MC-25976Blocks broken by flowing fluids do not produce particles or make breaking sounds
The bug
When a block which can be destroyed via a flowing liquid, such as grass, torches or flowers, is destroyed by a fluid, absolutely no sound is produced, nor are any breaking particles shown. Contrast this with breaking those blocks directly, via removing a supporting block, or by placing the fluid source directly inside of that block: in all those cases, particles and a breaking sound are produced, as one would expect.
How to reproduce
- Place down a non-solid block which is destroyed by fluids (ex. levers)
- Place down water or lava in the same block space the block is in
→ You will see breaking particles and hear the breaking sound - Place another non-solid block which is destroyed by fluids next to the fluid source
→ You will see that the block is destroyed but there are not breaking particles nor a breaking sound
Expected behavior
The expected behavior would be that breaking particles and sounds would always be produced; see MC-122251.
The expected behaviour can also be encountered in the since-discontinued Console Edition, which may also make this a parity issue. Example of this expected behaviour: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yxiKwynwE9U&t=58s
Linked Issues
is duplicated by2
- Unresolved
Connor Steppie- John Distler
- 24
- 12
- Confirmed
Low- Platform
- Particles Sound
- general-breaking-zone missing-particle missing-sound vanilla-parity
1.6.1 - 24w35a
1.6.1 1.6.2 1.11.2 17w06a 1.12.2 1.13 18w30b 1.13.1 1.13.2 18w48a 18w48b 18w49a 18w50a 19w02a 19w03a 19w03b 19w04a 19w06a 19w07a 19w11a 19w12b 19w13a 19w13b 19w14a 19w14b 1.14-pre1 1.14-pre2 1.14-pre5 1.14.2-pre1 1.14.2-pre3 1.14.3-pre3 1.14.3-pre4 1.14.4-pre4 19w35a 19w36a 19w37a 19w38b 19w39a 19w40a 19w41a 19w42a 19w44a 19w45a 1.15-pre1 1.15-pre2 1.15-pre3 1.15-pre4 1.15-pre6 1.15-pre7 1.15.1-pre1 1.15.2-pre1 1.15.2-pre2 20w06a 20w07a 20w08a 20w09a 20w10a 20w11a 20w12a 20w13a 20w21a 1.16-pre2 1.16-pre3 1.16-pre4 1.16-pre5 1.16-pre7 20w28a 20w29a 20w30a 1.16.2-pre1 1.16.3-rc1 1.16.3 1.16.4 20w51a 21w03a 21w05a 21w05b 21w06a 21w07a 21w08b 21w11a 21w14a 21w17a 21w18a 21w20a 1.17-pre1 1.17 1.17.1-rc1 1.17.1 1.18 1.18.1 1.18.2 22w12a 1.19 1.19.2 1.20-rc1 1.20 1.20.1 23w32a 1.20.2 1.20.4 1.21 24w35a
Created Issue:
When destroying non-blocks that are destroyed by fluids (besides air), by placing water or lava in the block, a breaking sound, and particles result.
Steps to reproduce:
1. Place down a non-solid block that is destroyed by fluids (ex. levers).
2. Place down water or lava in the same block space the block is in.
3. A breaking sound, and particles should result.
This bug is probably related to the bug of placing fluids inside each other.
Environment
Irrelevant
Attachments4
- Unresolved
- Open
- Unconfirmed
- fluid non_solid_blocks
- 1.6.1 1.6.2
When destroying *non-blocks that are destroyed by fluids* ex. levers (besides air), by placing water or lava in the block, a breaking sound, and particles result.
Steps to reproduce:
1. Place down a non-solid block that is destroyed by fluids (ex. levers).
2. Place down water or lava in the same block space the block is in.
3. A breaking sound, and particles should result.
This bug is probably related to the bug of placing fluids inside each other.
