Villages and witch huts sometimes don't generate properly
I created some super flat worlds and most of the time I found the villages in these conditions. Attention! Sometimes not all the villages have this bug.
The bug has been working from the snapshot 13w19a. Follow those steps to reproduce it:
- Create a world and join
- As soon as you see a village, leave the game.
- Quickly re-join the same world and the bug should work.
Linked Issues
is cloned by1
Importantis duplicated by26
MC-9014problems loading village in superflatDuplicateMC-9190Strange village generationDuplicateMC-11267Server World Generator BugDuplicateMC-12737Odd Villager House GenerationDuplicateMC-14229Damaged Villages after loading with 13w16a and returning back to 1.5.1DuplicateMC-21239Villages appear strange!DuplicateMC-28475Double buildings in superflat, and half buildings on top of some buildings without nearby abandoned mineshaft: How do you upload pics on mac?DuplicateMC-31023Village Houses in fragmentsDuplicateMC-37767Village GenerationDuplicateMC-75189Blocks completely missingDuplicateMC-87260Half-Generated VillagesDuplicateMC-92751without chest and matches villages.DuplicateMC-94695Strange Village Generation (Half-Houses and -Gardens)DuplicateMC-98431Partial generation of end cities on realms.DuplicateMC-103528village generation is brokenDuplicateMC-104564villageDuplicateMC-107718Village Generation BugDuplicateMC-108171Village Generation GlitchDuplicateMC-12580618w07c Village generation in desert biomes brokenDuplicateMC-126446Latest snapshot village house bug!DuplicateMC-127790Fix the bug with villager garden and library house (roof spawning) (undigested).DuplicateMC-139720Village houses are double-stacked on SuperFlatDuplicateMC-140221Houses in villages are all stacked up upon each other.DuplicateMC-146177Village Generation IssueDuplicateMC-2961Some villages are generating wrong for no reasonDuplicateMC-4106generating flat world bugDuplicaterelates to8
MC-55596Some chunks in the same world seed seem to have different versions
NormalMC-87522Villages can generate on void
LowMC-84800Reloading a world during terrain generation causes some parts of the world to be generated in stripped parts (snow, trees, etc.)Awaiting ResponseMC-5737World generating in stripped partsFixedMC-7294Structures can be generated with different parts at different heightInvalidMC-96998End Cities / Woodland Mansions don't generate completely when interrupting generationCannot ReproduceMC-125615Some end cities don't generate completelyFixedMC-139526Igloo generated in a stackCannot ReproduceAttachments21
Created Issue:
The houses of the villages are divided into several parts.
I created some worlds super flat and most of the time I found the villages in these conditions. Attention! Sometimes not all the villages have this bug.
Attachments11
2013-05-17_16.58.42.png
I created some worlds super flat and most of the time I found the villages in these conditions. Attention! Sometimes not all the villages have this bug.
These are the seed and the coordinates of both worlds with this bug.
I created some worlds super flat and most of the time I found the villages in these conditions. Attention! Sometimes not all the villages have this bug.
These are the seed and the coordinates of both worlds with this bug.
Seed1:-8464678981462005138
x: -187
y: 4
z: -260
Seed2:-5599721526539106282
x: 1205
y: 4
z: -982
I created some worlds super flat and most of the time I found the villages in these conditions. Attention! Sometimes not all the villages have this bug.
These are the seed and the coordinates of both worlds with this bug.
Seed1:-8464678981462005138
x: -187
y: 4
z: -260
Seed2:-5599721526539106282
x: 1205
y: 4
z: -982I created some worlds super flat and most of the time I found the villages in these conditions. Attention! Sometimes not all the villages have this bug.
The bug has come back always in the snapshot 13w19a. here's how it happened.
1) I created the world
2) As soon as I saw the village, I am out of the world
3) as soon as I came out, I'm backyou can see the seed in the screenshots (the last two)
I think it was an occasional bug, hopefully not happen again more
I created some worlds super flat and most of the time I found the villages in these conditions.Attention! Sometimes not all the villages have this bug.
The bug has come back always in the snapshot 13w19a. here's how it happened.
