Missing stat.mineBlock for various blocks (mob spawners, cauldrons, beds, etc.)
Attempting to add a stat.mineBlock objective using the following blocks produces an Invalid objective criteria type error:
- minecraft:bed
- minecraft:brewing_stand
- minecraft:cake
- minecraft:cauldron
- minecraft:cocoa
- minecraft:daylight_detector_inverted
- minecraft:fire
- minecraft:flower_pot
- minecraft:grass_path
- minecraft:melon_stem
- minecraft:pumpkin_stem
- minecraft:mob_spawner
- minecraft:piston_head
- minecraft:powered_comparator
- minecraft:unpowered_comparator
- minecraft:powered_repeater
- minecraft:unpowered_repeater
- minecraft:purpur_double_slab
- minecraft:redstone_wire
- minecraft:reeds
- minecraft:skull
- minecraft:standing_banner
- minecraft:wall_banner
- minecraft:standing_sign
- minecraft:wall_sign
- minecraft:trapdoor
- minecraft:iron_trapdoor
- minecraft:tripwire
- minecraft:wheat
- minecraft:beetroots
- minecraft:carrots
- minecraft:potatoes
- minecraft:nether_wart
- minecraft:wooden_door
- minecraft:acacia_door
- minecraft:birch_door
- minecraft:dark_oak_door
- minecraft:jungle_door
- minecraft:spruce_door
- minecraft:iron_door
Missing blocks (not mineable)
As minecraft:end_portal_frame or minecraft:command_block both work, these blocks could be added as well.
- minecraft:barrier
- minecraft:bedrock
- minecraft:end_gateway
- minecraft:end_portal
- minecraft:flowing_lava
- minecraft:flowing_water
- minecraft:lava
- minecraft:water
- minecraft:piston_extension
- minecraft:portal
Counted within different statistics
Their own stats are missing, but they are counted as other (similar) blocks.
| Affected block | Counts as |
|---|---|
| minecraft:double_stone_slab | minecraft:stone_slab |
| minecraft:double_stone_slab2 | minecraft:stone_slab2 |
| minecraft:double_wooden_slab | minecraft:wooden_slab |
| minecraft:lit_furnace | minecraft:furnace |
| minecraft:lit_redstone_lamp | minecraft:redstone_lamp |
| minecraft:lit_redstone_ore | minecraft:redstone_ore |
| minecraft:unlit_redstone_torch | minecraft:redstone_torch |
Code analysis by Marcono1234 can be found in this comment.
Linked Issues
is duplicated by9
MC-48894blocks missing from scoreboard objective stat.mineBlockDuplicateMC-49045Missing stat.mineBlock.minecraft.nether_wartDuplicateMC-65050stat.mineBlock.minecraft.grass does not register when mining grassDuplicateMC-79531Sugarcane scoreboard objective not availableDuplicateMC-79642Scoreboard bug with skullsDuplicateMC-81268stat.mineBlock.minecraft:grass doesn't work.DuplicateMC-95615Farmland block not tracked by statisticsDuplicateMC-97949"stat.mineBlock.minecraft.bed" does not existDuplicateMC-105602stat.mineBlock.minecraft.banner missingDuplicateAttachments2
- Fixed
Dallas Rihm- 48
- 21
- Confirmed
- objectives scoreboard
13w42b - 17w48a
13w42b 1.7.4 14w02b 14w02c 14w04b 14w05b 14w06a 14w06b 14w07a 14w08a 1.7.5 14w11b 14w20b 14w21a 14w21b 14w30c 14w31a 1.8 1.8.2-pre6 1.8.3 1.8.7 1.8.8 15w38a 15w38b 15w47c 15w49a 15w49b 1.8.9 15w51b 16w04a 16w05a 16w05b 16w06a 16w07a 16w07b 1.9-pre1 1.9-pre2 1.9 1.9.1-pre1 1.9.1-pre2 1.9.1-pre3 1.9.1 1.9.2 1.9.4 16w20a 16w21b 1.10-pre1 1.10.2 16w32a 16w32b 16w33a 16w35a 16w39b 16w39c 16w40a 16w41a 16w44a 1.11 1.11.2 17w13a 1.12 1.12.1 17w48a- 17w49a
Created Issue:
stat.mineBlock cannot detect Spawners and Cauldrons
When you make a new objective for mining a block, it is unable to accept when you break Spawners (ID:52) or Cauldrons (ID:118 and 380)
Attachments2
is duplicated by
I guess that it's the same issue for nether wart?