This bug is defiantly not intended
When destroying *non-blocks that are destroyed by fluids* ex. levers (besides air), by placing water or lava in the block, a breaking sound, and particles result unlike when fluids flow into the non-solid block that is destroyed by fluids..
When destroying *non-blocks that are destroyed by fluids* ex. levers (besides air), by placing water or lava in the block, a breaking sound, and particles result unlike when fluids flow into the non-solid block that is destroyed by fluids..
When destroying*non-blocks that are destroyed by fluids* ex. levers (besides air), by placing water or lava in the block, a breaking sound, and particles result unlike when fluids flow into the non-solid block that is destroyed by fluids.
When destroying non-blocks that are destroyed by fluids* ex. levers (besides air),by placing water or lava in the block, a breaking sound, and particles result unlike when fluids flow into the non-solid block thatis destroyed by fluids.*Destroying non-blocks that are destroyed by fluids besides air (ex. levers), by placing water or lava in the same block, a breaking sound, and particles result unlike when fluids flow into the non-solid block that's destroyed by fluids.*
*Destroying non-blocks that are destroyed by fluids besides air (ex. levers), by placingwater or lavain the same block, a breaking sound, and particles result unlike when fluids flow into the non-solid block that's destroyed by fluids.**Destroying non-blocks that are destroyed by fluids besides air (ex. levers), by placing a fluid in the same block space, a breaking sound, and particles result unlike when fluids flow into the non-solid block that's destroyed by fluids.*
*Destroying non-blocks that are destroyed by fluids besides air (ex. levers), by placing a fluid in the same block space, a breaking sound, and particles result unlike when fluids flow into the non-solid block that's destroyed by fluids.**Breaking non-blocks that are destroyed by fluids besides air (ex. levers), by placing a fluid in the same block space, a breaking sound, and particles result unlike when fluids flow into the non-solid block that's destroyed by fluids.*
*Breaking non-blocks that are destroyed by fluids besides air (ex. levers), by placing a fluid in the same block space, a breaking sound, and particles result unlike when fluids flow into the non-solid block that's destroyed by fluids.*
Steps to reproduce:
1. Place down a non-solid block that is destroyed by fluids (ex. levers).
2. Place down water or lava in the same block space the block is in.
3. A breaking sound, and particles should result.
This bug is probably related to the bug of placing fluids inside each other.
This bug is defiantly not intended
BE SURE TO READ THE BUG VERY VERY CAREFULLY.
This bug may be related to
Steps to reproduce:
1. Place down a non-solid block that is destroyed by fluids (ex. levers).
2. Place down water or lava in the same block space the block is in.
3. A breaking sound, and particles should result.
This bug is probably related to the bug of placing fluids inside each other.
BE SURE TO READ THE BUG VERY VERY CAREFULLY.
This bug may be related to
Steps to reproduce:
1. Place down a non-solid block that is destroyed by fluids (ex. levers).
2. Place down water or lava in the same block space the block is in.
3. A breaking sound, and particles should result.
This bug is probably related to the bug of placing fluids inside each other.
BE SURE TO READ THE BUG VERY VERY CAREFULLY.
This bug is the NOT fix of
MC-18342. ITS ABOUT THE PARTICLES AND THE SOUND EFFECT!
MC-18342IS ABOUT THE AN ITEM!Steps to reproduce:
1. Place down a non-solid block that is destroyed by fluids (ex. levers).
2. Place down water or lava in the same block space the block is in.
3. A breaking sound, and particles should result.
This bug is probably related to the bug of placing fluids inside each other.
BE SURE TO READ THE BUG VERY VERY CAREFULLY.
This bug is the NOT fix of
MC-18342. ITS ABOUT THE PARTICLES AND THE SOUND EFFECT!
MC-18342IS ABOUT THE AN ITEM!Steps to reproduce:
1. Place down a non-solid block that is destroyed by fluids (ex. levers).
2. Place down water or lava in the same block space the block is in.
3. A breaking sound, and particles should result.
This bug is probably related to the bug of placing fluids inside each other.
