicates any other reports.
- The screenshots taken that are directly embedded within the description were taken in release 1.16.1.
- Sorry if the images are resized stragely; I'm not too sure why that's happening.
- This relates to many reports, so I'll explain all relations here:
- MC-157183 is slightly different than this report as that report deals specifically with doors; also, that report mentions that the speed of the player is reduced while in that position, unlike this report.
- MC-181404 contradicts MC-157183 by stating that speed isn't affected by crouching in the door.
MC-131942is different than this report because when the player released their crouch key, their appearance reverted to standing up. The appearance in this report is locked until the block is broken or the player moves out of the block.MC-148390is different than this report because this report is about the appearance of the player in third-person view more than their hitbox; yes, this report is about hitboxes but talks about the relationship between the hitbox and third-person view.- MC-165423 is included in this report, and the method described in that ticket is now obsolete. Possibly resolve that ticket to this one, as this contains more information (including new reproduction steps). I'll link the video included in that report here
- MC-149259 relates to MC-165423, and the same relations apply.
MC-161608is included within this report, but with slightly more detail. Possibly resolve that ticket to this one, as this contains more information. I'll link the video included in that report here.The bug
If a solid transparent block* (that confused me, so it might confuse you; take a look at the links at the end of the report to learn more) is forced into the space where the player's feet are located, then the player's hitbox remains the same size as a sneaking player's, even though the player, seen from third person view, is shown as not sneaking anymore.
While in this state, the player can walk at normal speed, even while their hitbox is shortened. This can be used to their advantage in a PVP situation where a tiny difference in hitbox sizes can make a huge difference.
When the block described above is broken, the camera shifts upwards (as if the player was leaving sneak mode), even though the rendered player does not change at all (but the hitbox reverts to its normal size).
How to reproduce
- Place a wooden pressure plate with 10 redstone ticks of delay in repeaters coming out of it:
- Place a command block (Impulse, Needs Redstone) at the end of the repeater chain:
- Insert the following command into the command block (note that glass can be replaced by any solid transparent blocks*):
execute at @p run setblock ~ ~ ~ minecraft:glass
- Stand on a block that isn't part of the contraption you've built.
- Enter third-person view mode by pressing F5 and enable hitboxes by pressing F3 + B (note: keybinds may differ):
- Throw an item onto the pressure plate while sneaking (set to left shift by default) and wait for the redstone signal to reach the command block.
- When the block is set, notice how player appears to have stood up, but the hitbox is still shortened (and notice how player can now walk at normal speed instead of sneaking speed).
- Release sneaking key, and notice how nothing changes.
- Break the solid transparent block, and notice how hitbox expands and camera shifts upwards, even though the player doesn't appear to have changed in any way.
Alternate reproduction method
Instead of using a command block to insert the block, the player can surround themselves with solid blocks and then, using a piston or a one-tick sticky piston, push the glass block into themself. The same results can be achieved, replacing steps 1-3 above; steps 4-9 must still be followed.
Footnotes
- Opacity (solid transparent block): https://minecraft.gamepedia.com/Opacity
- *note: full-block solids, non-full-block solids, and solid mechanisms, as shown on this wiki page, are all considered solid transparent blocks for the simplicity of this report.
Some info
- This bug can be reproduced in snapshot 20w29a or release 1.16.1. I haven't tested this in any other versions (may change in the future as newer versions are released).
- It was difficult to search for this bug because the only summary I could think of was the really long one you see above, so I'm sorry if this duplicates any other reports.
- The screenshots taken that are directly embedded within the description were taken in release 1.16.1.
- Sorry if the images are resized stragely; I'm not too sure why that's happening.
- This relates to many reports, so I'll explain all relations here:
- MC-157183 is slightly different than this report as that report deals specifically with doors; also, that report mentions that the speed of the player is reduced while in that position, unlike this report.
- MC-181404 contradicts MC-157183 by stating that speed isn't affected by crouching in the door.
MC-131942is different than this report because when the player released their crouch key, their appearance reverted to standing up. The appearance in this report is locked until the block is broken or the player moves out of the block.MC-148390is different than this report because this report is about the appearance of the player in third-person view more than their hitbox; yes, this report is about hitboxes but talks about the relationship between the hitbox and third-person view.- MC-165423 is included in this report, and the method described in that ticket is now obsolete.
Possibly resolve that ticket to this one, as this contains more information (including new reproduction steps). I'll link the video included in that report here- MC-149259 relates to MC-165423, and the same relations apply.
MC-161608is included within this report, but with slightly more detail. Possibly resolve that ticket to this one, as this contains more information. I'll link the video included in that report here.The bug
If a solid transparent block* (that confused me, so it might confuse you; take a look at the links at the end of the report to learn more) is forced into the space where the player's feet are located, then the player's hitbox remains the same size as a sneaking player's, even though the player, seen from third person view, is shown as not sneaking anymore.
While in this state, the player can walk at normal speed, even while their hitbox is shortened. This can be used to their advantage in a PVP situation where a tiny difference in hitbox sizes can make a huge difference.