is duplicated by
![[Mod] Torabi](../../../data/assets/gravatar/torabi.png){kind=small}
When you make a new objective for miningablock, it is unable to accept when you break Spawners (ID:52) or Cauldrons (ID:118 and 380)Attempting to add a stat.mineBlock objective using the following blocks produces an "Invalid objective criteria type" error:
- minecraft:bed
- minecraft:mob_spawner
- minecraft:redstone_wire
- minecraft:wheat
- minecraft:standing_sign
- minecraft:wooden_door
- minecraft:wall_sign
- minecraft:iron_door
- minecraft:reeds
- minecraft:unpowered_repeater
- minecraft:powered_repeater
- minecraft:trapdoor
- minecraft:pumpkin_stem
- minecraft:melon_stem
- minecraft:nether_wart
- minecraft:brewing_stand
- minecraft:cauldron
- minecraft:flower_pot
- minecraft:carrots
- minecraft:potatoes
- minecraft:unpowered_comparator
- minecraft:powered_comparator
- minecraft:double_stone_slab
- minecraft:double_stone_slab2
- minecraft:double_wooden_slab
- minecraft:standing_banner
- minecraft:wall_banner
stat.mineBlock objectives can successfully be added for the following blocks, but the objective will not increase when they are mined:
- minecraft:grass - Not even with silk touch
- minecraft:lit_furnace - Counts as a furnace instead
- minecraft:farmland - Counts as dirt
stat.mineBlock cannot detectSpawnersand Cauldronsstat.mineBlock cannot detect spawners, cauldrons, and various other blocks
is duplicated by
Attempting to add a stat.mineBlock objective using the following blocks produces an "Invalid objective criteria type" error:
- minecraft:bed
- minecraft:mob_spawner
- minecraft:redstone_wire
- minecraft:wheat
- minecraft:standing_sign
- minecraft:wooden_door
- minecraft:wall_sign
- minecraft:iron_door
- minecraft:reeds
- minecraft:unpowered_repeater
- minecraft:powered_repeater
- minecraft:trapdoor
- minecraft:pumpkin_stem
- minecraft:melon_stem
- minecraft:nether_wart
- minecraft:brewing_stand
- minecraft:cauldron
- minecraft:flower_pot
- minecraft:carrots
- minecraft:potatoes
- minecraft:unpowered_comparator
- minecraft:powered_comparator
- minecraft:double_stone_slab
- minecraft:double_stone_slab2
- minecraft:double_wooden_slab
- minecraft:standing_banner
- minecraft:wall_banner
- minecraft:skull
stat.mineBlock objectives can successfully be added for the following blocks, but the objective will not increase when they are mined:
- minecraft:grass - Not even with silk touch
- minecraft:lit_furnace - Counts as a furnace instead
- minecraft:farmland - Counts as dirt
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
Attempting to add a stat.mineBlock objective using the following blocks produces an "Invalid objective criteria type" error:
- minecraft:bed
- minecraft:mob_spawner
- minecraft:redstone_wire
- minecraft:wheat
- minecraft:standing_sign
- minecraft:wooden_door
- minecraft:wall_sign
- minecraft:iron_door
- minecraft:reeds
- minecraft:unpowered_repeater
- minecraft:powered_repeater
- minecraft:trapdoor
- minecraft:pumpkin_stem
- minecraft:melon_stem
- minecraft:nether_wart
- minecraft:brewing_stand
- minecraft:cauldron
- minecraft:flower_pot
- minecraft:carrots
- minecraft:potatoes
- minecraft:unpowered_comparator
- minecraft:powered_comparator
- minecraft:double_stone_slab
- minecraft:double_stone_slab2
- minecraft:double_wooden_slab
- minecraft:standing_banner
- minecraft:wall_banner
- minecraft:skull
- minecraft:lit_redstone_lamp
- minecraft:daylight_detector_inverted
- minecraft:piston_head
- minecraft:spruce_door
- minecraft:birch_door
- minecraft:jungle_door
- minecraft:acacia_door
- minecraft:dark_oak_door
- minecraft:beetroots
stat.mineBlock objectives can successfully be added for the following blocks, but the objective will not increase when they are mined:
- minecraft:grass - Not even with silk touch
- minecraft:lit_furnace - Counts as a furnace instead
- minecraft:farmland - Counts as dirt
Attempting to add a stat.mineBlock objective using the following blocks produces an "Invalid objective criteria type" error:
- minecraft:bed
- minecraft:mob_spawner
- minecraft:redstone_wire
- minecraft:wheat
- minecraft:standing_sign
- minecraft:wooden_door
- minecraft:wall_sign
- minecraft:iron_door
- minecraft:reeds
- minecraft:unpowered_repeater
- minecraft:powered_repeater
- minecraft:trapdoor
- minecraft:pumpkin_stem
- minecraft:melon_stem
- minecraft:nether_wart
- minecraft:brewing_stand
- minecraft:cauldron
- minecraft:flower_pot
- minecraft:carrots
- minecraft:potatoes
- minecraft:unpowered_comparator
- minecraft:powered_comparator
- minecraft:double_stone_slab
- minecraft:double_stone_slab2
- minecraft:double_wooden_slab
- minecraft:standing_banner
- minecraft:wall_banner
- minecraft:skull
- minecraft:lit_redstone_lamp
- minecraft:daylight_detector_inverted
- minecraft:piston_head
- minecraft:spruce_door
- minecraft:birch_door
- minecraft:jungle_door
- minecraft:acacia_door
- minecraft:dark_oak_door
- minecraft:beetroots
stat.mineBlock objectives can successfully be added for the following blocks, but the objective will not increase when they are mined:
- minecraft:grass - Not even with silk touch
- minecraft:lit_furnace - Counts as a furnace instead
- minecraft:farmland - Counts as dirt
is duplicated by
relates to
is duplicated by
relates to
is duplicated by
relates to
is duplicated by
![[Mod] Skylinerw](../../../data/assets/gravatar/skylinerw.png){kind=small}
is duplicated by
stat.mineBlockcannot detect spawners, cauldrons, and various other blocksMissing stat.mineBlock for various blocks (mob spawners, cauldrons, beds, etc.)