1) I created the world
2) As soon as I saw the village, I am out of the world
3) as soon as I came out, I'm backyou can see the seed in the screenshots (the last two)
+ Watch the video to understand how to reproduce the bug. + http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3yJ6gaO-hQc
I created some worlds super flat and most of the time I found the villages in these conditions. Attention! Sometimes not all the villages have this bug.
The bug has come back always in the snapshot 13w19a. here's how it happened.
1) I created the world
2) As soon as I saw the village, I am out of the world
3) as soon as I came out, I'm backyou can see the seed in the screenshots (the last two)
+Watch the video to understand how to reproduce the bug.+http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3yJ6gaO-hQc
I created some worlds super flat and most of the time I found the villages in these conditions. Attention! Sometimes not all the villages have this bug.
The bug has come back always in the snapshot 13w19a. here's how it happened.
1) I created the world
2) As soon as I saw the village, I am out of the world
3) as soon as I came out, I'm backyou can see the seed in the screenshots (the last two)
Watch the video to understand how to reproduce the bug. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3yJ6gaO-hQc
I created some worlds super flat and most of the time I found the villages in these conditions. Attention! Sometimes not all the villages have this bug.
The bug has come back always in the snapshot 13w19a. here's how it happened.
1) I created the world
2) As soon as I saw the village, I am out of the world
3) as soon as I came out, I'm backyou can see the seed in the screenshots (the last two)
Watch the video to understand how to reproduce the bug. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3yJ6gaO-hQc (sorry for the poor quality of the video)
I created some worlds super flat and most of the time I found the villages in these conditions. Attention! Sometimes not all the villages have this bug.
The bug has come back always in the snapshot 13w19a. here's how it happened.
1) I created the world
2) As soon as I saw the village, I am out of the world
3) as soon as I came out, I'm backyou can see the seed in the screenshots (the last two)
Watch the video to understand how to reproduce the bug. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3yJ6gaO-hQc (sorry for the poor quality of the video)
I created some worlds super flat and most of the time I found the villages in these conditions. Attention! Sometimes not all the villages have this bug.
The bug has come back always in the snapshot 13w19a. here's how it happened.
1) I created the world
2) As soon as I saw the village, I am out of the world
3) as soon as I came out, I'm backyou can see the seed in the screenshots (the last two)
The houses of the villages are divided into several parts.Reloading a world while generating a new village messes up the village generation
Reloading a world while generatinga new villagemesses up thevillage generationReloading a world while generating structures messes up the structure generation
Reloading a worldwhile generating structures messes up the structure generationReloading a world during terrain generation causes some parts of the world to be generated in stripped parts
relates to
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
relates to
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
Watch the video to understand how to reproduce the bug.http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3yJ6gaO-hQc(sorry for the poor quality of the video)
I created some worlds super flat and most of the time I found the villages in these conditions.Attention! Sometimes not all the villages have this bug.
The bug has come back always in the snapshot 13w19a. here's how it happened.
1) I created the world
2) As soon as I saw the village, I am out of the world
3) as soon as I came out, I'm backI created some worlds super flat and most of the time I found the villages in these conditions. Attention! Sometimes not all the villages have this bug.
The bug has come back always in the snapshot 13w19a. here's how it happened.
1) I created the world
2) As soon as I saw the village, I am out of the world
3) as soon as I came out, I'm backEDIT: The video i provided was removed from Youtube, so i removed it from the description. You can reproduce the bug following the step
I created some worlds super flat and most of the time I found the villages in these conditions. Attention! Sometimes not all the villages have this bug.
The bug has come back always in the snapshot 13w19a. here's how it happened.
1) I created the world
2) As soon as I saw the village, I am out of the world
3) as soon as I came out, I'm backEDIT: The video
iprovided was removed from Youtube, soiremoved it from the description. You can reproduce the bug following the stepI created some worlds super flat and most of the time I found the villages in these conditions. Attention! Sometimes not all the villages have this bug.
The bug has come back always in the snapshot 13w19a. here's how it happened.