When the block described above is broken, the camera shifts upwards (as if the player was leaving sneak mode), even though the rendered player does not change at all (but the hitbox reverts to its normal size).
How to reproduce
- Place a wooden pressure plate with 10 redstone ticks of delay in repeaters coming out of it:
- Place a command block (Impulse, Needs Redstone) at the end of the repeater chain:
- Insert the following command into the command block (note that glass can be replaced by any solid transparent blocks*):
execute at @p run setblock ~ ~ ~ minecraft:glass
- Stand on a block that isn't part of the contraption you've built.
- Enter third-person view mode by pressing F5 and enable hitboxes by pressing F3 + B (note: keybinds may differ):
- Throw an item onto the pressure plate while sneaking (set to left shift by default) and wait for the redstone signal to reach the command block.
- When the block is set, notice how player appears to have stood up, but the hitbox is still shortened (and notice how player can now walk at normal speed instead of sneaking speed).
- Release sneaking key, and notice how nothing changes.
- Break the solid transparent block, and notice how hitbox expands and camera shifts upwards, even though the player doesn't appear to have changed in any way.
Alternate reproduction method
Instead of using a command block to insert the block, the player can surround themselves with solid blocks and then, using a piston or a one-tick sticky piston, push the glass block into themself. The same results can be achieved, replacing steps 1-3 above; steps 4-9 must still be followed.
Footnotes
- Opacity (solid transparent block): https://minecraft.gamepedia.com/Opacity
- *note: full-block solids, non-full-block solids, and solid mechanisms, as shown on this wiki page, are all considered solid transparent blocks for the simplicity of this report.
Some info
- This bug can be reproduced in snapshot 20w29a or release 1.16.1. I haven't tested this in any other versions (may change in the future as newer versions are released).
- It was difficult to search for this bug because the only summary I could think of was the really long one you see above, so I'm sorry if this duplicates any other reports.
- The screenshots taken that are directly embedded within the description were taken in release 1.16.1.
- Sorry if the images are resized stragely; I'm not too sure why that's happening.
- This relates to many reports, so I'll explain all relations here:
- MC-157183 is slightly different than this report as that report deals specifically with doors; also, that report mentions that the speed of the player is reduced while in that position, unlike this report.
- MC-181404 contradicts MC-157183 by stating that speed isn't affected by crouching in the door.
MC-131942is different than this report because when the player released their crouch key, their appearance reverted to standing up. The appearance in this report is locked until the block is broken or the player moves out of the block.MC-148390is different than this report because this report is about the appearance of the player in third-person view more than their hitbox; yes, this report is about hitboxes but talks about the relationship between the hitbox and third-person view.- MC-165423 is included in this report, and the method described in that ticket is now obsolete. This contains more information (including new reproduction steps). I'll link the video included in that report here
- MC-149259 relates to MC-165423, and the same relations apply.
- I'm planning on trying to do code analysis and make a chart later today.
The bug
If a solid transparent block* (that confused me, so it might confuse you; take a look at the links at the end of the report to learn more) is forced into the space where the player's feet are located, then the player's hitbox remains the same size as a sneaking player's, even though the player, seen from third person view, is shown as not sneaking anymore.
While in this state, the player can walk at normal speed, even while their hitbox is shortened. This can be used to their advantage in a PVP situation where a tiny difference in hitbox sizes can make a huge difference.
When the block described above is broken, the camera shifts upwards (as if the player was leaving sneak mode), even though the rendered player does not change at all (but the hitbox reverts to its normal size).
How to reproduce
- Place a wooden pressure plate with 10 redstone ticks of delay in repeaters coming out of it:
- Place a command block (Impulse, Needs Redstone) at the end of the repeater chain:
- Insert the following command into the command block (note that glass can be replaced by any solid transparent blocks*):
execute at @p run setblock ~ ~ ~ minecraft:glass
- Stand on a block that isn't part of the contraption you've built.
- Enter third-person view mode by pressing F5 and enable hitboxes by pressing F3 + B (note: keybinds may differ):
- Throw an item onto the pressure plate while sneaking (set to left shift by default) and wait for the redstone signal to reach the command block.
- When the block is set, notice how player appears to have stood up, but the hitbox is still shortened (and notice how player can now walk at normal speed instead of sneaking speed).
- Release sneaking key, and notice how nothing changes.
- Break the solid transparent block, and notice how hitbox expands and camera shifts upwards, even though the player doesn't appear to have changed in any way.
Alternate reproduction method
Instead of using a command block to insert the block, the player can surround themselves with solid blocks and then, using a piston or a one-tick sticky piston, push the glass block into themself. The same results can be achieved, replacing steps 1-3 above; steps 4-9 must still be followed.
Footnotes
- Opacity (solid transparent block): https://minecraft.gamepedia.com/Opacity
- *note: full-block solids, non-full-block solids, and solid mechanisms, as shown on this wiki page, are all considered solid transparent blocks for the simplicity of this report.