Attempting to add a stat.mineBlock objective using the following blocks produces an "Invalid objective criteria type" error:
- minecraft:bed
- minecraft:mob_spawner
- minecraft:redstone_wire
- minecraft:wheat
- minecraft:standing_sign
- minecraft:wooden_door
- minecraft:wall_sign
- minecraft:iron_door
- minecraft:reeds
- minecraft:unpowered_repeater
- minecraft:powered_repeater
- minecraft:trapdoor
- minecraft:pumpkin_stem
- minecraft:melon_stem
- minecraft:nether_wart
- minecraft:brewing_stand
- minecraft:cauldron
- minecraft:flower_pot
- minecraft:carrots
- minecraft:potatoes
- minecraft:unpowered_comparator
- minecraft:powered_comparator
- minecraft:double_stone_slab
- minecraft:double_stone_slab2
- minecraft:double_wooden_slab
- minecraft:standing_banner
- minecraft:wall_banner
- minecraft:skull
- minecraft:lit_redstone_lamp
- minecraft:daylight_detector_inverted
- minecraft:piston_head
- minecraft:spruce_door
- minecraft:birch_door
- minecraft:jungle_door
- minecraft:acacia_door
- minecraft:dark_oak_door
- minecraft:beetroots
Missing blocks (not mineable)
As minecraft:end_portal_frame or minecraft:command_block both work, these blocks could be added as well.
- minecraft:bedrock
- minecraft:piston_extension
- minecraft:portal
- minecraft:end_portal
- minecraft:end_gateway
- minecraft:water
- minecraft:lava
stat.mineBlock objectives can successfully be added for the following blocks, but the objective will not increase when they are mined:
- minecraft:grass - Not even with silk touch
- minecraft:lit_furnace - Counts as a furnace instead
- minecraft:farmland - Counts as dirt
Attempting to add a stat.mineBlock objective using the following blocks produces an "Invalid objective criteria type" error:
- minecraft:bed
- minecraft:mob_spawner
- minecraft:redstone_wire
- minecraft:wheat
- minecraft:standing_sign
- minecraft:wooden_door
- minecraft:wall_sign
- minecraft:iron_door
- minecraft:reeds
- minecraft:unpowered_repeater
- minecraft:powered_repeater
- minecraft:trapdoor
- minecraft:pumpkin_stem
- minecraft:melon_stem
- minecraft:nether_wart
- minecraft:brewing_stand
- minecraft:cauldron
- minecraft:flower_pot
- minecraft:carrots
- minecraft:potatoes
- minecraft:unpowered_comparator
- minecraft:powered_comparator
- minecraft:double_stone_slab
- minecraft:double_stone_slab2
- minecraft:double_wooden_slab
- minecraft:standing_banner
- minecraft:wall_banner
- minecraft:skull
- minecraft:lit_redstone_lamp
- minecraft:daylight_detector_inverted
- minecraft:piston_head
- minecraft:spruce_door
- minecraft:birch_door
- minecraft:jungle_door
- minecraft:acacia_door
- minecraft:dark_oak_door
- minecraft:beetroots
Missing blocks (not mineable)
As minecraft:end_portal_frame or minecraft:command_block both work, these blocks could be added as well.