BE SURE TO READ THE BUG VERY VERY CAREFULLY.
This bug is the NOT fix of
MC-18342. ITS ABOUT THE PARTICLES AND THE SOUND EFFECT!
MC-18342IS ABOUT THE AN ITEM!This bug is definitely not intended since fluids flowing into the non-solid block that is destroyed by fluids results in no sound effect and no particles.
This bug is when you placeSteps to reproduce:
1. Place down a non-solid block that is destroyed by fluids (ex. levers).
2. Place down water or lava in the same block space the block is in.
3. A breaking sound, and particles should result.
This bug is probably related to the bug of placing fluids inside each other.
Breaking non-blocks that are destroyed by fluids besides air (ex. levers), by placing a fluid in the same block space, a breakingsound, and particles result unlike when fluids flow into the non-solid block that's destroyed by fluids.
BE SURE TO READ THE BUG VERY VERY CAREFULLY.
This bug is the NOT fix of
MC-18342. ITS ABOUT THE PARTICLES AND THE SOUND EFFECT!
MC-18342IS ABOUT THE AN ITEM!This bug is definitely not intended since fluids flowing into the non-solid block that is destroyed by fluids results in no sound effect and no particles.
This bug is when you placeSteps to reproduce:
1. Place down a non-solid block that is destroyed by fluids (ex. levers).
2. Place down water or lava in the same block space the block is in.
3. A breaking sound, and particles should result.
This bug is probably related to the bug of placing fluids inside each other.
BE SURE TO READ THE BUG VERY VERY CAREFULLY.
This bug is the *NOT fix of
MC-18342. ITS ABOUT THE PARTICLES AND THE SOUND EFFECT!*
MC-18342IS ABOUT THE AN ITEM!This bug is definitely not intended since fluids flowing into the non-solid block that is destroyed by fluids results in no sound effect and no particles.
This bug is when you place fluids in the same block space as a not-block that is destroyed by water besides air, a break sound, and particles result.Steps to reproduce:
1. Place down a non-solid block that is destroyed by fluids (ex. levers).
2. Place down water or lava in the same block space the block is in.
3. A breaking sound, and particles should result.
This bug is probably related to the bug of placing fluids inside each other.
BE SURE TO READ THE BUG VERY VERY CAREFULLY.
This bug is the *NOT fix of
MC-18342. ITS ABOUT THE PARTICLES AND THE SOUND EFFECT!*
MC-18342IS ABOUT THE AN ITEM!This bug is definitely not intended since fluids flowing into the non-solid block that is destroyed by fluids results in no sound effect and no particles.
This bug is when you place fluids in the same block space as a not-block that is destroyed by water besides air, a break sound, and particles result.Steps to reproduce:
1. Place down a non-solid block that is destroyed by fluids (ex. levers).
2. Place down water or lava in the same block space the block is in.
3. A breaking sound, and particles should result.
This bug is probably related to the bug of placing fluids inside each other.
BE SURE TO READ THE BUG VERY VERY CAREFULLY.
This bug is the NOT fix of
MC-18342. ITS ABOUT THE PARTICLES AND THE SOUND EFFECT!
MC-18342IS ABOUT THE AN ITEM!This bug is definitely not intended since fluids flowing into the non-solid block that is destroyed by fluids results in no sound effect and no particles.
This bug is when you place fluids in the same block space as a not-block that is destroyed by water besides air, a break sound, and particles result.Steps to reproduce:
1. Place down a non-solid block that is destroyed by fluids (ex. levers).
2. Place down water or lava in the same block space the block is in.
3. A breaking sound, and particles should result.
This bug is probably related to the bug of placing fluids inside each other.
Why would that be true?
BE SURE TO READ THE BUG VERY VERY CAREFULLY.
This bug is the NOT fix of
MC-18342. ITS ABOUT THE PARTICLES AND THE SOUND EFFECT!