1) I created the world
2) As soon as I saw the village, I am out of the world
3) as soon as I came out, I'm backEDIT: The video I provided was removed from Youtube, so I removed it from the description. You can reproduce the bug following the step.
is duplicated by
![[Mod] CubeTheThird](../../../data/assets/gravatar/cubethethird.jpeg){kind=small}
relates to
is duplicated by
relates to
![[Mod] Ezekiel (ezfe)](../../../data/assets/gravatar/ezekielelin.jpeg){kind=small}
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
I created some
worldssuper flat and most of the time I found the villages in these conditions. Attention! Sometimes not all the villages have this bug.
The bug hascome back always inthe snapshot 13w19a.here's how it happened.
1) I created the world
2) As soon asI saw thevillage,I am out of the world
3)as soon as I came out, I'm backEDIT: The video I provided was removed from Youtube, so I removed it from the description. You can reproduce the bug following the step.
I created some super flat worlds and most of the time I found the villages in these conditions. Attention! Sometimes not all the villages have this bug.
The bug has been working from the snapshot 13w19a. follow those steps to reproduce it.
1) I created the world and I joined it
2) As soon as you see a village, leave the game.
3) Quickly re-join the same world and the bug should work.EDIT: The video I provided was removed from Youtube, so I removed it from the description. You can reproduce the bug following the step.
EDIT 2: I stopped playing Minecraft for a while but it seems like the bug is still working like the first time I encountered it in my game.
Corrected some grammar errors in the description.
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
![[Mod] Les3awe](../../../data/avatars/users/79847.png){kind=small}
is duplicated by
I created some super flat worlds and most of the time I found the villages in these conditions. Attention! Sometimes not all the villages have this bug.
The bug has been working from the snapshot 13w19a. follow those steps to reproduce it.
1) I created the world and I joined it
2) As soon as you see a village, leave the game.
3) Quickly re-join the same world and the bug should work.EDIT: The video I provided was removed from Youtube, so I removed it from the description. You can reproduce the bug following the step.
EDIT 2: I stopped playing Minecraft for a while but it seems like the bug is still working like the first time I encountered it in my game.
Corrected some grammar errors in the description.
I created some super flat worlds and most of the time I found the villages in these conditions. Attention! Sometimes not all the villages have this bug.
The bug has been working from the snapshot 13w19a. follow those steps to reproduce it.
1) I created the world and I joined it
2) As soon as you see a village, leave the game.
3) Quickly re-join the same world and the bug should work.EDIT: The video I provided was removed from Youtube, so I removed it from the description. You can reproduce the bug following the step.
EDIT 2: I stopped playing Minecraft for a while but it seems like the bug is still working like the first time I encountered it in my game.
Corrected some grammar errors in the description.
Reloading a world during terrain generation causes some parts of the world to be generated in stripped partsStructures sometimes don't generate completely.
relates to
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
relates to
Structures sometimes don't generatecompletely.Villages sometimes don't generate Properly.
relates to
is duplicated by
![[Mod] Neko](../../../data/avatars/users/92901.png){kind=small}
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
![[Mod] Michael Wobst](../../../data/avatars/users/37868.png){kind=small}
I created some super flat worlds and most of the time I found the villages in these conditions. Attention! Sometimes not all the villages have this bug.
The bug has been working from the snapshot 13w19a. follow those steps to reproduce it.
1) I created the world and I joined it
2) As soon as you see a village, leave the game.
3) Quickly re-join the same world and the bug should work.EDIT: The video I provided was removed from Youtube, so I removed it from the description. You can reproduce the bug following the step.
EDIT2: I stopped playing Minecraft for a while but it seems like the bug is still working like the first time I encountered it in my game.
Corrected some grammar errors in the description.I created some super flat worlds and most of the time I found the villages in these conditions. Attention! Sometimes not all the villages have this bug.
The bug has been working from the snapshot 13w19a. Follow those steps to reproduce it:
- I created the world and I joined it
- As soon as you see a village, leave the game.
- Quickly re-join the same world and the bug should work.
EDIT: The video I provided was removed from Youtube, so I removed it from the description. You can reproduce the bug following the step.
EDIT 2: I stopped playing Minecraft for a while but it seems like the bug is still working like the first time I encountered it in my game.
I created some super flat worlds and most of the time I found the villages in these conditions. Attention! Sometimes not all the villages have this bug.
The bug has been working from the snapshot 13w19a. Follow those steps to reproduce it:
- I created the world and I joined it
- As soon as you see a village, leave the game.