- minecraft:bedrock
- minecraft:piston_extension
- minecraft:portal
- minecraft:end_portal
- minecraft:end_gateway
- minecraft:water
- minecraft:lava
stat.mineBlock objectives can successfully be added for the following blocks, but the objective will not increase when they are mined:
- minecraft:
grass - Not even with silk touch- minecraft:
lit_furnace- Counts asa furnace instead- minecraft:farmland - Counts as dirt
Attempting to add a stat.mineBlock objective using the following blocks produces an "Invalid objective criteria type" error:
- minecraft:bed
- minecraft:mob_spawner
- minecraft:redstone_wire
- minecraft:wheat
- minecraft:standing_sign
- minecraft:wooden_door
- minecraft:wall_sign
- minecraft:iron_door
- minecraft:reeds
- minecraft:unpowered_repeater
- minecraft:powered_repeater
- minecraft:trapdoor
- minecraft:pumpkin_stem
- minecraft:melon_stem
- minecraft:nether_wart
- minecraft:brewing_stand
- minecraft:cauldron
- minecraft:flower_pot
- minecraft:carrots
- minecraft:potatoes
- minecraft:unpowered_comparator
- minecraft:powered_comparator
- minecraft:double_stone_slab
- minecraft:double_stone_slab2
- minecraft:double_wooden_slab
- minecraft:standing_banner
- minecraft:wall_banner
- minecraft:skull
- minecraft:lit_redstone_lamp
- minecraft:daylight_detector_inverted
- minecraft:piston_head
- minecraft:spruce_door
- minecraft:birch_door
- minecraft:jungle_door
- minecraft:acacia_door
- minecraft:dark_oak_door
- minecraft:beetroots
Missing blocks (not mineable)
As minecraft:end_portal_frame or minecraft:command_block both work, these blocks could be added as well.
- minecraft:bedrock
- minecraft:piston_extension
- minecraft:portal
- minecraft:end_portal
- minecraft:end_gateway
- minecraft:water
- minecraft:lava
stat.mineBlock objectives can successfully be added for the following blocks, but the objective will not increase when they are mined:
- minecraft:lit_furnace - Counts as a furnace
- minecraft:grass - Counts as dirt
- minecraft:farmland - Counts as dirt
is duplicated by
![[Mod] Neko](../../../data/avatars/users/92901.png){kind=small}
relates to
Attempting to add a stat.mineBlock objective using the following blocks produces an "Invalid objective criteria type" error:
- minecraft:bed
- minecraft:mob_spawner
- minecraft:redstone_wire
- minecraft:wheat
- minecraft:standing_sign
- minecraft:wooden_door
- minecraft:wall_sign
- minecraft:iron_door
- minecraft:reeds
- minecraft:unpowered_repeater
- minecraft:powered_repeater
- minecraft:trapdoor
- minecraft:pumpkin_stem
- minecraft:melon_stem
- minecraft:nether_wart
- minecraft:brewing_stand
- minecraft:cauldron
- minecraft:flower_pot
- minecraft:carrots
- minecraft:potatoes
- minecraft:unpowered_comparator
- minecraft:powered_comparator
- minecraft:double_stone_slab
- minecraft:double_stone_slab2
- minecraft:double_wooden_slab
- minecraft:standing_banner
- minecraft:wall_banner
- minecraft:skull
- minecraft:lit_redstone_lamp
- minecraft:daylight_detector_inverted
- minecraft:piston_head
- minecraft:spruce_door
- minecraft:birch_door
- minecraft:jungle_door
- minecraft:acacia_door
- minecraft:dark_oak_door
- minecraft:beetroots
Missing blocks (not mineable)
As minecraft:end_portal_frame or minecraft:command_block both work, these blocks could be added as well.
- minecraft:bedrock
- minecraft:piston_extension
- minecraft:portal
- minecraft:end_portal
- minecraft:end_gateway
- minecraft:water
- minecraft:lava
stat.mineBlock objectives can successfully be added for the following blocks, but the objective will not increase when they are mined:
- minecraft:lit_furnace - Counts as a furnace
- minecraft:grass - Counts as dirt
- minecraft:farmland - Counts as dirt
relates to
![[Mod] Michael Wobst](../../../data/avatars/users/37868.png){kind=small}
Attempting to add a stat.mineBlock objective using the following blocks produces an "Invalid objective criteria type" error:
- minecraft:bed
- minecraft:mob_spawner
- minecraft:redstone_wire
- minecraft:wheat
- minecraft:standing_sign
- minecraft:wooden_door
- minecraft:wall_sign
- minecraft:iron_door
- minecraft:reeds
- minecraft:unpowered_repeater
- minecraft:powered_repeater
- minecraft:trapdoor
- minecraft:pumpkin_stem
- minecraft:melon_stem
- minecraft:nether_wart
- minecraft:brewing_stand
- minecraft:cauldron
- minecraft:flower_pot
- minecraft:carrots
- minecraft:potatoes
- minecraft:unpowered_comparator
- minecraft:powered_comparator
- minecraft:double_stone_slab
- minecraft:double_stone_slab2
- minecraft:double_wooden_slab
- minecraft:standing_banner
- minecraft:wall_banner
- minecraft:skull
- minecraft:lit_redstone_lamp
- minecraft:daylight_detector_inverted
- minecraft:piston_head
- minecraft:spruce_door
- minecraft:birch_door
- minecraft:jungle_door
- minecraft:acacia_door
- minecraft:dark_oak_door
- minecraft:beetroots
Missing blocks (not mineable)
As minecraft:end_portal_frame or minecraft:command_block both work, these blocks could be added as well.