TLDR: While sneaking, set the block where your feet are to glass. After releasing the sneak key, your hitbox and eye level will remain lowered, but otherwise you will behave as if not sneaking.
![[Helper] Jack McKalling](../../../data/avatars/users/92859.png){kind=small}
Some info
- This bug can be reproduced in snapshot 20w29a or release 1.16.1. I haven't tested this in any other versions (may change in the future as newer versions are released).
- It was difficult to search for this bug because the only summary I could think of was the really long one you see above, so I'm sorry if this duplicates any other reports.
- The screenshots taken that are directly embedded within the description were taken in release 1.16.1.
- Sorry if the images are resized stragely; I'm not too sure why that's happening.
- This relates to many reports, so I'll explain all relations here:
- MC-157183 is slightly different than this report as that report deals specifically with doors; also, that report mentions that the speed of the player is reduced while in that position, unlike this report.
- MC-181404 contradicts MC-157183 by stating that speed isn't affected by crouching in the door.
MC-131942is different than this report because when the player released their crouch key, their appearance reverted to standing up. The appearance in this report is locked until the block is broken or the player moves out of the block.MC-148390is different than this report because this report is about the appearance of the player in third-person view more than their hitbox; yes, this report is about hitboxes but talks about the relationship between the hitbox and third-person view.- MC-165423 is included in this report, and the method described in that ticket is now obsolete. This contains more information (including new reproduction steps). I'll link the video included in that report here
- MC-149259 relates to MC-165423, and the same relations apply.
- I'm planning on trying to do code analysis and make a chart later today.
The bug
If a solid transparent block* (that confused me, so it might confuse you; take a look at the links at the end of the report to learn more) is forced into the space where the player's feet are located, then the player's hitbox remains the same size as a sneaking player's, even though the player, seen from third person view, is shown as not sneaking anymore.
While in this state, the player can walk at normal speed, even while their hitbox is shortened. This can be used to their advantage in a PVP situation where a tiny difference in hitbox sizes can make a huge difference.
When the block described above is broken, the camera shifts upwards (as if the player was leaving sneak mode), even though the rendered player does not change at all (but the hitbox reverts to its normal size).
How to reproduce
- Place a wooden pressure plate with 10 redstone ticks of delay in repeaters coming out of it:
- Place a command block (Impulse, Needs Redstone) at the end of the repeater chain:
- Insert the following command into the command block (note that glass can be replaced by any solid transparent blocks*):
execute at @p run setblock ~ ~ ~ minecraft:glass
- Stand on a block that isn't part of the contraption you've built.
- Enter third-person view mode by pressing F5 and enable hitboxes by pressing F3 + B (note: keybinds may differ):
- Throw an item onto the pressure plate while sneaking (set to left shift by default) and wait for the redstone signal to reach the command block.
- When the block is set, notice how player appears to have stood up, but the hitbox is still shortened (and notice how player can now walk at normal speed instead of sneaking speed).
- Release sneaking key, and notice how nothing changes.
- Break the solid transparent block, and notice how hitbox expands and camera shifts upwards, even though the player doesn't appear to have changed in any way.
Alternate reproduction method
Instead of using a command block to insert the block, the player can surround themselves with solid blocks and then, using a piston or a one-tick sticky piston, push the glass block into themself. The same results can be achieved, replacing steps 1-3 above; steps 4-9 must still be followed.
Footnotes
- Opacity (solid transparent block): https://minecraft.gamepedia.com/Opacity
- *note: full-block solids, non-full-block solids, and solid mechanisms, as shown on this wiki page, are all considered solid transparent blocks for the simplicity of this report.
![[Mod] NeunEinser](../../../data/avatars/users/39263.png){kind=small}
![[Mod] LateLag](../../../data/avatars/users/92884.png){kind=small}
relates to
![[Bot] Arisa](../../../data/avatars/users/43007.png){kind=small}
relates to
relates to
relates to
relates to
relates to
![[Mod] violine1101](../../../data/avatars/users/92858.png){kind=small}
![[Mojang] slicedlime](../../../data/assets/gravatar/slicedlime.jpeg){kind=small}
is duplicated by
![[Mod] SPGoding](../../../data/avatars/users/44622.png){kind=small}
![[Helper] Johnibur](../../../data/avatars/users/28381.png){kind=small}
![[Mod] j_p_smith](../../../data/avatars/users/92851.png){kind=small}
is duplicated by
Some info
- This bug can be reproduced in snapshot 20w29a or release 1.16.1. I haven't tested this in any other versions (may change in the future as newer versions are released).
- It was difficult to search for this bug because the only summary I could think of was the really long one you see above, so I'm sorry if this duplicates any other reports.
- The screenshots taken that are directly embedded within the description were taken in release 1.16.1.
- Sorry if the images are resized stragely; I'm not too sure why that's happening.
- This relates to many reports, so I'll explain all relations here:
- MC-157183 is slightly different than this report as that report deals specifically with doors; also, that report mentions that the speed of the player is reduced while in that position, unlike this report.
- MC-181404 contradicts MC-157183 by stating that speed isn't affected by crouching in the door.