MC-18342IS ABOUTTHEAN ITEM!This bug is definitely not intended since fluids flowing into the non-solid block that is destroyed by fluids results in no sound effect and no particles.
This bug is when you place fluids in the same block space as a not-block that is destroyed by water besides air, a break sound, and particles result.Steps to reproduce:
1. Place down a non-solid block that is destroyed by fluids (ex. levers).
2. Place down water or lava in the same block space the block is in.
3. A breaking sound, and particles should result.
This bug is probably related to the bug of placing fluids inside each other.
BE SURE TO READ THE BUG VERY VERY CAREFULLY.
This bug is the NOT the fix of
MC-18342. ITS ABOUT THE PARTICLES AND THE SOUND EFFECT!
MC-18342IS ABOUT AN ITEM!This bug is definitely not intended since fluids flowing into the non-solid block that is destroyed by fluids results in no sound effect and no particles.
This bug is when you place fluids in the same block space as a not-block that is destroyed by water besides air, a break sound, and particles result.Steps to reproduce:
1. Place down a non-solid block that is destroyed by fluids (ex. levers).
2. Place down water or lava in the same block space the block is in.
3. A breaking sound, and particles should result.
This bug is probably related to the bug of placing fluids inside each other.
is duplicated by
![[Bot] Arisa](../../../data/assets/gravatar/mustek2.png){kind=small}
Breakingnon-blocksthat are destroyed by fluids besides air (ex. levers), by placing a fluid in the same block space, a break sound, and particles result unlike when fluids flow into the non-solid block that's destroyed by fluids.Breaking blocks by placing water at their position shows breaking particles and plays breaking sound while them being broken by flowing water does not
BE SURE TO READ THE BUG VERY VERY CAREFULLY.
This bug is the NOT the fix of
MC-18342. ITS ABOUT THE PARTICLES AND THE SOUND EFFECT!
MC-18342IS ABOUT AN ITEM!This bug is definitely not intended since fluids flowing into the non-solid block that is destroyed by fluids results in no sound effect and no particles.
This bug is when you place fluids in the same block space as a not-block that is destroyed by water besides air, a break sound, and particles result.Steps to reproduce:
1. Place down a non-solid block that is destroyed by fluids (ex. levers).
2. Place down water or lava in the same block space the block is in.
3. A breaking sound, and particles should result.
This bug is probably related to the bug of placing fluids inside each other.
The bug
Non-solid blocks like levers or flower pots create breaking particles and play the breaking sound when you replace them with a fluid, but if they are replaced by the fluid which flows into the position they are at this does not happen.
Steps to reproduce
- Place down a non-solid block which is destroyed by fluids (ex. levers)
- Place down water or lava in the same block space the block is in
→ You will see breaking particles and hear the breaking sound- Place another non-solid block which is destroyed by fluids next to the fluid source
→ You will see that the block is destroyed but there are not breaking particles nor a breaking sound
Breaking blocks by placingwaterat their position shows breaking particles and plays breaking sound while them being broken by flowingwaterdoes notBreaking blocks by placing a fluid at their position shows breaking particles and plays breaking sound while them being broken by flowing fluid does not
The bug
Non-solid blocks like levers or flower pots create breaking particles and play the breaking sound when you replace them with a fluid, but if they are replaced by the fluid which flows into the position they are at this does not happen.
Steps to reproduce
- Place down a non-solid block which is destroyed by fluids (ex. levers)
- Place down water or lava in the same block space the block is in
→ You will see breaking particles and hear the breaking sound- Place another non-solid block which is destroyed by fluids next to the fluid source
→ You will see that the block is destroyed but there are not breaking particles nor a breaking soundExpected behavior
The expected behavior would probably be that there are no breaking particles or a breaking sound.