- Quickly re-join the same world and the bug should work.
EDIT: The video I provided was removed from Youtube, so I removed it from the description. You can reproduce the bug following the step.
EDIT 2: I stopped playing Minecraft for a while but it seems like the bug is still working like the first time I encountered it in my game.
Villages sometimes don't generateProperly.Villages sometimes don't generate properly
I created some super flat worlds and most of the time I found the villages in these conditions. Attention! Sometimes not all the villages have this bug.
The bug has been working from the snapshot 13w19a. Follow those steps to reproduce it:
I created theworld andIjoined it- As soon as you see a village, leave the game.
- Quickly re-join the same world and the bug should work.
I created some super flat worlds and most of the time I found the villages in these conditions. Attention! Sometimes not all the villages have this bug.
The bug has been working from the snapshot 13w19a. Follow those steps to reproduce it:
- Create a world and join
- As soon as you see a village, leave the game.
- Quickly re-join the same world and the bug should work.
![[Mod] tryashtar](../../../data/avatars/users/41963.png){kind=small}
Villages and witch huts sometimes don't generate properly
is cloned by
![[Mod] bemoty](../../../data/avatars/users/50554.png){kind=small}
relates to
is duplicated by
is duplicated by
relates to
is duplicated by
relates to
is duplicated by
![[Mod] Asteraoth](../../../data/avatars/users/92886.png){kind=small}
is duplicated by
![[Mod] violine1101](../../../data/avatars/users/92858.png){kind=small}
is duplicated by
![[Mojang] Nathan Adams](../../../data/assets/gravatar/dinnerbone.png){kind=small}
I was able to reproduce the issue by reloading the world during terrain generation. So please vote for MC-15820 since it has different reproduction steps.
This ticket has been marked as a duplicate of MC-15820, in favor of the better description/information provided.
This ticket has been marked as a duplicate of MC-15820, in favor of the better description/information provided.
This is not a duplicate of MC-15820
When you create a world it will be like this
Can not confirm
However, it might be MC-15820
It is MC-15820. Thanks!
These spots were supposed to be trees, but they didn't generate properly. In that case, it might be MC-15820
The Zombie could've come out of the roofed forest as it's possible to be dark enought to allow spawning other thick layer of leaves.
MC-15820
Please use search function.
Still a duplicate of MC-15820.
Tried 5 times to recreate your issue, got always the the wall with more coal blocks.
Always waited after initial spawning until the number of chunk updates was going against zero before TP'ing to the specified coordinates.
Oh, allright then, but shouldn't we at least update issue MC-15820? Because I am not getting stripes, even if the cause is the same. I think it changed from stripe generating to this, making this issue more actual than the other.
But I'll leave that decision to you.
Firstly I should say I have opened this bug before a few days and years ago. With all due respect, I'm requesting moderator Kumasasa to leave this one to another mod, because I'd like a second opinion. Contrary to what was thought before:
- Even when standing around for ten minutes to wait till there are 0 chunk updates AND when standing still every 100 blocks, the world still generates differently at times. So it's not a duplicate of
MC-15820
-It is also not a duplicate of MC-15820 because the world does not generate in stripes at all. That bug was probably fixed long ago. This is a different issue, I swear.
But because there was much confusion on how to replicate the bug, it was eventually closed by the mods. Now I have a quick way to replicate it which is described at the end. I'm 100% positive this is a (minor) bug, so my request is to take it seriously!
A seed is supposed to generate exact the same world on all PC's. But some world chunks seem to have more versions. So most of the world is the same, but in 50% of all instances the seed is used to generate a new world, the seed is different. This is visible in the 2 screenshots I uploaded. There are two versions of this wall: one with coal in it, one with far less coal in it.
I discovered it this way: I was playing along with an LPer with the seed "PythonGB LP World". The world was the same, but upon seeing this wall, he had the version with many coal in it, I had just one coal spot. When playing along further, there were more instances (differently placed trees, pools, landscaping). This is kind of frustrating because when an LPer discoveres for instance a diamond chunk, it may not be there in my world. This happens with every seed. So every seed has some differently generated chunks.