MC-131942is different than this report because when the player released their crouch key, their appearance reverted to standing up. The appearance in this report is locked until the block is broken or the player moves out of the block.MC-148390is different than this report because this report is about the appearance of the player in third-person view more than their hitbox; yes, this report is about hitboxes but talks about the relationship between the hitbox and third-person view.- MC-165423 is included in this report, and the method described in that ticket is now obsolete. This contains more information (including new reproduction steps). I'll link the video included in that report here
- MC-149259 relates to MC-165423, and the same relations apply.
The bug
If a solid transparent block* (that confused me, so it might confuse you; take a look at the links at the end of the report to learn more) is forced into the space where the player's feet are located, then the player's hitbox remains the same size as a sneaking player's, even though the player, seen from third person view, is shown as not sneaking anymore.
While in this state, the player can walk at normal speed, even while their hitbox is shortened. This can be used to their advantage in a PVP situation where a tiny difference in hitbox sizes can make a huge difference.
When the block described above is broken, the camera shifts upwards (as if the player was leaving sneak mode), even though the rendered player does not change at all (but the hitbox reverts to its normal size).
How to reproduce
- Place a wooden pressure plate with 10 redstone ticks of delay in repeaters coming out of it:
- Place a command block (Impulse, Needs Redstone) at the end of the repeater chain:
- Insert the following command into the command block (note that glass can be replaced by any solid transparent blocks*):
execute at @p run setblock ~ ~ ~ minecraft:glass
- Stand on a block that isn't part of the contraption you've built.
- Enter third-person view mode by pressing F5 and enable hitboxes by pressing F3 + B (note: keybinds may differ):
- Throw an item onto the pressure plate while sneaking (set to left shift by default) and wait for the redstone signal to reach the command block.
- When the block is set, notice how player appears to have stood up, but the hitbox is still shortened (and notice how player can now walk at normal speed instead of sneaking speed).
- Release sneaking key, and notice how nothing changes.
- Break the solid transparent block, and notice how hitbox expands and camera shifts upwards, even though the player doesn't appear to have changed in any way.
Alternate reproduction method
Instead of using a command block to insert the block, the player can surround themselves with solid blocks and then, using a piston or a one-tick sticky piston, push the glass block into themself. The same results can be achieved, replacing steps 1-3 above; steps 4-9 must still be followed.
Footnotes
- Opacity (solid transparent block): https://minecraft.gamepedia.com/Opacity
- *note: full-block solids, non-full-block solids, and solid mechanisms, as shown on this wiki page, are all considered solid transparent blocks for the simplicity of this report.
Brief summary
Courtesy of misterblue28: While sneaking, set the block where your feet are to glass. After releasing the sneak key, your hitbox and eye level will remain lowered, but otherwise you will behave as if not sneaking.
Some info
- This bug can be reproduced in snapshot 20w29a or release 1.16.1. I haven't tested this in any other versions (may change in the future as newer versions are released).
- It was difficult to search for this bug because the only summary I could think of was the really long one you see above, so I'm sorry if this duplicates any other reports.
- The screenshots taken that are directly embedded within the description were taken in release 1.16.1.
- Sorry if the images are resized stragely; I'm not too sure why that's happening.
- This relates to many reports, so I'll explain all relations here:
- MC-157183 is slightly different than this report as that report deals specifically with doors; also, that report mentions that the speed of the player is reduced while in that position, unlike this report.
- MC-181404 contradicts MC-157183 by stating that speed isn't affected by crouching in the door.
MC-131942is different than this report because when the player released their crouch key, their appearance reverted to standing up. The appearance in this report is locked until the block is broken or the player moves out of the block.MC-148390is different than this report because this report is about the appearance of the player in third-person view more than their hitbox; yes, this report is about hitboxes but talks about the relationship between the hitbox and third-person view.- MC-165423 is included in this report, and the method described in that ticket is now obsolete. This contains more information (including new reproduction steps). I'll link the video included in that report here
- MC-149259 relates to MC-165423, and the same relations apply.
The bug
If a solid transparent block* (that confused me, so it might confuse you; take a look at the links at the end of the report to learn more) is forced into the space where the player's feet are located, then the player's hitbox remains the same size as a sneaking player's, even though the player, seen from third person view, is shown as not sneaking anymore.
While in this state, the player can walk at normal speed, even while their hitbox is shortened. This can be used to their advantage in a PVP situation where a tiny difference in hitbox sizes can make a huge difference.
When the block described above is broken, the camera shifts upwards (as if the player was leaving sneak mode), even though the rendered player does not change at all (but the hitbox reverts to its normal size).
How to reproduce
- Place a wooden pressure plate with 10 redstone ticks of delay in repeaters coming out of it:
- Place a command block (Impulse, Needs Redstone) at the end of the repeater chain:
- Insert the following command into the command block (note that glass can be replaced by any solid transparent blocks*):
execute at @p run setblock ~ ~ ~ minecraft:glass
- Stand on a block that isn't part of the contraption you've built.