![[Mod] Neko](../../../data/avatars/users/92901.png){kind=small}
![[Mod] Michael Wobst](../../../data/avatars/users/37868.png){kind=small}
Irrelevant
![[Mod] Pokechu22](../../../data/avatars/users/92931.png){kind=small}
The bug
Non-solid blocks like levers or flower pots create breaking particles and play the breaking sound when you replace them with a fluid, but if they are replaced by the fluid which flows into the position they are at this does not happen.
Stepsto reproduce
- Place down a non-solid block which is destroyed by fluids (ex. levers)
- Place down water or lava in the same block space the block is in
→ You will see breaking particles and hear the breaking sound- Place another non-solid block which is destroyed by fluids next to the fluid source
→ You will see that the block is destroyed but there are not breaking particles nor a breaking soundExpected behavior
The expected behavior would probably be that there are no breaking particles or a breaking sound.
The bug
Non-solid blocks like levers or flower pots create breaking particles and play the breaking sound when you replace them with a fluid, but if they are replaced by the fluid which flows into the position they are at this does not happen.
How to reproduce
- Place down a non-solid block which is destroyed by fluids (ex. levers)
- Place down water or lava in the same block space the block is in
→ You will see breaking particles and hear the breaking sound- Place another non-solid block which is destroyed by fluids next to the fluid source
→ You will see that the block is destroyed but there are not breaking particles nor a breaking soundExpected behavior
The expected behavior would probably be that there are no breaking particles or a breaking sound.
The bug
Non-solid blocks like levers or flower pots create breaking particles and play the breaking sound when you replace them with a fluid, but if they are replaced by the fluid which flows into the position they are at this does not happen.
How to reproduce
- Place down a non-solid block which is destroyed by fluids (ex. levers)
- Place down water or lava in the same block space the block is in
→ You will see breaking particles and hear the breaking sound- Place another non-solid block which is destroyed by fluids next to the fluid source
→ You will see that the block is destroyed but there are not breaking particles nor a breaking soundExpected behavior
The expected behavior would probably be that there are no breaking particles or a breaking sound.
The bug
Non-solid blocks like levers or flower pots create breaking particles and play the breaking sound when you replace them with a fluid, but if they are replaced by the fluid which flows into the position they are at this does not happen.
How to reproduce
- Place down a non-solid block which is destroyed by fluids (ex. levers)
- Place down water or lava in the same block space the block is in
→ You will see breaking particles and hear the breaking sound- Place another non-solid block which is destroyed by fluids next to the fluid source
→ You will see that the block is destroyed but there are not breaking particles nor a breaking soundExpected behavior
The expected behavior would be that breaking particles would always be produced; see
MC-122251.
![[Mojang] Nathan Adams](../../../data/assets/gravatar/dinnerbone.png){kind=small}
[Missing particles] Breaking blocks by placing a fluid at their position shows breaking particles and plays breaking sound while them being broken by flowing fluid does not
[Missing particles/Missing sounds] Breaking blocks by placing a fluid at their position shows breaking particles and plays breaking sound while them being broken by flowing fluid does not
[Missing particles/Missing sounds]Breaking blocks by placing a fluid at their position shows breaking particles and plays breaking sound while them being broken by flowing fluid does not
[Add to categories Particles and Sound then delete this line]
The bug
Non-solid blocks like levers or flower pots create breaking particles and play the breaking sound when you replace them with a fluid, but if they are replaced by the fluid which flows into the position they are at this does not happen.
How to reproduce
- Place down a non-solid block which is destroyed by fluids (ex. levers)
- Place down water or lava in the same block space the block is in
→ You will see breaking particles and hear the breaking sound- Place another non-solid block which is destroyed by fluids next to the fluid source
→ You will see that the block is destroyed but there are not breaking particles nor a breaking soundExpected behavior
The expected behavior would be that breaking particles would always be produced; see
MC-122251.
relates to
[Add to categories Particles and Sound then delete this line]
The bug
Non-solid blocks like levers or flower pots create breaking particles and play the breaking sound when you replace them with a fluid, but if they are replaced by the fluid which flows into the position they are at this does not happen.