- minecraft:bedrock
- minecraft:piston_extension
- minecraft:portal
- minecraft:end_portal
- minecraft:end_gateway
- minecraft:water
- minecraft:lava
Attempting to add a stat.mineBlock objective using the following blocks produces an "Invalid objective criteria type" error:
- minecraft:bed
- minecraft:mob_spawner
- minecraft:redstone_wire
- minecraft:wheat
- minecraft:standing_sign
- minecraft:wooden_door
- minecraft:wall_sign
- minecraft:iron_door
- minecraft:reeds
- minecraft:unpowered_repeater
- minecraft:powered_repeater
- minecraft:trapdoor
- minecraft:pumpkin_stem
- minecraft:melon_stem
- minecraft:nether_wart
- minecraft:brewing_stand
- minecraft:cauldron
- minecraft:flower_pot
- minecraft:carrots
- minecraft:potatoes
- minecraft:unpowered_comparator
- minecraft:powered_comparator
- minecraft:double_stone_slab
- minecraft:double_stone_slab2
- minecraft:double_wooden_slab
- minecraft:standing_banner
- minecraft:wall_banner
- minecraft:skull
- minecraft:lit_redstone_lamp
- minecraft:daylight_detector_inverted
- minecraft:piston_head
- minecraft:spruce_door
- minecraft:birch_door
- minecraft:jungle_door
- minecraft:acacia_door
- minecraft:dark_oak_door
- minecraft:beetroots
Missing blocks (not mineable)
As minecraft:end_portal_frame or minecraft:command_block both work, these blocks could be added as well.
- minecraft:bedrock
- minecraft:piston_extension
- minecraft:portal
- minecraft:end_portal
- minecraft:end_gateway
- minecraft:water
- minecraft:lava
Code analysis by Marcono1234 can be found in this comment.
Attempting to add a stat.mineBlock objective using the following blocks produces an "Invalid objective criteria type" error:
- minecraft:bed
- minecraft:
mob_spawner- minecraft:
redstone_wire- minecraft:
wheat- minecraft:
standing_sign- minecraft:
wooden_door- minecraft:
wall_sign- minecraft:
iron_door- minecraft:
reeds- minecraft:
unpowered_repeater- minecraft:p
owered_repeater- minecraft:
trapdoor- minecraft:p
umpkin_stem- minecraft:
melon_stem- minecraft:
nether_wart- minecraft:
brewing_stand- minecraft:
cauldron- minecraft:
flower_pot- minecraft:
carrots- minecraft:
potatoes- minecraft:
unpowered_comparator- minecraft:
powered_comparator- minecraft:
double_stone_slab- minecraft:
double_stone_slab2- minecraft:
double_wooden_slab- minecraft:
standing_banner- minecraft:
wall_banner- minecraft:
skull- minecraft:
lit_redstone_lamp- minecraft:
daylight_detector_inverted- minecraft:
piston_head- minecraft:
spruce_door- minecraft:
birch_door- minecraft:
jungle_door- minecraft:acacia_door
- minecraft:
dark_oak_door- minecraft:
beetrootsMissing blocks (not mineable)
As minecraft:end_portal_frame or minecraft:command_block both work, these blocks could be added as well.
- minecraft:b
edrock- minecraft:
piston_extension- minecraft:
portal- minecraft:end_portal
- minecraft:
end_gateway- minecraft:water
- minecraft:lava
Code analysis by Marcono1234 can be found in this comment.
Attempting to add a stat.mineBlock objective using the following blocks produces an "Invalid objective criteria type" error:
- minecraft:bed
- minecraft:brewing_stand
- minecraft:cake
- minecraft:cauldron
- minecraft:cocoa
- minecraft:daylight_detector_inverted
- minecraft:fire
- minecraft:flower_pot
- minecraft:grass_path
- minecraft:melon_stem
- minecraft:pumpkin_stem
- minecraft:mob_spawner
- minecraft:piston_head
- minecraft:powered_comparator
- minecraft:unpowered_comparator
- minecraft:powered_repeater
- minecraft:unpowered_repeater
- minecraft:purpur_double_slab
- minecraft:redstone_wire
- minecraft:reeds
- minecraft:skull
- minecraft:standing_banner
- minecraft:wall_banner
- minecraft:standing_sign
- minecraft:wall_sign
- minecraft:trapdoor
- minecraft:iron_trapdoor
- minecraft:tripwire
- minecraft:wheat
- minecraft:beetroots
- minecraft:carrots
- minecraft:potatoes
- minecraft:nether_wart
- minecraft:wooden_door
- minecraft:acacia_door
- minecraft:birch_door
- minecraft:dark_oak_door
- minecraft:jungle_door
- minecraft:spruce_door
- minecraft:iron_door
Missing blocks (not mineable)
As minecraft:end_portal_frame or minecraft:command_block both work, these blocks could be added as well.