- Enter third-person view mode by pressing F5 and enable hitboxes by pressing F3 + B (note: keybinds may differ):
- Throw an item onto the pressure plate while sneaking (set to left shift by default) and wait for the redstone signal to reach the command block.
- When the block is set, notice how player appears to have stood up, but the hitbox is still shortened (and notice how player can now walk at normal speed instead of sneaking speed).
- Release sneaking key, and notice how nothing changes.
- Break the solid transparent block, and notice how hitbox expands and camera shifts upwards, even though the player doesn't appear to have changed in any way.
Alternate reproduction method
Instead of using a command block to insert the block, the player can surround themselves with solid blocks and then, using a piston or a one-tick sticky piston, push the glass block into themself. The same results can be achieved, replacing steps 1-3 above; steps 4-9 must still be followed.
Footnotes
- Opacity (solid transparent block): https://minecraft.gamepedia.com/Opacity
- *note: full-block solids, non-full-block solids, and solid mechanisms, as shown on this wiki page, are all considered solid transparent blocks for the simplicity of this report.
Brief summary
Courtesy of misterblue28:
While sneaking, set the block where your feet are to glass. After releasing the sneak key, your hitbox and eye level will remain lowered, but otherwise you will behave as if not sneaking.Some info
- This bug can be reproduced in snapshot 20w29a or release 1.16.1. I haven't tested this in any other versions (may change in the future as newer versions are released).
- It was difficult to search for this bug because the only summary I could think of was the really long one you see above, so I'm sorry if this duplicates any other reports.
- The screenshots taken that are directly embedded within the description were taken in release 1.16.1.
- Sorry if the images are resized stragely; I'm not too sure why that's happening.
- This relates to many reports, so I'll explain all relations here:
- MC-157183 is slightly different than this report as that report deals specifically with doors; also, that report mentions that the speed of the player is reduced while in that position, unlike this report.
- MC-181404 contradicts MC-157183 by stating that speed isn't affected by crouching in the door.
MC-131942is different than this report because when the player released their crouch key, their appearance reverted to standing up. The appearance in this report is locked until the block is broken or the player moves out of the block.MC-148390is different than this report because this report is about the appearance of the player in third-person view more than their hitbox; yes, this report is about hitboxes but talks about the relationship between the hitbox and third-person view.- MC-165423 is included in this report, and the method described in that ticket is now obsolete. This contains more information (including new reproduction steps). I'll link the video included in that report here
- MC-149259 relates to MC-165423, and the same relations apply.
The bug
If a solid transparent block* (that confused me, so it might confuse you; take a look at the links at the end of the report to learn more) is forced into the space where the player's feet are located, then the player's hitbox remains the same size as a sneaking player's, even though the player, seen from third person view, is shown as not sneaking anymore.
While in this state, the player can walk at normal speed, even while their hitbox is shortened. This can be used to their advantage in a PVP situation where a tiny difference in hitbox sizes can make a huge difference.
When the block described above is broken, the camera shifts upwards (as if the player was leaving sneak mode), even though the rendered player does not change at all (but the hitbox reverts to its normal size).
How to reproduce
- Place a wooden pressure plate with 10 redstone ticks of delay in repeaters coming out of it:
- Place a command block (Impulse, Needs Redstone) at the end of the repeater chain:
- Insert the following command into the command block (note that glass can be replaced by any solid transparent blocks*):
execute at @p run setblock ~ ~ ~ minecraft:glass
- Stand on a block that isn't part of the contraption you've built.
- Enter third-person view mode by pressing F5 and enable hitboxes by pressing F3 + B (note: keybinds may differ):
- Throw an item onto the pressure plate while sneaking (set to left shift by default) and wait for the redstone signal to reach the command block.
- When the block is set, notice how player appears to have stood up, but the hitbox is still shortened (and notice how player can now walk at normal speed instead of sneaking speed).
- Release sneaking key, and notice how nothing changes.
- Break the solid transparent block, and notice how hitbox expands and camera shifts upwards, even though the player doesn't appear to have changed in any way.
Alternate reproduction method
Instead of using a command block to insert the block, the player can surround themselves with solid blocks and then, using a piston or a one-tick sticky piston, push the glass block into themself. The same results can be achieved, replacing steps 1-3 above; steps 4-9 must still be followed.
Footnotes
- Opacity (solid transparent block): https://minecraft.gamepedia.com/Opacity
- *note: full-block solids, non-full-block solids, and solid mechanisms, as shown on this wiki page, are all considered solid transparent blocks for the simplicity of this report.
Brief summary
Courtesy of misterblue28: While sneaking, set the block where your feet are to glass. After releasing the sneak key, your hitbox and eye level will remain lowered, but otherwise you will behave as if not sneaking.
Some info
- This bug can be reproduced in snapshot 20w29a or release 1.16.1. I haven't tested this in any other versions (may change in the future as newer versions are released).
- It was difficult to search for this bug because the only summary I could think of was the really long one you see above, so I'm sorry if this duplicates any other reports.
- The screenshots taken that are directly embedded within the description were taken in release 1.16.1.