How to reproduce
- Place down a non-solid block which is destroyed by fluids (ex. levers)
- Place down water or lava in the same block space the block is in
→ You will see breaking particles and hear the breaking sound- Place another non-solid block which is destroyed by fluids next to the fluid source
→ You will see that the block is destroyed but there are not breaking particles nor a breaking soundExpected behavior
The expected behavior would be that breaking particles would always be produced; see
MC-122251.
![[Mod] Chandler](../../../data/assets/gravatar/triwonder81.png){kind=small}
![[Helper] Johnibur](../../../data/avatars/users/28381.png){kind=small}
relates to
![[Mojang] Adrian Östergård](../../../data/assets/gravatar/nighter.jpeg){kind=small}
![[Helper] gaspoweredpick](../../../data/avatars/users/80904.png){kind=small}
![[Mod] violine1101](../../../data/avatars/users/92858.png){kind=small}
is duplicated by
![[Bot] Arisa](../../../data/avatars/users/43007.png){kind=small}
![[Mod] markderickson](../../../data/avatars/users/18946.svg){kind=small}
Breaking blocks by placingafluidat their position shows breakingparticlesand playsbreaking soundwhile them being broken by flowing fluid does notBlocks broken by flowing fluids do not produce particles or make breaking sounds
The bug
Non-solid blocks like levers or flower pots create breaking particles and playthebreakingsound when you replace them with a fluid, but if they are replaced by the fluid which flows into the position they are at this does not happen.How to reproduce
- Place down a non-solid block which is destroyed by fluids (ex. levers)
- Place down water or lava in the same block space the block is in
→ You will see breaking particles and hear the breaking sound- Place another non-solid block which is destroyed by fluids next to the fluid source
→ You will see that the block is destroyed but there are not breaking particles nor a breaking soundExpected behavior
The expected behavior would be that breaking particles would always be produced; see
MC-122251.The bug
When a block which can be destroyed via a flowing liquid, such as grass, torches or flowers, is destroyed by a fluid, absolutely no sound is produced, nor are any breaking particles shown. Contrast this with breaking those blocks directly, via removing a supporting block, or by placing the fluid source directly inside of that block: in all those cases, particles and a breaking sound are produced, as one would expect.
How to reproduce
- Place down a non-solid block which is destroyed by fluids (ex. levers)
- Place down water or lava in the same block space the block is in
→ You will see breaking particles and hear the breaking sound- Place another non-solid block which is destroyed by fluids next to the fluid source
→ You will see that the block is destroyed but there are not breaking particles nor a breaking soundExpected behavior
The expected behavior would be that breaking particles and sounds would always be produced; see
MC-122251.The expected behaviour can also be encountered in the since-discontinued Console Edition, which may also make this a parity issue. Example of this expected behaviour: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yxiKwynwE9U&t=58s
![[Mod] ampolive](../../../data/avatars/users/18949.svg){kind=small}
![[Mod] Avoma](../../../data/avatars/users/86198.png){kind=small}
![[Mojang] slicedlime](../../../data/assets/gravatar/slicedlime.jpeg){kind=small}
![[Mod] Jarl-Penguin](../../../data/avatars/users/92849.png){kind=small}
![[Mod] Torabi](../../../data/assets/gravatar/torabi.png){kind=small}
Similar to MC-25976.
The bug
When placing a solid block or armor stand into something like grass, no breaking particles for the replaced block are produced, and any potential item drops from said block will also be destroyed. This is inconsistent with placing a fluid in the same position (MC-25976) (may be difficult due to MC-130761), which does allow these to happen.
Fire is a rather unusual block in that while it can be broken like any other block can, the sound event used when it is broken is not the same as other sound events: the "fire extinguishing" sound only plays when the block is directly targeted and broken, and will never play when broken any other way.
Such other ways include when its supporting block is removed, when directly replaced by a placed fluid source (see also MC-25976, as all other fluid replacements would be expected to play a sound for every other block but do not, and replaced by blocks not making a sound is MC-136703), or replaced by another block via commands (MC-206473).