- minecraft:barrier
- minecraft:bedrock
- minecraft:end_gateway
- minecraft:end_portal
- minecraft:flowing_lava
- minecraft:flowing_water
- minecraft:lava
- minecraft:water
- minecraft:piston_extension
- minecraft:portal
Counted within different statistics
Their own stats are missing, but they are counted as other (similar) blocks.
Affected block Counts as minecraft:double_stone_slab minecraft:stone_slab minecraft:double_stone_slab2 minecraft:stone_slab2 minecraft:double_wooden_slab minecraft:wooden_slab minecraft:lit_furnace minecraft:furnace minecraft:lit_redstone_lamp minecraft:redstone_lamp minecraft:lit_redstone_ore minecraft:redstone_ore minecraft:unlit_redstone_torch minecraft:redstone_torch
Code analysis by Marcono1234 can be found in this comment.
Attempting to add a stat.mineBlock objective using the following blocks produces an "Invalid objective criteria type" error:
- minecraft:bed
- minecraft:brewing_stand
- minecraft:cake
- minecraft:cauldron
- minecraft:cocoa
- minecraft:daylight_detector_inverted
- minecraft:fire
- minecraft:flower_pot
- minecraft:grass_path
- minecraft:melon_stem
- minecraft:pumpkin_stem
- minecraft:mob_spawner
- minecraft:piston_head
- minecraft:powered_comparator
- minecraft:unpowered_comparator
- minecraft:powered_repeater
- minecraft:unpowered_repeater
- minecraft:purpur_double_slab
- minecraft:redstone_wire
- minecraft:reeds
- minecraft:skull
- minecraft:standing_banner
- minecraft:wall_banner
- minecraft:standing_sign
- minecraft:wall_sign
- minecraft:trapdoor
- minecraft:iron_trapdoor
- minecraft:tripwire
- minecraft:wheat
- minecraft:beetroots
- minecraft:carrots
- minecraft:potatoes
- minecraft:nether_wart
- minecraft:wooden_door
- minecraft:acacia_door
- minecraft:birch_door
- minecraft:dark_oak_door
- minecraft:jungle_door
- minecraft:spruce_door
- minecraft:iron_door
Missing blocks (not mineable)
As minecraft:end_portal_frame or minecraft:command_block both work, these blocks could be added as well.
- minecraft:barrier
- minecraft:bedrock
- minecraft:end_gateway
- minecraft:end_portal
- minecraft:flowing_lava
- minecraft:flowing_water
- minecraft:lava
- minecraft:water
- minecraft:piston_extension
- minecraft:portal
Counted within different statistics
Their own stats are missing, but they are counted as other (similar) blocks.
Affected block Counts as minecraft:double_stone_slab minecraft:stone_slab minecraft:double_stone_slab2 minecraft:stone_slab2 minecraft:double_wooden_slab minecraft:wooden_slab minecraft:lit_furnace minecraft:furnace minecraft:lit_redstone_lamp minecraft:redstone_lamp minecraft:lit_redstone_ore minecraft:redstone_ore minecraft:unlit_redstone_torch minecraft:redstone_torch
Code analysis by Marcono1234 can be found in this comment.
Attempting to add a stat.mineBlock objective using the following blocks produces an Invalid objective criteria type error:
- minecraft:bed
- minecraft:brewing_stand
- minecraft:cake
- minecraft:cauldron
- minecraft:cocoa
- minecraft:daylight_detector_inverted
- minecraft:fire
- minecraft:flower_pot
- minecraft:grass_path
- minecraft:melon_stem
- minecraft:pumpkin_stem
- minecraft:mob_spawner
- minecraft:piston_head
- minecraft:powered_comparator
- minecraft:unpowered_comparator
- minecraft:powered_repeater
- minecraft:unpowered_repeater
- minecraft:purpur_double_slab
- minecraft:redstone_wire
- minecraft:reeds
- minecraft:skull
- minecraft:standing_banner
- minecraft:wall_banner
- minecraft:standing_sign
- minecraft:wall_sign
- minecraft:trapdoor
- minecraft:iron_trapdoor
- minecraft:tripwire
- minecraft:wheat
- minecraft:beetroots
- minecraft:carrots
- minecraft:potatoes
- minecraft:nether_wart
- minecraft:wooden_door
- minecraft:acacia_door
- minecraft:birch_door
- minecraft:dark_oak_door
- minecraft:jungle_door
- minecraft:spruce_door
- minecraft:iron_door
Missing blocks (not mineable)
As minecraft:end_portal_frame or minecraft:command_block both work, these blocks could be added as well.
- minecraft:barrier
- minecraft:bedrock
- minecraft:end_gateway
- minecraft:end_portal
- minecraft:flowing_lava
- minecraft:flowing_water
- minecraft:lava
- minecraft:water
- minecraft:piston_extension
- minecraft:portal
Counted within different statistics
Their own stats are missing, but they are counted as other (similar) blocks.