- Sorry if the images are resized stragely; I'm not too sure why that's happening.
- This relates to many reports, so I'll explain all relations here:
- MC-157183 is slightly different than this report as that report deals specifically with doors; also, that report mentions that the speed of the player is reduced while in that position, unlike this report.
- MC-181404 contradicts MC-157183 by stating that speed isn't affected by crouching in the door.
MC-131942is different than this report because when the player released their crouch key, their appearance reverted to standing up. The appearance in this report is locked until the block is broken or the player moves out of the block.MC-148390is different than this report because this report is about the appearance of the player in third-person view more than their hitbox; yes, this report is about hitboxes but talks about the relationship between the hitbox and third-person view.- MC-165423 is included in this report, and the method described in that ticket is now obsolete. This contains more information (including new reproduction steps). I'll link the video included in that report here
- MC-149259 relates to MC-165423, and the same relations apply.
The bug
If a solid transparent block* (that confused me, so it might confuse you; take a look at the links at the end of the report to learn more) is forced into the space where the player's feet are located, then the player's hitbox remains the same size as a sneaking player's, even though the player, seen from third person view, is shown as not sneaking anymore.
While in this state, the player can walk at normal speed, even while their hitbox is shortened. This can be used to their advantage in a PVP situation where a tiny difference in hitbox sizes can make a huge difference.
When the block described above is broken, the camera shifts upwards (as if the player was leaving sneak mode), even though the rendered player does not change at all (but the hitbox reverts to its normal size).
How to reproduce
- Place a wooden pressure plate with 10 redstone ticks of delay in repeaters coming out of it:
- Place a command block (Impulse, Needs Redstone) at the end of the repeater chain:
- Insert the following command into the command block (note that glass can be replaced by any solid transparent blocks*):
execute at @p run setblock ~ ~ ~ minecraft:glass
- Stand on a block that isn't part of the contraption you've built.
- Enter third-person view mode by pressing F5 and enable hitboxes by pressing F3 + B (note: keybinds may differ):
- Throw an item onto the pressure plate while sneaking (set to left shift by default) and wait for the redstone signal to reach the command block.
- When the block is set, notice how player appears to have stood up, but the hitbox is still shortened (and notice how player can now walk at normal speed instead of sneaking speed).
- Release sneaking key, and notice how nothing changes.
- Break the solid transparent block, and notice how hitbox expands and camera shifts upwards, even though the player doesn't appear to have changed in any way.
Alternate reproduction method
Instead of using a command block to insert the block, the player can surround themselves with solid blocks and then, using a piston or a one-tick sticky piston, push the glass block into themself. The same results can be achieved, replacing steps 1-3 above; steps 4-9 must still be followed.
Footnotes
- Opacity (solid transparent block): https://minecraft.gamepedia.com/Opacity
- *note: full-block solids, non-full-block solids, and solid mechanisms, as shown on this wiki page, are all considered solid transparent blocks for the simplicity of this report.
![[Mod] Michael Wobst](../../../data/avatars/users/37868.png){kind=small}
Brief summary
Courtesy of misterblue28: While sneaking, set the block where your feet are to glass. After releasing the sneak key, your hitbox and eye level will remain lowered, but otherwise you will behave as if not sneaking.
Some info
- This bug can be reproduced in snapshot 20w29a or release 1.16.1. I haven't tested this in any other versions (may change in the future as newer versions are released).
- It was difficult to search for this bug because the only summary I could think of was the really long one you see above, so I'm sorry if this duplicates any other reports.
- The screenshots taken that are directly embedded within the description were taken in release 1.16.1.
- Sorry if the images are resized stragely; I'm not too sure why that's happening.
- This relates to many reports, so I'll explain all relations here:
- MC-157183 is slightly different than this report as that report deals specifically with doors; also, that report mentions that the speed of the player is reduced while in that position, unlike this report.
- MC-181404 contradicts MC-157183 by stating that speed isn't affected by crouching in the door.
MC-131942is different than this report because when the player released their crouch key, their appearance reverted to standing up. The appearance in this report is locked until the block is broken or the player moves out of the block.MC-148390is different than this report because this report is about the appearance of the player in third-person view more than their hitbox; yes, this report is about hitboxes but talks about the relationship between the hitbox and third-person view.- MC-165423 is included in this report, and the method described in that ticket is now obsolete. This contains more information (including new reproduction steps). I'll link the video included in that report here
- MC-149259 relates to MC-165423, and the same relations apply.
The bug
If a solid transparent block* (that confused me, so it might confuse you; take a look at the links at the end of the report to learn more) is forced into the space where the player's feet are located, then the player's hitbox remains the same size as a sneaking player's, even though the player, seen from third person view, is shown as not sneaking anymore.
While in this state, the player can walk at normal speed, even while their hitbox is shortened. This can be used to their advantage in a PVP situation where a tiny difference in hitbox sizes can make a huge difference.
When the block described above is broken, the camera shifts upwards (as if the player was leaving sneak mode), even though the rendered player does not change at all (but the hitbox reverts to its normal size).