How to replicate this:
1. Make a world (use the seed "PythonGB LP world" or "1862394111" for verification)
2. Go to the coördinates specified on the screen (make sure the world is loaded properly first just to make sure)
3. Observe the wall
4. Recreate the world, like ten times
5. Around 50% of the time, the wall looks different. This affects some other chunks as well and affects every seed.
Mr. Kumasasa tried this 5 times and every time he got one version. This is why I'm requesting a second opinion. I tried this at two PC's, both fast enough to run the game. If a second mod also cannot replicate this or says it's some duplicate, then I will give up on this.
This will work with every world and every seed, but you'll need to find a place that is "sensitive" to it. Some chunks always generate the same, like they're supposed to.
I didn't quit and reload during playing,
50% of the time (may be more or less, it's based on chance), the wall will be different. So a seed seems to have at least two versions of some chunks.
The terrain generation itself isn't cut off, only the trees are cut off. That's why I think this is a dupe of MC-15820.
This issue may be duplicates MC-15820
This issue duplicates MC-15820.
Pretty sure this is MC-15820
It's not MC-15820, the cause is different.
Here's another reproduction case that proves it's a different issue:
- Create a world.
- Go find some end cities.
- Go back to the Overworld.
- Close the world.
- Delete the DIM1 folder from the save, to reset the end. Do not delete EndCity.dat.
- Go back to the End and see that none of the cities you previously found generate.
- Close the world.
- Delete the DIM1 folder from the save, to reset the end, and also delete EndCity.dat this time.
- Go back to the End and see that the cities you previously found generate again.
MC-15820 seems to be about (in MCP terms) the whole IChunkGenerator.populate() method not being called correctly. In this bug, populate() being called but MapGenEndCity.generateStructure() is deciding not to do its thing, because when the city data is loaded from EndCity.dat the MapGenEndCity.Start.isSizeable field isn't restored properly.
If I mod MapGenEndCity.Start to set this.isSizeable = true when loading the city data from EndCity.dat, I can no longer reproduce the bug with either method.
![[Helper] gaspoweredpick](../../../data/avatars/users/80904.png){kind=small}
I still confirm this NOT duplicate of MC-15820 because with villages it DOESN'T always happen, and with end cities it ALWAYS happens. I LOOKED at the screenshots, End cities aren't stacking up like the buildings in the villages, and i noticed that only the rendered chunks will spawn end city pieces, the village bug is different because the chunk bugging is more random. I generously gave screenshots to people with bad imaginations. SIMPLE PROOF: try telling the difference between the chunk generation screenshots on this bug and MC-15820 and double check the difference between them, if you cant see any difference (other than the village and end city being different generated structures) keep in note that the village probably glitches out the unseen chunks, while the end city totally deletes unseen chunks and doesn't stack buildings on top of each other. if you cant tell the difference then you probably have a tumor!
IM SERIOUS!!!
I am deeply sorry about that, I was pretty grumpy when this ticket was resolved as a duplicate and i promise i wont act grumpy on the internet again. (but i still don't think this is a duplicate of MC-15820) Could you please specifically tell me why this is resolved as "Duplicate"?
Because both villages and end cities are structures, there are more structures with this kind of issues, and seperate tickets for what is essencially the same problem is not useful.
One thing about your screenshots, The parts missing also occures with villages like shown in MC-15820.
Thanks, I don't think I need to give out any more info about this ticket, I pretty much typed all the info I could possibly type, and i am glad the bug is now related to MC-15820 rather than duplicate, it just seemed as wrong as "pigs eating bacon" in many ways. I was also furious when this happened but i decided to be forgiving. I now understand why it seemed to be a duplicate. i got all the screenshots within 30 minutes, i reproduced the bug on every screenshot proving it almost always works.
Thank you for your report!
However, this issue is a Duplicate of MC-15820.
If you have additional information, please add it to that report.
Please search before reporting, as it's likely that one exists already.
Quick Links:
📓 Issue Guidelines – 💬 Community Support – 📧 Customer Support – 📖 Game Wiki
Christian Krieg please comment your problem and seed in the section of the original ticket: MC-15820
Thank you for your report!
We're actually already tracking this issue at MC-15820, so we will resolve and link this ticket as a duplicate.
If you would like to add a vote and any extra information to the main ticket it would be appreciated.