The expected behaviour would be that the fire extinguishing sound would play in all cases of a fire block being destroyed (with the exception of fire just burning out by itself, and potentially it burning its supporting block), as to be consistent with literally every other block in the game. It should also produce the smoke particles as well.
For a period of time, the wood sound was played in such cases, after which the wool sound was used. From 1.16 onwards, there is now silence.
It is also worth noting that particles using the fire textures would also be produced, specifically when replaced directly with a fluid. These were considered a bug and eventually removed.
MC-25976 is likely to be the bug causing this; I'd recommend trying to fix that one first to see if the issue resolved itself as a result.
Sculk sensors are intended to detect the breaking of blocks as valid vibrations. This works for manually broken blocks, however if a block is instead broken by a fluid flowing into its place, the block is destroyed without the sculk sensor picking up vibrations as a result.
The expected behaviour would be that the sculk sensor would in fact pick this up as a vibration, since a block is obviously being broken.
Thank you for your report!
We're tracking this issue in MC-25976, so this ticket is being resolved and linked as a duplicate.
If you would like to add a vote and any extra information to the main ticket it would be appreciated.
If you haven't already, you might like to make use of the search feature to see if the issue has already been mentioned.
Quick Links:
📓 Bug Tracker Guidelines – 💬 Community Support – 📧 Mojang Support
📓 Project Summary – ✍️ Feedback and Suggestions – 📖 Game Wiki
![[Mod] EVGENSYPERPRO](../../../data/avatars/users/92853.png){kind=small}
Summary:
Blocks broken by fluids (water/lava) do not produce particles or make breaking sounds.
In java, unlike bedrock, when placing lava / water in a block, for example with grass, particles and sound appear and the problem is only with flowing liquids MC-25976.
Steps to reproduce:
- Place the grass.
- Place water or lava in the same block space the grass is in.
- Place the grass.
- Place water or lava nearby.
Observed results:
Blocks broken by fluids do not produce particles or make breaking sounds.
Expected results:
Blocks broken by liquid (water or lava - flowing or directly placed) produce particles and make breaking sounds.
Screenshots:
Java
Intended. The fix of
MC-18342.You are not reading this bug correctly. The bug is that particles and a breaking sound results from placing water or lava in the same block as the non-solid block that is destroyed by water.
That is how Grum decided to fix
MC-18342. It is not up to either of us to decide what is intended, only Mojang.BE SURE TO READ THE BUG VERY VERY CAREFULLY.
This bug is the NOT fix of
MC-18342. ITS ABOUT THE PARTICLES AND THE SOUND EFFECT!MC-18342IS ABOUT THE AN ITEM!This bug is definitely not intended since fluids flowing into the non-solid block that is destroyed by fluids results in no sound effect and no particles.
This bug is when you place fluids in the same block space as a not-block that is destroyed by water besides air, a break sound, and particles result.
Seems to be fixed for 15w36c (and probably earlier). Now there are particles and the sound effect
Confirmed for 1.12.2; placing water in tall grass makes both particles and sound.
Affects 1.13-pre4
Confirmed for 1.13.1.
As per
MC-122251, the expected behaviour should be that particles and sounds should be created at all times.Affects 18w50a, can I request ownership of the ticket?
Confirmed/Reproduced in 20w29a.
Can confirm in 20w51a.
Can confirm in 21w05b.
Can confirm in 21w06a.
Can confirm in 21w07a.
Can confirm in 21w11a.
Can confirm in 21w14a.
Can confirm in 21w17a.
Can confirm in 1.17.
Can confirm in 1.17.1 Release Candidate 1.
Can confirm in 1.18.
Can confirm in 1.18.1.
Can confirm in 1.18.2 and 22w12a.
Can confirm in 1.19.
Can confirm in 1.19.2.
In 23w31a
In 1.20.2