Affected block Counts as minecraft:double_stone_slab minecraft:stone_slab minecraft:double_stone_slab2 minecraft:stone_slab2 minecraft:double_wooden_slab minecraft:wooden_slab minecraft:lit_furnace minecraft:furnace minecraft:lit_redstone_lamp minecraft:redstone_lamp minecraft:lit_redstone_ore minecraft:redstone_ore minecraft:unlit_redstone_torch minecraft:redstone_torch
Code analysis by Marcono1234 can be found in this comment.
Confirmed in 16w40a
Confirmed in 16w35a
Confirmed in 16w39c
Confirmed in 16w41a
Confirmed in 16w39b
![[Mod] tryashtar](../../../data/avatars/users/41963.png){kind=small}
Duplicate of MC-36191
Putting out a fire and breaking blocks are both actions which remove a placed block from the world. However, putting out a fire is not actually considered a form of block breaking, which leads to some rather odd effects. For example:
- While stat.mineBlock exists for fire (see comments of
MC-36191), the action of putting out a fire will not actually increment this value at all. This can be tested simply by checking your statistics after "mining" the fire block.
- It is possible to put out fires in Creative mode while holding a sword or trident, despite the fact that these are programmed to not break any blocks whatsoever (and fire is a block). See
MC-30414.
- Breaking most blocks displays the subtitle "Block broken", but putting out a fire displays its own subtitle "Fire extinguished". The only other block to have a unique block breaking subtitle is the turtle egg (see also MC-147246), and also anvils when used up or dropped too much, however both for different reasons. (I personally would prefer a unique translation string for each block being broken subtitle, but that's just me.) Fire's actual material type is wool, whose sounds can be heard when supporting blocks are removed (see
MC-91091); this should probably be changed by introducing a new fire material type, so the correct sound plays in such cases.
- There exists no loot table for the fire block, despite most other blocks having one.
There may be other things to test out, but those are just a few.
The bug
Unlike many other similar blocks, fire is not assigned a dedicated item form. This results in several issues arising which are not present for other blocks:
- Nothing is returned when using Pick Block on fire (
MC-167842) - Fire is displayed as "Air" in the Superflat menu (MC-48058)
- Endermen which hold fire do not drop anything beyond their usual drops when killed (
MC-206449) - The amount of fires put out (i.e. fire blocks "broken") is not displayed at all in Statistics. There exists a statistic intended to track this (according to the comments of
MC-36191), but this never increments. - Blocks which have multiple block states can have a BlockStateTag assigned to their item form which will result in the item placing the block with a specified block state combination. However, despite fire having many block states to choose from, the lack of an assigned item form means that this tag can never be used to get a desired state combination for fire from an item that places it.
How to reproduce
Since this ticket concerns many issues that arise due to a central problem, there exist different ways to reproduce each sub-issue. A brief demonstration of some of these cases follow:
- Attempt to use Pick Block on fire, and note that nothing is returned
- Paste the following Superflat preset into the custom preset text box, and note the "Air" entry despite no air being specified in the preset:
minecraft:netherrack,minecraft:fire;minecraft:the_void
- Execute the following command to summon an enderman holding fire and kill it, noting that it can only drop experience and ender pearls, and nothing else:
/summon minecraft:enderman ~ ~ ~ {carriedBlockState:{Name:"minecraft:fire"},Health:1} - Put out a large amount of fires in a Survival world, then open Statistics and search for any fire-related entries; ultimately there will be no relevant cases
- Give yourself a fire charge (item most fitting for fire's item form) with the following command and place it, and use F3 to check the age state to note whether or not it's actually 7:
/give @p minecraft:fire_charge{BlockStateTag:{age:"7"}}
Expected results
Fire would have an associated item form.
Actual results
Fire does not have an item form. As a result, all of the above issues arise.
How to fix
The best candidate for fire's item form would be the fire charge, as it places fire on a right-click and is consumed upon use, unlike a flint and steel which has durability.
This matches up with other items that were assigned to the role of the item form of a block in 17w47a, such as seeds being tied to their respective crops, cases where distinct "floor" and "wall" variants neccessitated different item forms (e.g. heads, signs, banners), and other blocks which had a "different" item form beforehand (e.g. repeaters, comparators, cauldrons, cake, flower pots, redstone dust) being merged.
Plenty of other items were also given item forms that seem like a stretch when comapred to the fire charge being the item for fire; for example, buckets being made to be the item form of their respective fluids, despite not being entirely consumed upon use (and also likely being partially responsible for MC-205563).
Confirmed. Not having 380 makes sense as it is the item form of the cauldron.
Confirmed. Red mushrooms also present this issue, while brown mushrooms do not. I will update this comment for other blocks I find that can't be tracked.