If you haven't already, you might like to make use of the search feature to see if the issue has already been mentioned.
Please provide seed, preset string and coordinates.
Now I only found these two seed with the bug.
Seed1:-8464678981462005138
x: -187
y: 4
z: -260
Seed2:-5599721526539106282
x: 1205
y: 4
z: -982
I'm sure there are other worlds in these conditions in fact I'm looking for more.
Tried the seeds, neither worked. Are you sure you are playing vanilla Minecraft?
I'm playing Minecraft snapshot13w19a. Are you sure you are playing 13w19a?
I recreated the worlds mentioned in the description by placing the seed but the villages were normal. I decided to create other worlds without seed, and the bug has come back. I don't know what to say
Unable to reproduce either. Created both worlds in 13w19a, both look normal, see screenshots.
I'm doing a video that will make you understand how to reproduce the bug.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3yJ6gaO-hQc
This bug also affects other structures that are generated by the game
Confirmed by following the steps using the Seed #1.
Following the steps I was able to reproduce the occasional reports of
MC-5737still not beeing fixed. But these should be kept separated since they are reproduced differently.I was able to reproduce the bug of the world that is generated in stripped parts. See screenshots
This may not be relevant, but confirmed for versions dating as far back as 1.3.2 - I've had the bug in the past, but figured it was just a one-time quirk. Yes, I re-loaded the world as I was flying around (inevitably generating chunks just as I reloaded), and the glitch was permanent (whereas
MC-5737is apparently client-side with unglitched server-side terrain?).I even observed the chunks back then, curious as to why they hadn't populated - in MCedit, they were not marked for population, indicating that the game unmarked them without actually populating them. I've never heard of half-populated chunks, but the screenshots seem to contain doubly-populated chunks - it seems "unmark chunk for population" and "populate chunk" aren't atomic actions with regards to saving chunks, but "populate chunk" on its own is atomic with regards to chunk saving? I find it odd that both "accidentally leave unpopulated" and "accidentally populate twice" are possible, although that may not quite be what's happening in the screenshots.
The game generate the village twice.
Is this still a concern in the current Minecraft version? If so, please update the affected versions in order to best aid Mojang ensuring bugs are still valid in the latest releases/pre-releases.
(Automatic Message)
This bug also works in version 1.6
This bug still exists as of 14w02c, I have a screenshot of a very long strip of missing generation in the middle of a forest, can provide it if needed.
I was unable to reproduce the bug of the villages in 1.7.9. I came back in 1.6.4 version and it still works. This bug was fixed in 1.7 i think, because it is the first release where the bug doesn't works, after the 1.6.4
This bug still works. Some chunks get generated differently (are corrupted) when strolling to a place when chunks are still busy loading. I am not getting stripes, but I do get some chunks not appearing as they are supposed to. For example iof I let a world load perfectly a certain mountain may have a bunch of coal in it, but when I stroll to the location before the chunk is generated perfectly, the mountain wall looks different, with far less coal, flowers placed in another way and ponds that are different.
Seen this recently in 1.7.9 as we prepared our unpopulated chunks ready for the 1.8 update. Willing to share the map data if it’ll help devs look into this.
Confirmed for 1.8
Can confirm for 1.8.1
Cant really reproduce because I ran into a new area then quit then logged on later and saw this bug.
If you saw the bug, then what do you mean "Can't really reproduce"?
Good point
Confirmed for 1.8.3
Multiplayer
Confirmed for:
Confirmed for 15w46a
Confirmed for 1.7.10, but, unable to reproduce in 1.9.4. It is most likely lag based.
Ethan Cha 1.7.10 is outdated.
Please link to this comment by Anomie X for a way to reproduce this
Don't bother, the situation in
MC-96998does not have the same cause as this bug.Changing this to generated structures only and
MC-84800to chunk population (trees, snow, etc.).Torches sometimes stay in midair, or hang where they shouldn't
This is from 1.11, half of the end ship (with all the good stuff) didn't generate
End cities/Woodland mansions is
MC-96998this sometimes happens, its just a world generation glitch.
Seems to be fixed in 1.13.1, tried it by five different villages.
Please check if that's still an issue in the latest 1.14 development snapshot.