How to reproduce
- Place a wooden pressure plate with 10 redstone ticks of delay in repeaters coming out of it:
- Place a command block (Impulse, Needs Redstone) at the end of the repeater chain:
- Insert the following command into the command block (note that glass can be replaced by any solid transparent blocks*):
execute at @p run setblock ~ ~ ~ minecraft:glass
- Stand on a block that isn't part of the contraption you've built.
- Enter third-person view mode by pressing F5 and enable hitboxes by pressing F3 + B (note: keybinds may differ):
- Throw an item onto the pressure plate while sneaking (set to left shift by default) and wait for the redstone signal to reach the command block.
- When the block is set, notice how player appears to have stood up, but the hitbox is still shortened (and notice how player can now walk at normal speed instead of sneaking speed).
- Release sneaking key, and notice how nothing changes.
- Break the solid transparent block, and notice how hitbox expands and camera shifts upwards, even though the player doesn't appear to have changed in any way.
Alternate reproduction method
Instead of using a command block to insert the block, the player can surround themselves with solid blocks and then, using a piston or a one-tick sticky piston, push the glass block into themself. The same results can be achieved, replacing steps 1-3 above; steps 4-9 must still be followed.
Footnotes
- Opacity (solid transparent block): https://minecraft.gamepedia.com/Opacity
- *note: full-block solids, non-full-block solids, and solid mechanisms, as shown on this wiki page, are all considered solid transparent blocks for the simplicity of this report.
Brief summary
Courtesy of misterblue28: While sneaking, set the block where your feet are to glass. After releasing the sneak key, your hitbox and eye level will remain lowered, but otherwise you will behave as if not sneaking.
Some info
- This bug can be reproduced in snapshot 20w29a or release 1.16.1. I haven't tested this in any other versions (may change in the future as newer versions are released).
- It was difficult to search for this bug because the only summary I could think of was the really long one you see above, so I'm sorry if this duplicates any other reports.
- The screenshots taken that are directly embedded within the description were taken in release 1.16.1.
- Sorry if the images are resized strangely; I'm not too sure why that's happening.
- This relates to many reports, so I'll explain all relations here:
- MC-157183 is slightly different than this report as that report deals specifically with doors; also, that report mentions that the speed of the player is reduced while in that position, unlike this report.
- MC-181404 contradicts MC-157183 by stating that speed isn't affected by crouching in the door.
MC-131942is different than this report because when the player released their crouch key, their appearance reverted to standing up. The appearance in this report is locked until the block is broken or the player moves out of the block.MC-148390is different than this report because this report is about the appearance of the player in third-person view more than their hitbox; yes, this report is about hitboxes but talks about the relationship between the hitbox and third-person view.- MC-165423 is included in this report, and the method described in that ticket is now obsolete. This contains more information (including new reproduction steps). I'll link the video included in that report here
- MC-149259 relates to MC-165423, and the same relations apply.
The bug
If a solid transparent block* (that confused me, so it might confuse you; take a look at the links at the end of the report to learn more) is forced into the space where the player's feet are located, then the player's hitbox remains the same size as a sneaking player's, even though the player, seen from third person view, is shown as not sneaking anymore.
While in this state, the player can walk at normal speed, even while their hitbox is shortened. This can be used to their advantage in a PVP situation where a tiny difference in hitbox sizes can make a huge difference.
When the block described above is broken, the camera shifts upwards (as if the player was leaving sneak mode), even though the rendered player does not change at all (but the hitbox reverts to its normal size).
How to reproduce
- Place a wooden pressure plate with 10 redstone ticks of delay in repeaters coming out of it:
- Place a command block (Impulse, Needs Redstone) at the end of the repeater chain:
- Insert the following command into the command block (note that glass can be replaced by any solid transparent blocks*):
execute at @p run setblock ~ ~ ~ minecraft:glass- Stand on a block that isn't part of the contraption you've built.
- Enter third-person view mode by pressing F5 and enable hitboxes by pressing F3 + B (note: keybinds may differ):
- Throw an item onto the pressure plate while sneaking (set to left shift by default) and wait for the redstone signal to reach the command block.
- When the block is set, notice how player appears to have stood up, but the hitbox is still shortened (and notice how player can now walk at normal speed instead of sneaking speed).
- Release sneaking key, and notice how nothing changes.
- Break the solid transparent block, and notice how hitbox expands and camera shifts upwards, even though the player doesn't appear to have changed in any way.
Alternate reproduction method
Instead of using a command block to insert the block, the player can surround themselves with solid blocks and then, using a piston or a one-tick sticky piston, push the glass block into themself. The same results can be achieved, replacing steps 1-3 above; steps 4-9 must still be followed.
Footnotes
- Opacity (solid transparent block): https://minecraft.gamepedia.com/Opacity
- *note: full-block solids, non-full-block solids, and solid mechanisms, as shown on this wiki page, are all considered solid transparent blocks for the simplicity of this report.