EDIT: Confirmed for 1.7.4. Now present up to 14w06b. The exception is "flower", which has changed to "yellow_flower" and also works. The rest still do not.
Blocks you mine should be mined with the proper tool in order for it to count towards the score.
Blocks that are available to track but do not increment score:
1. minecraft:grass (2) - Not even with silk touch
3. minecraft:red_mushroom (39) - Brown mushrooms work, these do not.
4. minecraft:lit_furnace (62) - Counts as a furnace instead (61)
5. minecraft:farmland (60) - Counts as dirt (3)
6. minecraft:double_stone/wooden_slab (43/125) - The doubles count as a single slab (44/126)
Blocks that are listed as "Invalid objective criteria type":
1. minecraft:bed (26)
2. minecraft:mob_spawner (52)
3. minecraft:redstone_wire (55)
4. minecraft:wheat (59)
5. minecraft:standing_sign (63)
6. minecraft:wooden_door (64)
7. minecraft:wall_sign (68)
8. minecraft:iron_door (71)
9. minecraft:reeds (83)
10. minecraft:unpowered_repeater (93)
11. minecraft:powered_repeater (94)
12. minecraft:trapdoor (96)
13. minecraft:pumpkin_stem (104)
14. minecraft:melon_stem (105)
15. minecraft:nether_wart (115)
16. minecraft:brewing_stand (117)
17. minecraft:cauldron (118)
18. minecraft:flower_pot (140)
19. minecraft:carrots (141)
20. minecraft:potatoes (142)
21. minecraft:unpowered_comparator (149)
22. minecraft:powered_comparator (150)
Note: the above lists are not necessarily complete and will continue to be modified if more blocks are found
Confirmed for 14w02c/14w08a
Still a Problem in 14w11b.
This would be super useful if it was fixed.
You just have to use "stat.useItem.minecraft.cauldron" or "stat.useItem.minecraft.mob_spawner" instead of mineBlock.@Gary, this is incorrect. "useItem" is for tracking the placement or usage of a block/item. "mineBlock" tracks the destruction. Tested in 14w19a, "useItem" does not track the destruction of cauldrons or mob spawners, which is what the issue is (which is still an issue in 14w19a).
Ok, you're right.
Confirmed in 14w21b still unable to track the mining of mob_spawners
Confirmed for
standing_banner and wall_banner don't work neither
I have double-checked [Mod] Skylinerw's list for the current snapshot. Red mushrooms are fixed, double slabs now produce an error, standing_banner and wall_banner produce an error. I have not checked blocks that were not mentioned in the comments, so there may be others.
(Sigh) well I hope they'll fix this.... some day
15w38a still affected.
Confirmed for
Missing blocks
Missing blocks (not mineable)
As minecraft:end_portal_frame or minecraft:command_block works, maybe these blocks could be added as well.
Confirmed for 15w49b.
Confirmed for 15w51b
Still unable to check for mined Spawners, not had time to check others, just the one I was in need of.
Confirmed for 16w04a
Confirmed for 16w05a
Confirmed for 16w05b
Confirmed for 16w07a
starting to get the feeling this wont be fixed for 1.9 since it was reported back in 2013
Please link to this comment in the description
The following is based on decompiled version of Minecraft 1.8 using MCP. All method and class names are the names used in the decompiled version.
The method private static void func_151181_c() of the class net.minecraft.stats.StatList which adds all the stats for mining blocks uses the item names instead of the block names. This means if a block does not exist as a block item it does not get a stat. Additionally some blocks have stats disabled using the protected Block disableStats() method.
The method private static void replaceAllSimilarBlocks(StatBase[] p_75924_0_) is responsible for the fact that mining certain blocks like lit_furnace counts as mining a furnace.
Confirmed for 16w07b
Confirmed for 1.9-Pre1
Please link to my comment from the description
@Marcono1234: Here's the obfuscated names (for mojang's assistance):
Confirmed 1.9-Pre2
Confirmed for 1.9
still an issue in 1.9
Still in 1.9.1-pre1
Still in 1.9.1-pre3
Confirmed for 1.9.2
Confirmed 16w20a
Confirmed for 1.10-pre1.
1.10.2 Confirmed
Moved the list of existing but not changing objectives to
MC-105050Confirmed in 1.11.2
Confirmed 17w13a
Can confirm for MC 1.12.1.
This is fixed in 17w49a, but there are two things still not right:
1. The criteria for breaking banners now exists, but never increases score (
MC-122939).2. The criteria for breaking fire exists but never increases. Is it supposed to increase score when you put out fire with your fist? Or is it not possible to "mine" fire?
All the others exist and work as intended. I tested them all. There are some that have been re-named or act differently than they were intended to when this bug report was made, but those are the only two problematic issues.
Can confirm that the issue with fire persists in 19w14b. Should I make a separate ticket?
EDIT: New ticket at
MC-147708