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
![[Mod] tryashtar](../../../data/avatars/users/41963.png){kind=small}
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
![[Mod] turbo](../../../data/avatars/users/92867.png){kind=small}
is duplicated by
Thank you for your report!
However, this issue is a Duplicate of MC-195736.
It has been linked to this report. If you have additional information, please add it to that report.
Please search before reporting, as it's likely that one exists already.
Quick Links:
📓 Issue Guidelines – 💬 Community Support – 📧 Customer Support – 📖 Game Wiki
![[Mod] Avoma](../../../data/avatars/users/86198.png){kind=small}
Duplicate of MC-195736.
Thank you for your report!
We're tracking this issue in MC-195736, so this ticket is being resolved and linked as a duplicate.
If you would like to add a vote and any extra information to the main ticket it would be appreciated.
If you haven't already, you might like to make use of the search feature to see if the issue has already been mentioned.
Quick Links:
📓 Bug Tracker Guidelines – 💬 Community Support – 📧 Mojang Support
📓 Project Summary – ✍️ Feedback and Suggestions – 📖 Game Wiki
Thank you for your report!
We're tracking this issue in MC-195736, so this ticket is being resolved and linked as a duplicate.
If you would like to add a vote and any extra information to the main ticket it would be appreciated.
If you haven't already, you might like to make use of the search feature in the future to see if the issue has already been reported.
Quick Links:
📓 Issue Guidelines – 💬 Community Support – 📧 Customer Support – ✍️ Feedback and Suggestions – 📖 Game Wiki
Duplicate of MC-195736.
Thank you for your report!
We're tracking this issue in MC-195736, so this ticket is being resolved and linked as a duplicate.
If you would like to add a vote and any extra information to the main ticket it would be appreciated.
If you haven't already, you might like to make use of the search feature to see if the issue has already been mentioned.
Quick Links:
📓 Bug Tracker Guidelines – 💬 Community Support – 📧 Mojang Support
📓 Project Summary – ✍️ Feedback and Suggestions – 📖 Game Wiki
– I am a bot. This action was performed automatically! If you think it was incorrect, please notify us on Discord or Reddit
Duplicate of MC-195736. In the future, please also make sure that you are able to reproduce the issue in a vanilla environment before creating a ticket. 
Thank you for your report!
We're tracking this issue in MC-195736, so this ticket is being resolved and linked as a duplicate.
If you would like to add a vote and any extra information to the main ticket it would be appreciated.
If you haven't already, you might like to make use of the search feature to see if the issue has already been mentioned.
Quick Links:
📓 Bug Tracker Guidelines – 💬 Community Support – 📧 Mojang Support
📓 Project Summary – ✍️ Feedback and Suggestions – 📖 Game Wiki
– I am a bot. This action was performed automatically! If you think it was incorrect, please notify us on Discord or Reddit
I'm quite certain that this is actually a duplicate of MC-195736.
I believe this is a duplicate of MC-195736.
Thank you for your report!
We're tracking this issue in MC-195736, so this ticket is being resolved and linked as a duplicate.
If you would like to add a vote and any extra information to the main ticket it would be appreciated.
If you haven't already, you might like to make use of the search feature to see if the issue has already been mentioned.
Quick Links:
📓 Bug Tracker Guidelines – 💬 Community Support – 📧 Mojang Support
📓 Project Summary – ✍️ Feedback and Suggestions – 📖 Game Wiki
– I am a bot. This action was performed automatically! The ticket was resolved by one of our moderators, and I left this message to give more information to you.
This ticket actually appears to be a duplicate of MC-195736.
Duplicate of MC-195736.
Thank you for your report!
We're tracking this issue in MC-195736, so this ticket is being resolved and linked as a duplicate.
If you would like to add a vote and any extra information to the main ticket it would be appreciated.
If you haven't already, you might like to make use of the search feature to see if the issue has already been mentioned.
Quick Links:
📓 Bug Tracker Guidelines – 💬 Community Support – 📧 Mojang Support
📓 Project Summary – ✍️ Feedback and Suggestions – 📖 Game Wiki
– I am a bot. This action was performed automatically! The ticket was resolved by one of our moderators, and I left this message to give more information to you.
Thank you for your report!
We're tracking this issue in MC-195736, so this ticket is being resolved and linked as a duplicate.
If you would like to add a vote and any extra information to the main ticket it would be appreciated.
If you haven't already, you might like to make use of the search feature to see if the issue has already been mentioned.
Quick Links:
📓 Bug Tracker Guidelines – 💬 Community Support – 📧 Mojang Support
📓 Project Summary – ✍️ Feedback and Suggestions – 📖 Game Wiki
– I am a bot. This action was performed automatically! The ticket was resolved by one of our moderators, and I left this message to give more information to you.
Can confirm
Confirmed as a bug in latest version.
Can confirm in 1.17.
1.17.1 still has this issue, the same also happens even when under a "slab ceiling".
This bug can also be reproduced by closing a trapdoor on your feet.
Even under a "slab ceiling" you can move at normal walking speed (instead of sneak speed) while your feet are in a transparent block.
Confirmed in 22w12a with stairs:
